[Direct answer]When selecting a lawyer on a consultation platform, the screening process can be broken down into four verifiable steps: first, verify the lawyer's practice license number; second, verify the lawyer's practice institution; third, review the power of attorney contract; and fourth, verify the fees and the entity receiving the payment. Any lawyer who is unable to provide a practice license number, refuses to issue a written power of attorney contract, requires payment to be made to a personal account, or charges additional fees by promising results should be immediately discontinued from further contact. Lawyer practice is an administrative licensing activity. Those who have not obtained a lawyer's practice certificate are not allowed to practice as lawyers, and those who impersonate lawyers will also bear administrative responsibilities. The platform's profile pictures, case displays, and verbal guarantees cannot replace any of the above verification processes.

1. Problem background and typical scenarios

The initial contact on the consultation platform usually starts with a free Q&A session. The questioner briefly describes the case, and the other party quickly provides a seemingly professional analysis. After that, the topic naturally turns to fees: some quote prices that are significantly lower than the market rate, some first demand so-called case filing fees and activity fees, and some promise that they can get things done as long as they have connections. Another type of situation is well-packaged: the profile uses the law firm's logo, the introduction lists a large number of cases, and during the chat, the lawyer sends a power of attorney contract with the law firm's letterhead, but the name of the attorney and the license number are blank, and the payment QR code points to a personal account.

The root cause of this problem is information asymmetry. Clients usually don't understand the specific path of qualification verification, nor do they know which practices are prohibited by professional norms, so they can't judge obvious abnormalities. There is another situation that is easily overlooked: the other party does have a practice qualification, but the actual practitioner is not himself. The case is passed around in personal chat software, and there is a lack of corresponding written documents between the client relationship, fees, and services. When problems arise, it's often difficult to identify the responsible party. Platforms also commonly display so-called success rates and case numbers, but the sources of such data are unclear.

II. Key points of dispute

The first point of contention is the issue of professional qualifications and professional status.To determine whether a person can provide legal services as a lawyer, the first thing to check is whether the practicing license number is authentic and whether it is in a valid practicing state. Lawyers in the internship assessment period can practice under the guidance of supervising lawyers, but they are not allowed to handle cases independently in the name of practicing lawyers; forging, altering, or buying and selling practicing licenses constitute criminal offenses. In addition, it is necessary to check whether there are publicized information such as suspension of practice or revocation of practicing licenses. These contents can be queried through the publicity channels of the judicial administrative departments and lawyers' associations.

The second point of contention is the professional relationship between the lawyer and the actual practitioner.Lawyers shall practice in law firms and accept their management. Only when the name of the lawyer handling the case and the license number are specified in the entrustment contract, and the name is consistent with the actual person who communicates with the client, collects evidence, and appears in court, can a traceable service chain be formed. If the contract only lists the name of the law firm without the information of the lawyer handling the case, or if a person without a practicing qualification handles the whole process as an assistant but refuses to explain the situation of practicing, there is doubt about whether the entrustment relationship really exists; handling cases in other places and subcontracting at various levels should also be avoided.

The third point of contention is the fee structure and contract terms.The fees for lawyer services shall be determined in accordance with a combination of government-guided prices and market-regulated prices, and may be charged on a per-case, hourly, or percentage-of-the-value basis. All such fees shall be specified in a written contract and invoiced by the law firm. Key points to pay attention to include: whether the fees are collected uniformly by the law firm; whether additional hard-to-define activity fees are charged; whether the contract stipulates that fees will not be refunded in the event of unilateral termination; and whether it requires the client to separately sign a waiver of liability clause. Such clauses may be invalidated as they unreasonably exempt one party from liability.

The fourth point of contention is the promise of boundaries and criminal risks.Lawyers are not allowed to make promises about the outcome of cases, which is a basic requirement of professional conduct. Any high-priced services advertised as "guaranteed success" or "insider connections" should be viewed with caution. If the other party charges fees without professional qualifications and fabricates a client-attorney relationship, they may be suspected of fraud and will be held criminally liable in accordance with Article 226 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 29, 2018).

