[Direct answer]The compensation amount depends on whether the losses can be quantified. In the case of equipment damage during factory demolition, there are two scenarios: if it is caused by the administrative authorities organizing illegal demolition, the compensation shall be claimed in accordance with administrative compensation rules, which includes the residual value of the equipment after deducting depreciation, disassembly and transportation fees, and production losses during the transition period; if it is caused by the construction units' brutal operations, the compensation shall be claimed in accordance with civil tort claims. The compensation amount is usually based on the appraisal conclusion, rather than the net book value of the enterprise. The prerequisite are that the inventory, numbering, and photography of the equipment must be completed before the demolition, and the basis for the replacement value must be obtained. Otherwise, it will be difficult to restore the losses afterwards.

I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios

When factories are subject to expropriation, the time limit for vacating the premises after signing the contract is often only a few dozen days. Some enterprises are still looking for temporary production sites, but the demolition teams have already moved in. Cranes, injection molding machines, electrical cabinets, and clean rooms were demolished before they could be dismantled; some enterprises also had their water and electricity cut off at night, causing raw materials in temperature-controlled warehouses to spoil and work-in-process products to be scrapped. Another type of problem occurs during the relocation process. Precision equipment is not properly packaged for shock protection, and the spindles are deformed during transportation. The carrier and the expropriation implementation unit are passing the buck to each other.

A common misunderstanding among business owners is that the equipment has already been included in the compensation for the house. In actual expropriation, the value of the house is assessed based on the building area, and the machinery and equipment do not belong to the house itself. They are usually listed separately as relocation fees, the replacement cost of the equipment or the losses caused by the suspension of production and business operations. The enterprises need to actively declare them and attach a list. For the unreported parts, the assessment agencies will not actively include them, and the difficulty of retrospective assessment will be multiplied.

II. Key points of dispute

Firstly, the distinction between compensation and indemnification. If the expropriation procedure is legal but the equipment is not included in the compensation, it constitutes a compensation dispute. In this case, one should first apply for a review of the compensation decision or file a lawsuit to demand full compensation. If the demolition itself is illegal, such as the absence of a decision document, failure to announce the demolition, or demolishing neighboring factories beyond the scope of the expropriation, it constitutes administrative indemnification, and one can claim full actual losses. The defendants, requests, and evidentiary structures in the two cases are different. Mixing them up will result in the dismissal of the request.

Secondly, the basis for calculating the losses. The enterprise claims the replacement value, while the expropriator claims the net book value. The appraisal institutions often use the replacement value as the new value. The differences between the three approaches may exceed one-fold. In judicial practice, the purchase invoices, fixed asset cards, depreciation periods, and market quotations of the same model jointly determine the new value rate. The actual usage intensity of the equipment and maintenance records will also affect the conclusion.

Thirdly, the causality and the obligation of mitigation. If the equipment is left unattended for a long time after the notice of eviction and suffers from moisture and rust during the rainy season, it may be deemed that the enterprise failed to take mitigation measures and therefore will not be supported. Whether there is a direct causality between the demolition action and the damage result needs to be verified by on-site images, records of the entry and exit of the operation vehicles, and witness statements to form a closed loop.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers

The case of Liu **'s land expropriation information disclosure in Group 1 of Shuguang Village, XX Town, H City, handled by He Ningning, an attorney with our firm (practice certificate number: 11101202511925103, subject to the document issued by the judicial administrative organ), aptly demonstrates why it is necessary to obtain evidence first when claiming compensation for equipment. Liu **'s legal house was included in the expropriation scope due to the construction of the F to S high-speed railway but received no compensation. On September 23, 2025, Liu ** applied to the H City People's Government for disclosure of seven core land expropriation information, but the municipal government refused on the grounds that the house had not been expropriated and the information did not exist. The attorney filed for administrative reconsideration twice, and on April 14, 2026, the reconsideration authority issued a second reconsideration decision. After trial, it was found that the land involved in the case was approved for expropriation by the Ministry of Land and Resources on November 30, 2016. The reconsideration authority also pointed out key illegal points. Article 46 of the previous version of the Land Management Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on August 28, 2004) stipulates that land expropriation shall be announced and organized by the county-level or higher government. This case cites Articles 26, 28, and paragraph 4 of Article 32 of the Implementing Regulations of the Land Management Law of the People's Republic of China (effective on September 1, 2021).

