[Direct answer]If the biological father refuses to acknowledge the paternity relationship, a lawsuit to confirm the paternity relationship may be initiated, and the court will determine the blood relationship. Article 1073 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021) grants the right to request confirmation of paternity to a father or mother who have doubts about the paternity relationship and have legitimate reasons; Article 39 of the Interpretation of the Marriage and Family Code (I) stipulates that if the plaintiff provides necessary evidence and the defendant has no contrary evidence and refuses to take a paternity test, the court may determine that the request for confirmation is established. Common materials for proving the relationship include birth medical certificates, transfer records of child support, chat records admitting the blood relationship, and witness statements; after the confirmation is established, claims such as child support and inheritance will have the prerequisite of identity.

I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios

There are generally three types of situations where a biological father refuses to acknowledge paternity: evading responsibility during the relationship, refusing to sign the birth certificate after the child is born; after giving birth for many years, the biological father forms another family and denies the historical relationship to avoid child support; after the biological father's death, his spouse or other heirs deny the identity of the illegitimate child to block inheritance. The proof methods for the three types of situations are consistent, but the urgency of the problem is different — the first two types involve the cost of raising and educating the child during the growth period, while the third type is subject to the difficulty of preserving evidence after the inheritance begins. A common dilemma for mothers is that they have chat records and transfer receipts in their hands, but they don't know if these materials are sufficient, and they worry that suing might cause the other party to completely cut off contact.

There is another type of complex scenario: the biological father's attitude is inconsistent, sometimes providing support and sometimes denying paternity, with evidence that is intermittent and inconsistent. In such cases, continuous records are particularly important. Intermittent transfers and discontinuous chat records, when combined together, can actually reflect the fact that the biological father has long been aware of and actually fulfilled his obligation to support the child. The evidentiary value of this is higher than that of a single large-sum payment, and it is also more effective in countering the possibility of the father recanting his testimony later on.

The timing of litigation also requires planning. A lawsuit to confirm the parent-child relationship is a matter of identity verification, and the request for child support should be raised together with the confirmation of identity. It's more convenient to make claims during the minor's period. However, inheritance claims can only be raised after the death of the decedent and the commencement of the inheritance. Therefore, it's advisable to complete the identity verification as early as possible during the child's growth period, so as to reserve evidence and legal documents for possible future inheritance disputes. Although the mother holds many records, it's still recommended to back them up once every quarter to prevent irreversible losses caused by equipment failure.

II. Key points of contention

The first point of contention is the standard for necessary evidence: the court requires the plaintiff to first submit materials that are sufficient to enable the judge to form a preliminary belief in paternity. Birth medical certificates stating the father's information, continuous alimony transfers, and chat records with acknowledgments are all common options, but hearsay alone is not sufficient. The second point of contention is the application of the presumption of refusal to undergo DNA testing: if the defendant refuses to attend the sampling session upon the court's notice and there is no contrary evidence, the presumption rule is triggered; however, if the defendant has legitimate reasons for not being able to attend, the presumption does not apply. The third point of contention is the plaintiff's qualifications: minor children are sued by their mothers as legal representatives, while adult children can sue on their own to confirm their relationship with their biological fathers. The fourth point of contention is the scope of effectiveness after confirmation: the effective judgment can be used for household registration, correction of birth certificates, inheritance and alimony claims, and is equally binding on the heirs of the biological father.

In terms of the allocation of the burden of proof, the plaintiff bears the initial burden of proof regarding the blood relationship, and the defendant who denies it shall provide evidence to the contrary; when the evidence is equally persuasive, the court may initiate an appraisal on its own authority, and the party whose evidence-gathering efforts hinder the case shall bear the consequences thereof himself/herself.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm

The experience of Hengluo Lawyers in handling such cases lies in evidence layering and rhythm control. The first layer is identity traces: birth certificates, prenatal checkup records, household registration information, which prove the objective connection between the child and his parents before and after birth; the second layer is behavioral traces: transfer notes of the biological father's payment, insurance policies for the child, and photos and videos of visits and pickups; the third layer is linguistic traces: records of acknowledging the child on WeChat, call recordings, and witness testimonies admitting to relatives and friends. After the three layers of evidence are in place, the appraisal is just the final step - if the other party cooperates, it will be conclusive; if they refuse, the presumption rule will be triggered. Rhythm-wise, it is recommended to first send a written notice of default and then sue. Any statement admitting paternity in the reply to the notice is worth screenshotting and preserving; direct suing, although quick, may lead the other party to remain silent and miss the opportunity for low-cost evidence collection. The value of evidence layering is that even if no appraisal is ultimately needed, the first two layers of evidence are sufficient to support mediation or the other party's voluntary acknowledgement, reducing the conflict to a negotiation. Confirmation suits themselves do not involve property interests, so the cost burden is relatively light. The difficulty of most cases lies not in legal application, but in the patience and meticulousness of evidence organization. Another advantage of phased evidence collection is that when the dispute escalates to litigation, lawyers can directly prepare the list of evidence based on the existing layering, shortening the preparation period.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

The legal basis is Article 1071, Article 1073, and Article 1067 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021), as well as Article 39 of the Interpretation (I) of the Marriage and Family Chapter. The suggested handling process is as follows: First, organize all materials according to the timeline, and file the sections on birth and upbringing separately; Second, keep the original carriers of chat records and transfer receipts and have them notarized to prevent them from being inaccessible after device replacement; Third, issue a written reminder first to fix the admissive statements in the other party's response; Fourth, if no agreement is reached, file a lawsuit to confirm the paternity on behalf of the child in the court of the defendant's residence, and claim alimony in accordance with Article 1067 simultaneously or separately; Fifth, after the judgment takes effect, use the document to handle household registration, birth certificate correction, and subsequent inheritance matters. It is recommended to arrange the litigation materials according to three segments: identity, blood relationship, and upbringing, which is consistent with the judge's review habits and can accelerate the pace of case filing and trial. For the claim of inheritance shares and the connection with the document, reference can be made to the relevant provisions.\nInheritance of property, division of family assetsProfessional advice on the direction to take.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder

It's better to confirm paternity as early as possible. The younger the child is, the smoother the process of obtaining evidence and samples will be, and the more complete the claims for child support will be. Mothers who maintain communication with the biological father should consciously keep the original records of every transfer and conversation, and not wait until the other party blocks them or loses contact before thinking of backing them up. Stay vigilant against conditional negotiations that require paying first and then acknowledging paternity. Such promises lack legal protection. After the judgment takes effect, file it promptly, and keep at least two copies of the original judgment. Various procedures such as household registration, notarization, and inheritance may require the original documents. Litigation is not about ruining relationships. Only after confirming the judgment can the child's household registration, school enrollment, and medical insurance truly be initiated. If the other party voluntarily acknowledges paternity and supplements the birth certificate with the father's information, the household registration should also be updated simultaneously to avoid long-term discrepancies between written records and actual facts.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: If the man refuses to cooperate with the paternity test, can the parent-child relationship still be confirmed?

Yes. Article 39 of the Interpretation of the Marriage and Family Code (I) sets out a presumption rule: If the plaintiff sues to confirm the parent-child relationship and provides necessary evidence, and the other party refuses to undergo a paternity test without providing contrary evidence, the court may determine that the request for confirmation is established. Necessary evidence generally refers to materials such as birth medical certificates, records of continuous payment of child support, and chat records admitting blood kinship, which are sufficient to form a preliminary belief. In cases where the man refuses to provide evidence when all necessary materials are available, this may actually work against him. There are many cases where the court has made confirmation judgments based on this presumption rule. The presumption rule targets refusals without legitimate reasons. If there are genuine difficulties such as illness or overseas travel that prevent timely sampling, the party may explain the situation to the court and apply for a postponement, rather than giving up the lawsuit just because the other party temporarily avoids the process.