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers

When receiving new clients, Hengluo Lawyers usually conduct a 15-minute qualification check first, focusing on five aspects: what is the practice license number, and can it be found on public channels; whether the name and address of the law firm belong to them and are consistent with the contract; who is actually handling the case, and whether the person appearing in court is the same person; what are the fee methods, amounts, and payment deadlines, and who will receive the payment; and how will the rights and obligations of both parties be arranged if there are unfavorable results. If the client can provide clear answers to all five questions and is willing to cooperate with the verification, the communication can continue; if they avoid answering any of these questions, the follow-up process should be suspended.

There are specific methods for verification. The practice certificate number can be checked on the practice information publicity channels of the judicial administrative departments and lawyers' associations, or by directly calling the consultation phone number publicly disclosed by the law firm to verify whether the number is registered. Regarding fees, the focus should be on the payment path: law firm's public account or the receipt account confirmed in writing by the law firm are normal channels, while personal chat software accounts, personal bank cards, or third-party company accounts require high vigilance. Once a dispute arises, there is no direct correspondence between the payment and the lawyer, making it significantly more difficult to recover the funds. Regarding contracts, check the entrusted matters, deadlines, fees, risk disclosures, and termination conditions item by item. For blank pages or missing attachments, require an explanation before signing.

At the same time, we need to avoid another extreme: turning verification into a misjudgment of professional competence. Responsible communication often includes adverse warnings, such as insufficient evidence, potential jurisdictional disputes, the possibility of the opposing party's defense being successful, and the likelihood of a prolonged litigation process. Answers that only talk about the chances of winning without mentioning the risks also require caution. Hengluo Lawyer's judgment criteria are whether the other party is willing to clarify the adverse aspects before charging fees, and whether they are willing to include the service content in the contract. These are more worth referring to than the promised results.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

In terms of operation, the process of leaving a record can be divided into four steps. Firstly, request materials: the lawyer's license number, the full name and address of the law firm, the name of the lawyer handling the case, the charging method and amount. Require a written power of attorney and retain all communication records. Secondly, cross-check: check the lawyer's license number on publicly available channels to verify their practicing status; then use the law firm's public phone number to verify whether the lawyer is employed by the firm. Thirdly, review the contract: confirm the trustee, the entrusted matters and authority, the time limit, the fees and payment deadlines, the risk disclosure, the breach of contract liability and the conditions for termination. Require explanations for blank pages and unilateral exemption clauses. Only pay the fees to the law firm account specified in the contract and request an invoice. Fourthly, store evidence for reference: file the contract, invoice, transfer receipt, and chat records in chronological order, which can be used as a basis for complaints in case of disputes.

The main norms that need to be cited include: the provisions of the Law of the People's Republic of China on Lawyers (amended on September 1, 2017) regarding the acquisition of a practicing certificate and the norms of practicing behavior; Article 55 of the same law on the punishment for engaging in legal services business under the guise of a lawyer without obtaining a practicing certificate; Article 56 on the punishment for impersonating a lawyer; the provisions of the Measures for the Administration of Lawyers' Practice (implemented on September 1, 2016) regarding the public disclosure of practicing information; the provisions of the Measures for the Administration of Lawyers' Service Fees (implemented on April 1, 2011) regarding the charging methods and fee management; Article 497 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 2021) regarding the effectiveness of standard clauses; Article 566 regarding the termination of contracts; and Article 585 regarding the adjustment of the penalty for breach of contract. The specific application shall be subject to the currently effective laws, regulations, and judicial rulings.

For more details on the verification of professional qualifications and the review of entrustment contracts, please refer to the following document:Guidelines for Attorney's Mandate and Qualification VerificationColumn.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder

Three reminders. First, when the other party urges you to pay first and then discuss the contract, stop and verify the information first. The payment order should be after the verification. Second, write down the verbal promises into the contract, including the service methods, communication frequency, material delivery and deadlines. The promises that cannot be written down are of low value. Third, keep good receipts, specify the purpose of the transfer, request invoices, and keep the original contract. If you find out that the other party does not have a practicing qualification after making the payment, do not interrupt the communication or delete the records. Fix the evidence in time and report it to the judicial administrative department and the lawyers' association. If it involves criminal offenses, report the case to the police in time. Fixing the verification into a process is more reliable than relying on judgment every time.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Is it always reliable if the platform shows that a lawyer has a practicing license number?