The lesson of this case regarding equipment claims is not a conclusion, but a sequence of events. To prove equipment losses, companies must first obtain three sets of documents: the expropriation scope map, the compensation and resettlement plan, and the main body responsible for the demolition. Without these documents, it's impossible to even identify the defendant, and the compensation request will be dismissed due to the unqualified subject. Many companies focus all their energy on negotiating with the demolition office, only remembering to collect evidence after the factory building has been demolished. By then, the scene has already disappeared, leaving them with no choice but to piece together the evidence using indirect materials.

Another point that is easily overlooked is the separation of equipment from the building. Equipment losses are a separate compensation item, which requires listing the equipment's name, quantity, original value, depreciation rate, and damage method in the lawsuit's claims section. If the claim is combined with the compensation for the building, the court will usually only review the legality of the compensation decision and not deal with the equipment part in substance, which means the enterprise will lose a valuable opportunity to assert its rights.

The third group of expenses that are often underestimated are disassembly, installation, and commissioning costs. The relocation of heavy equipment requires the services of professional lifting companies, the need to repour foundations, and the need to recalibrate precision. These costs are often higher than the depreciation value of the equipment itself. Enterprises should obtain written quotes from lifting, transportation, and installation companies before disassembly as a basis for calculating losses; it's difficult for courts to support estimates based solely on retrospective recollections. Specialized molds, tools, and fixtures that come with the equipment should also be listed item by item to avoid being overlooked as low-value consumables.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

Firstly, complete the inventory of equipment before dismantling. According to the production line number, take photos of the nameplates, factory numbers, and purchase invoices of each piece of equipment, compile an equipment inventory list, and ask the staff of the tax collection department to sign for receipt. If it is not possible to sign for receipt, mail it by EMS and keep the shipping list and the list of the contents of the package.

Secondly, apply for an evaluation and reserve the right to raise objections. If you have any objections to the equipment's replacement value in the evaluation report, you can apply for a review or commission an expert appraisal after receiving the report. The objections must be submitted in writing and the delivery receipts must be preserved.

Thirdly, distinguish the request path. If the compensation is insufficient, apply for administrative reconsideration or initiate administrative litigation against the compensation decision; if the illegal forced demolition results in equipment damage, raise an administrative compensation request in the reconsideration or litigation to avoid being rejected on the grounds of duplicate processing if sued in a separate case.

Fourth, pay attention to the time limit. The preliminary handling procedures of the compensation-liable organ cannot be omitted. Before initiating an administrative compensation lawsuit, one should first submit an application to the compensation-liable organ. If the compensation is not paid within the time limit or there are disputes over the amount of compensation, one can then file a lawsuit.

Fifth, establish a causal relationship. Record the entire process of the demolition site with video, document the corresponding relationship between the damaged parts of the equipment and the construction vehicles, and apply to the notary office for evidence preservation notarization when necessary.

In terms of legal basis, Article 48 of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2020) stipulates that fair and reasonable compensation shall be provided for land expropriation, and the compensation fees shall include above-ground attachments, etc. The Implementing Regulations of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective September 1, 2021) provide detailed regulations on the preparation, announcement, and signing of compensation and resettlement plans. Articles 4 and 36 of the State Compensation Law of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2013) respectively stipulate the scope of compensation and the calculation method for infringement of property rights. Regarding the burden of proof, Article 38 Paragraph 2 of the Administrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that in cases of administrative compensation and compensation, if the defendant causes the plaintiff to be unable to provide evidence, the burden of proof shall be borne by the defendant. Disputes involving equipment damage often involve the intersection of expropriation procedures and compensation calculations. For more information, please refer to the relevant provisions.Land expropriation and demolition, and administrative litigationThe approach to handling this matter.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Advice

The most common ways for equipment to be lost are twofold: firstly, when no one records the removal process at the site; secondly, when rights are waived during the signing of the confirmation document. Common clauses in eviction notices stipulate that the enterprise shall dispose of the equipment itself, and that the equipment will be deemed abandoned if not removed within the specified timeframe. Once the document is signed, it will be very difficult to claim compensation for the damaged equipment afterward. It is recommended that enterprises take photos of all documents requiring their signature before deciding whether to sign them, and keep the full text for future reference.