Q2: In a lawsuit to confirm the parent-child relationship, who can act as the plaintiff to represent the child in court?

The plaintiff is the child himself/herself. When a minor child files a lawsuit, the mother acts as the legal representative to carry out the litigation procedures on behalf of the child, and the mother does not need to file a lawsuit in her own name. Adult children can file a lawsuit on their own to confirm the parent-child relationship with their biological father. The legal representative shall carry out the litigation procedures in accordance with the principle of maximizing the interests of the child. When there is a conflict of interest between the child and the legal representative, the court may appoint another representative to ensure the fairness of the proceedings. The defendant is the biological father. If the biological father has died, the action for confirmation may be continued against his heirs, and the judgment will be effective against all the heirs. Generally, the case is filed with the court in the defendant's place of residence. If the defendant's place of residence is unknown, the court may proceed according to his/her habitual residence. If the defendant's whereabouts are unknown, the court may apply for service by public notice, and the proceedings will not be completely suspended because the defendant cannot be found.

Q3: Can alimony and inheritance shares be adjudicated together in the same case?

Alimony can be handled in the same lawsuit as the confirmation of the parent-child relationship. The confirmation of identity is a prerequisite for the request for alimony, and the court usually handles it jointly. The amount is determined in accordance with Article 1067 of the Civil Code, based on the income of the payer, the actual needs of the children, and the local living standards. It is generally paid monthly, and after the judgment takes effect, the payer can apply for enforcement. However, the inheritance share cannot be determined in advance: inheritance begins from the time of the decedent's death. During the stage when the biological father is still alive, only issues of identity and custody are resolved; after the inheritance begins, children born out of wedlock can participate in the division of the estate as first-order heirs based on the confirmation judgment, in accordance with Article 1127 of the Civil Code. These two stages should be planned separately, and it is not possible to expect one judgment to solve all problems at once.

Q4: Can transfer records and chat records be used as initial evidence of a parent-child relationship?

They can constitute necessary evidence. The transfer notes indicate the child support payments and the regular monthly payment habit, and the chat records contain content acknowledging the child and discussing custody arrangements. Combined with the timeline of their interactions and the pregnancy period, this is enough for the court to form a preliminary belief in the existence of a blood relationship, thereby triggering the presumption rule when the other party refuses to undergo DNA testing. When organizing the evidence, it should be arranged in chronological order and marked with the acquisition time, forming a continuous record of parental involvement, which is more capable of demonstrating the true state of the relationship than scattered individual materials. The original carriers must be preserved. If necessary, the original records can be retrieved from the platform, and the notarized certificate and the original carriers should be submitted together. Replacing the phone or uninstalling the software may make it impossible to recover the evidence. A single ambiguous chat or an ordinary transfer alone has limited probative value. The materials should be organized into a systematic framework.

Q5: After the parent-child relationship is confirmed, how should the household registration and school records be changed?

Apply to the public security organ with the effective judgment or judicial appraisal opinion: If the father's information on the birth medical certificate is missing or incorrect, first apply to the original issuing agency for a replacement or supplementary issuance, and then go to the police station to handle the birth registration or household registration change; if the child's previous household registration was with the mother, they can apply for household registration transfer to the father's household under the household registration transfer regulations. For inter-provincial transfers, follow the transfer regulations of the receiving area to handle the transfer approval and transfer procedures. The school enrollment information will be updated with the household registration information. The guardian should take the household registration booklet to the school's enrollment management department to apply for changes. If the name needs to be changed, the name change will be handled simultaneously. The entire process starts with the effective document. After completion, the child's medical insurance, school admission qualifications, and inheritance rights can be smoothly connected. After the changes are completed, it is recommended to make and keep copies of the new household registration pages for future reference.

The above content is based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. The facts of individual cases and the jurisdiction of the court may affect the conclusions. Welcome to consult Hengluo Lawyers for specific cases.

If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence, to avoid missing the statutory time limit.Legal services for inheritance·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.