Not necessarily. A valid practice certificate number only indicates that the certificate holder has the qualification to practice law, but it does not guarantee that they will actually handle your case. There are three additional verification steps: 1. Check the certificate number on the practice information publicity channels of the judicial administrative department and the bar association to confirm the practitioner's practice status and affiliated law firm. 2. Call the law firm's public phone number to verify whether the certificate number is registered with the firm. 3. Check whether the name of the attorney handling the case on the contract matches the actual person who communicates with you. Additionally, you should verify whether there are any public announcements such as suspension of practice or revocation of the practice certificate, and whether the fees are collected and invoiced by the law firm. Practice qualifications are the minimum requirement, but they do not guarantee high-quality service.

Q2: How to verify whether a lawyer is practicing in a regular law firm?

You can compare the information disclosed to the public item by item: Check the full name of the law firm, the name and address specified in the practice license, and confirm that they are consistent with the official website of the law firm, the map marking, or the official publicized address; Confirm that the law firm is registered in the public list of the local judicial administrative department and the bar association; Check that the registration authority of the lawyer's practice certificate is consistent with the entrusted agency on the contract; Confirm that the payment is made to the law firm's account and an invoice is issued by the law firm. The entrustment contract should state the name of the lawyer handling the case and the practice certificate number. If the other party is only willing to write the name of the law firm and not the name of the lawyer handling the case, refuses to provide the practice certificate number, or requires payment first and then completing the formalities, these are all signals that the negotiation should be terminated.

Q3: Which cost items are considered unreasonable charges before entrusting a lawyer with a case?

The fees for lawyer services are regulated by the "Measures for the Administration of Lawyer Service Fees" (effective April 1, 2011), which combines government-guided prices and market-regulated prices. Fees can be charged on a per-case, hourly, or percentage-of-case value basis, with reasonable portions concentrated in attorney's fees and the costs of bills issued by law firms. Four common unreasonable items include: so-called filing fees and preservation fees charged without a power of attorney; ambiguous activity fees for which the standard is refused to be explained; payments required to be directly deposited into personal accounts; and fees charged based on promises of outcomes through connections and bribes. The judgment criteria are simple: whether the project name, charging entity, corresponding basis, and actual services can be matched one by one.

Q4: Is it valid to stipulate in the contract that there will be no refunds or fee refunds?

No, it's not necessarily effective. It depends on the nature of the terms and whether the obligation to provide notice and explanations has been fulfilled. If the entrustment contract stipulates that all payments made when the contract is unilaterally terminated will not be refunded, this is an unfair clause that exempts the party's own responsibilities and restricts the other party's main rights. According to Article 497 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), such clauses may be deemed invalid. Even if the clause is deemed valid, if the lawyer terminates the contract without providing actual services for no legitimate reason, the fees already paid should be settled or refunded in accordance with the actual circumstances. Articles 566 and 585 of the Civil Code regarding the termination of contracts and the payment of breach of contract penalties serve as the basis for judgment. When signing the contract, the progress of the services and the method of fee settlement should be clearly specified.

Q5: If you find that a lawyer is practicing without a license, how can you file a complaint and protect your rights?

Handle them separately according to their nature. If it's just unlicensed or out-of-scope practice without involving property losses, report it to the judicial administrative department and request verification of the practitioner's qualifications. If it involves illegal charging, delay in performance, or forged materials, submit a complaint to the bar association and request industry handling. If you have already paid the fees but the other party fabricated the entrustment relationship and refused to refund, you should promptly report the case to the public security organ if it involves fraud. At the same time, keep the contracts, transfer receipts, chat records, and identity information well. The more specific the materials provided to the judicial administrative department, the bar association, and the public security organ when seeking justice, the faster the verification will be. If necessary, you can entrust a practicing lawyer to evaluate the claim path for the return of fees separately.

The above answer is based on the judicial practice in Beijing. The adjudication guidelines in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.

If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials to avoid missing the statutory time limit.Specialised services - legal services·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.