[Direct answer]Pedestrians who fall and get injured due to the lack of warning signs or fences set up by construction units during road, residential area, or storefront construction are usually held liable by the construction units. According to Article 1258 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if anyone causes damage to others by excavating, repairing, or installing underground facilities in public places or on roads without setting up clear signs or taking safety measures, the construction workers shall bear tort liability. Victims should seek medical treatment promptly, report the incident to the police, and preserve medical records, receipts, and on-site images. The scope of compensation includes medical expenses, loss of income, nursing care expenses, and transportation costs. If the victim suffers from a disability, they can also claim disability compensation. If the other party refuses to accept responsibility, the victim can file a lawsuit with the basic-level people's court at the location of the infringement.
I. Problem background and typical scenarios
In cities, operations such as water and electricity excavation, pipe network maintenance, and facade renovation are frequent. However, some construction units rush to meet deadlines and fail to set up warning cones, fences, or night-time warning lights around pits and trenches, leading to frequent accidents where pedestrians and cyclists fall into the pits. After such incidents occur, victims often encounter three kinds of excuses: the construction units claim they have given verbal warnings; the property management companies say they are only responsible for the site and not the construction; and the contracting units claim they have nothing to do with it, making it difficult to determine responsibility in a timely manner.
There's another easily overlooked detail: the on-site window period. Construction sites change rapidly, with pits and trenches likely to be backfilled within a day or two, and fences and equipment being moved around at any time. By the time the injury stabilizes and evidence collection becomes a priority, the scene often no longer exists. Therefore, completing the on-site fixation as soon as possible after seeking medical treatment is a prerequisite for establishing a claim in such cases.
The identity of the injured party also affects the choice of legal path: if a passer-by files a claim for infringement, the construction worker's injury at work falls under the category of work-related injury, and the compensation process follows the work-related injury insurance procedures. The two situations have very different evidentiary focuses, compensation items, and processing time limits. If the wrong path is taken, it often results in a waste of several months' time. In addition, the injury of construction workers also involves the division of responsibilities between the general contractor and the labor subcontractor, which also requires first establishing the employment facts.
II. Key points of contention
The first point of contention is how to identify the responsible parties: the direct contractors who carry out the construction, the employers who illegally award the contracts, and the property or municipal departments responsible for site management may all fall into the scope of defendants. Victims may request to review the construction permits and road occupation approval information, based on which they can identify the specific construction entities. If the construction on the occupied roads has not been approved, there may also be joint or supplementary liability between the municipal management departments and the contractors.
The second layer of dispute is the proportion of the victim's own fault. The other party often uses "not paying attention to the road while walking" and "climbing over the fence" as defenses to reduce liability. In judicial practice, it is generally believed that the lack of warning signs is the main cause of the damage. If the victim only has general negligence, the extent of liability reduction and exemption is limited. The third layer of dispute is the calculation of loss items: loss of income requires proof of income and proof of loss of income, nursing fees are linked to the degree of nursing dependence, follow-up treatment fees can be claimed separately after they actually occur, and disability compensation is based on the appraisal grade.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers
When handling such personal injury cases, Hengluo Lawyers recommend assigning liability according to the principle of "giving priority to the fault of the constructor and supplementing with the fault of the manager". If the constructor digs a pit or repairs pipelines in a public place without setting up obvious signs and taking safety measures, Article 1258 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021) shall apply. This article is a presumption of fault clause, under which the victim does not need to prove the constructor's subjective fault, but only needs to prove the facts of the construction, the facts of the damage, and the causal relationship between the two. The burden of proof is relatively light. When taking photos, attention should be paid to including surrounding reference objects to facilitate the restoration of the relative positions of the pit and the building.
In terms of evidence, the police report, the 120 emergency records, and the interrogation transcripts from the police station can objectively fix the time, location, and scene conditions of the injury, and their probative force is higher than that of the scene photos taken afterwards. In terms of compensation, after the treatment is completed, the victim can apply for a disability assessment, and the disability rating from Level 1 to Level 10 corresponds to different compensation coefficients. The compensation for disability, nursing care, assistive devices, and mental distress are all calculated based on the assessment opinion. If the construction unit and property management companies or other entities are at fault for the damage, the victim can sue them jointly, and the court will apportion responsibility according to the degree of fault and causality.
For the compensation items and calculation methods for injuries caused by the fault of a third party, please refer to the relevant provisions.Personal injury compensation legal servicesRead the instructions on the page and then determine the scope of your claims based on your own injuries.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
The main legal basis is Article 1179 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021) on personal injury compensation items, Article 1258 on the contractor's liability, and the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trials of Personal Injury Compensation Cases (amended version effective from May 1, 2022). The statute of limitations applies to Article 188 of the Civil Code, which is three years, calculated from the date when the victim knows or should have known that his rights have been infringed and the date when the obligee knows or should have known that his obligations have been violated.
The victim can proceed in five steps: Firstly, seek medical treatment immediately and keep the diagnosis certificate, medical records, and expense receipts in full; Secondly, report the incident to the police or the property management company within 24 hours to obtain an official on-site record; Thirdly, take photos of the location of the pit, the missing warning facilities, the injured area, and the on-site environment; Fourthly, collect the name of the construction unit, construction permits, and other main information, and retrieve the information through government information disclosure channels if necessary; Fifthly, if the injury results in a disability, apply for a judicial appraisal after the treatment is completed, and file a lawsuit within the three-year statute of limitations.