There's another point worth noting: the residual value of the equipment should be listed separately. The proceeds from the sale of scrap metal can be deducted from the losses, and actively disclosing this information can help the assessment conclusions be accepted. However, if the residual value is deliberately concealed and later proven by the other party, the credibility of the entire statement will be affected. For precision equipment and specialized production lines, it is recommended to conduct a comprehensive technical condition appraisal before relocation to separate the repairable and non-repairable parts for valuation, so as to provide a basis for compensation negotiations.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: If the machine was not evaluated before it was dismantled, can the claim still be valid?

This can be claimed, but the difficulty of providing evidence has clearly increased. When the equipment has been lost, the court usually combines the purchase invoices, fixed asset ledgers, market inquiries for equipment of the same model, and image materials from the demolition to determine the value comprehensively. If necessary, the court may commission a price appraisal institution to calculate the replacement cost. Article 38, paragraph 2 of the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that if the plaintiff is unable to provide evidence due to the defendant's reasons, the burden of proof shall be borne by the defendant. Therefore, whether there are video recordings of the demolition site and whether there are witnesses present often directly determine the outcome of the case. If even the equipment list cannot be provided, it is usually only possible to claim for the main structure of the factory building, and it is difficult to obtain support for the equipment part.

Q2: If the original invoice for the equipment is lost, what materials can be used to prove the amount of the loss?

There are three types of materials that can be used as substitutes: first, the fixed asset detail ledger, depreciation accrual form, and annual audit report, which can reflect the original value recorded in the books and the depreciation already accrued; second, purchase contracts, payment bank statements, and supplier reconciliation statements; third, market quotes for similar equipment or transaction records of second-hand equipment. When the amount is large, you can apply to the court for a commissioned price evaluation. It should be noted that the net book value is usually lower than the replacement cost of new equipment. When making a claim, you should explain the actual usage intensity and maintenance condition of the equipment to avoid the evaluation agency mechanically depreciating it according to the age. If the equipment is self-made or modified, you should also provide drawings, work hour records, and material purchase certificates. Otherwise, it will be difficult to determine its independent value.

Q3: For claims for losses caused by disassembling the machine, which party should advance the appraisal and evaluation fees first?

Generally, the applicant pays the fees upfront, and the losing party ultimately bears the cost or shares it according to the proportion of liability. The fees for price evaluation and asset appraisal are usually calculated based on the amount of the subject matter, while equipment appraisal also involves on-site inspections and travel expenses. In administrative compensation cases, if the loss is caused by the illegal demolition by the administrative organ, the enterprise may claim the appraisal fees together with the litigation requests, and the court will support the reasonable part. It is recommended to confirm the charging method and the report issuance period with the appraisal agency before entrusting the appraisal, and to keep the original contract and invoices as part of the loss. If the appraisal conclusion is subject to a request for re-appraisal by the other party and the conclusion changes, the cost burden may be redistributed.

Q4: If we can't agree on the amount of compensation, how long is the first-instance trial usually scheduled to last?

Administrative compensation litigation applies to the time limit for administrative litigation. The first-instance court generally makes a judgment within six months. If there are special circumstances requiring an extension, it shall be approved by the higher people's court; if the case is tried by summary procedure, it shall be concluded within 45 days. In practice, cases involving equipment evaluation and cost appraisal do not count the appraisal period into the time limit, and the overall period is often more than eight months to one year. If a compensation request is raised together with the main case in compensation litigation, it can be tried at the same time as the main case, which saves time compared with suing in a separate case. The second-instance court generally takes three months to make a judgment. After the judgment takes effect, it enters the enforcement stage. If the administrative organ fails to perform its obligations, the party concerned may apply for compulsory enforcement.

Q5: The demolition party has cleared the site. How should the residual value of the equipment be determined on-site?

Three steps to proceed: First, immediately apply to the notary office for evidence preservation notarization, take photos and videos of the current situation of the site, the remaining equipment, and the numbered nameplates item by item, and have the notary make a working record on site; Second, notify the implementation unit of the expropriation and the demolition construction unit in writing to come to the scene, clarify the ownership of the equipment and request a suspension of the removal; Send the notice by EMS and keep the receipt; Third, entrust an evaluation agency to conduct a site survey before the removal of the debris. If the site has already been cleaned up, you can retrieve the video from the law enforcement recorder on the day of the demolition, the surrounding surveillance footage, and the witness statements, and apply to the court for evidence retrieval in the process of reconsideration or litigation, so as to string together the indirect materials into a complete chain of evidence.

The above answer is based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. The adjudication standards in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.

If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limits. →Land expropriation and demolition legal services·Attorney He Ningning·Beijing Henglu Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.