If you have any questions about the claims process, please refer to the following document for more information.Personal injury and medical dispute servicesYou can submit the evidence online through the court's official website, or bring the evidence materials for on-site evaluation. Preparing a list of the defendant's main parties, compensation items, and evidence groups in advance can make the filing and mediation process smoother.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
After an injury, don't rush to sign a one-time settlement agreement. The disability rating and subsequent treatment costs are uncertain in the early stages of the injury, and hasty settlements often lead to losses. When negotiating with the construction unit, list medical expenses, loss of income, nursing fees, and other items one by one and keep written records to avoid only discussing a general total amount. For government-funded or municipal projects, you can check the information on the public disclosure of construction permits to identify the responsible parties, which is more effective than arguing on-site.
If no agreement can be reached through negotiation, you can apply for people's mediation or request the intervention of the competent industry departments. However, the mediation agreement should leave room for additional compensation after the disability appraisal. Throughout the process, you should pay attention to the three-year statute of limitations and complete the evidence collection and claims at the stage when the evidence is fresh and the other party has not yet been characterized. The initiative should always be in your own hands.
The proof of loss of income is often underestimated: for those with incomes exceeding the personal income tax threshold, they need to prepare tax payment records or bank statements. A simple certificate issued by the employer may not be fully accepted. For those who are cared for by family members during hospitalization, they can claim nursing fees referring to the local nursing labor remuneration standards, and at the same time explain the loss of income of their family members. If the causal relationship between the injury and the previous illness is questioned, they can apply for a causality participation assessment and use the assessment opinion to respond to the other party's defense.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If someone gets injured at a construction site where no warning signs are posted, is the construction company required to provide full compensation?
Generally, the contractor bears the main responsibility, but not necessarily full responsibility. According to Article 1258 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the contractor fails to set up clear signs and take safety measures, causing damage to others, he shall bear tort liability. This article is based on the presumption of fault, and the burden of proof mainly lies with the contractor. If the victim has obvious major negligence, such as looking at the mobile phone while walking and falling into an obvious pit, or ignoring the fence and forcibly crossing the construction area, the court may reduce the contractor's liability by 10% to 30% according to the degree of fault. Insufficient night lighting and the absence of any warning signs around the pit will affect the determination of the liability proportion. Before suing, it is necessary to fix these on-site details as much as possible.
Q2: What evidence should the victims of falls prioritize preparing?
The first batch of evidence should be fixed within 48 hours after the injury. For on-site evidence, focus on photographing the location of the pit, the presence or absence of warning signs, the condition of the fence, and the injured area, with equal emphasis on long-shot and close-up shots. For official records, promptly call the police to obtain the police report, and keep the 120 emergency records and the property duty log. For medical evidence, fully preserve the diagnosis certificate, imaging report, medical records, and expense receipts. When seeking medical treatment, explain the cause of the injury to the doctor, and the account of the incident recorded in the medical records is often the earliest written evidence. For income evidence, prepare the labor contract, pay slips, and the unit's loss of working time certificate to claim compensation for loss of working time. Construction units often refill the pit and clean up the site very quickly. If the victim is unable to collect evidence themselves, they can entrust relatives or friends who are present at the scene to take additional photos, and if necessary, apply for evidence preservation in litigation.
Q3: What is the standard for calculating disability compensation after a fall injury?
The disability compensation is calculated according to Article 12 of the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trials of Personal Injury Compensation Cases" (the amended version effective from May 1, 2022): It is based on the per capita disposable income of urban residents in the jurisdiction of the court where the case is filed, calculated over a period of 20 years, and multiplied by the coefficient corresponding to the disability grade, with the first-degree disability being the highest and the tenth-degree disability being 10%. The disability grade shall be determined based on the judicial appraisal opinion after the treatment ends. Those who have suffered disabilities may also claim nursing fees, assistive device fees, and compensation for mental distress simultaneously. The amounts of each item will fluctuate with the appraisal grade and local income data. Before suing, lawyers can roughly calculate the claim range based on the appraisal expectations.
Q4: Is there a time limit for suing the court for injuries suffered at a construction site?
There are, and the restrictions directly affect the outcome of the case. According to Article 188 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), the statute of limitations for suing in the people's court to protect civil rights is three years, calculated from the date when the right holder knows or should know that his rights have been infringed and the date when the obligee knows or should know that his obligations have been violated. For injuries at construction sites, the statute of limitations usually starts from the date of the injury. If the treatment period is long, the parties continue to negotiate, or the obligee agrees to perform his obligations, the statute of limitations is interrupted and starts anew. After the statute of limitations expires, the obligee can raise the defense of non-performance of obligations, and the chances of winning the case will be greatly reduced. It is recommended to complete a preliminary evaluation of the injury and evidence within one year after the injury, and to reserve time for appraisal and negotiation. For those who want to sue after more than three years, they should first check whether there are any interruptions, and then decide whether to claim.
Q5: If the construction company refuses to compensate and shifts the blame, what specific procedures should I follow to resolve the matter?
A lawsuit can be filed with the basic-level people's court of the place where the infringement occurred. The process is as follows: First, verify the full name of the construction unit through enterprise credit information or the publicity of construction permits to determine the defendant; then list claims such as medical expenses, loss of income, nursing care fees, hospitalization meal subsidies, and disability-related items, and attach receipts; the case acceptance fee shall be prepaid according to the amount of the claim in accordance with the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" (implemented on April 1, 2007), and the losing party shall bear it after the plaintiff wins the case; if you are worried that the other party may transfer assets, you can apply for property preservation and provide guarantees. If it is difficult to collect evidence on your own, you can apply to the court for an investigation order to retrieve surveillance footage and approval files after suing. If both parties agree to mediation, you can request the court to issue a mediation agreement, which has the same binding force as a judgment. After filing the case, you can add the actual constructor as a co-defendant as needed to prevent omission of the main parties.
The above answer is based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. The judicial interpretation in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.
If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials to avoid missing the statutory time limit.Personal injury legal services·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.