[Direct answer]The live streaming of game footage often constitutes infringement. Original game footage can be protected by copyright as an audiovisual work, and unauthorized live streaming typically falls under the rights holder's broadcasting rights or information network dissemination rights. Both the streamer and the platform with fault may bear liability for compensation. Only in a small number of special circumstances constituting fair use can exemption from liability be granted. The party being sued should promptly verify the authorization chain with manufacturers and guilds, simultaneously preserve the live streaming records and complaint notifications, then evaluate the scope of responsibility and select a response strategy. Live streaming is not an inherently exempted usage method. Resolving the authorization issue before starting the broadcast is far more efficient than defending against claims after the fact.
I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios
Game live streaming is now one of the content forms with the most concentrated traffic. Streamers operate the game in real time in the live stream room and explain the plot, while the platform shares the rewards and advertisements with them. Manufacturers also regard live streaming as an important promotion channel. The problem often lies in unclear authorization: some streamers and manufacturers only have verbal permission, not written agreements; some live stream private servers, cracked versions, or versions that have not been launched in China; and some guilds bulk-transfer others' live stream recordings for secondary distribution. Once the manufacturer initiates legal protection, the streamers, guilds, and platforms may all be listed as defendants. For individual streamers, disputes often come without warning, and it's not uncommon for their accounts and earnings to be frozen overnight.
Another high-incidence scenario is the broadcast of e-sports event footage. Event organizers hold rights to the competition footage, and unauthorized broadcasters who simultaneously attract viewers during the event are easily accused of unfair competition. In the early stages of the dispute, many people don't know who to talk to or what to discuss first. By the time the screen recording is taken down due to complaints or the account is banned, they are forced to take action passively, and the scope for providing evidence and negotiating will be significantly limited.
There is another easily overlooked aspect: game-related user-generated content and compilation videos. Accounts that repost highlight reels and edit clips of key plot points may not engage in real-time live streaming, but the way they utilize video content is essentially the same, and rights holders often claim ownership of both types of content. To manage their own risks, platforms are increasingly restricting the recommendation and monetization of unauthorized game content, which in turn affects creators' earnings.
II. Key points of contention
The first layer of controversy is the copyrightability of the images. Early judges had differing opinions on whether game images could constitute works. With the amendment of the "Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China" (implemented on June 1, 2021) to reclassify film works as audiovisual works and relax the subject matter requirements, the mainstream view is that continuous images presented during operation have originality and can be protected as audiovisual works as a whole.
The second layer of controversy is the characterization of the act. The rights involved in real-time live streaming and recorded playback may be different. Whether it constitutes an infringement of broadcasting rights, information network dissemination rights, or other rights enjoyed by copyright holders directly affects the calculation method of compensation. The third layer of controversy is the platform's responsibility: the platform applies the notice and deletion rules of Article 1195 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021), and if it fails to take necessary measures in a timely manner after receiving a qualified notice, it shall bear joint and several liability for the expanded part of the damage; whether the streamer can invoke fair use depends on whether it constitutes transformative use and whether it affects the normal use of the work.
The fourth layer of controversy arises in the compensation stage. The income from live streaming is distributed among rewards, advertising, and sales promotions. When the rights holders provide evidence of their losses, they often extrapolate the figures based on transaction records, while the defendants argue that viewers may not necessarily convert into paying users, and the causal relationship is flexible. The disagreements over the calculation method are often harder to reconcile than the determination of infringement. This kind of "accounting"-style defense is quite common in practice. The earlier the preparation, the greater the room for negotiation.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
In intellectual property cases, the strength of the rights foundation and the evidence chain often determines the negotiating leverage. The case handled by our firm, "Trademark Infringement and Unfair Competition Case, Attorney Liu Yuanyuan Helped the Defendant Reduce the Claim from 980,000 to 60,000", is a typical example: The plaintiff, Company A, is a well-known paper industry enterprise, and the "EFGH" trademark is a well-known trademark for sanitary napkins in Category 5. The defendant, Company B, was authorized by a third party in September 2023 to use the "EFGK" trademark and design patent to produce and sell "EFGK" sanitary napkins, which were sold through the e-commerce channel of Company C. In April 2024, Company A sued the defendant, alleging that the defendant imitated the well-known trademark and packaging design to cause confusion, and claimed 98,000 in compensation.
Attorney Liu Yuanyuan of Beijing Henglu Law Firm (practice license number: 11101202011201094, subject to the document issued by the judicial administrative organ) represented Company B in its defense, arguing that the logo was legally authorized and not similar, the packaging and decoration did not constitute unfair competition, and the high compensation lacked basis. The court partially accepted the arguments: it determined that "EFGH" constituted a well-known trademark when applying for "EFGK", and the use of "EFGK" constituted imitation and trademark infringement; however, because the plaintiff failed to prove that the packaging and decoration "had a certain influence", the court dismissed the claim of unfair competition. Given the short infringement period and small scale, the court ordered Company B to compensate for economic losses of 50,000 yuan and reasonable expenses of 10,000 yuan, totaling 60,000 yuan, and ordered it to stop the infringement and publish a notice to eliminate the adverse effects.
This result shows that there is often a significant gap between the claim amount of the rights holder and the final compensation awarded. The defendant can completely reduce the liability to a reasonable range by clarifying the boundaries of rights and breaking down the basis for compensation item by item. The same applies to game live-stream disputes: whether the streamer holds authorizations, whether the platform has fulfilled its obligation to remove content, and the causal relationship between the loss and the live-stream behavior are all points that can be vigorously argued. When negotiating, actively presenting facts favorable to the manufacturer, such as live-stream data and traffic-driving effects, and transforming the adversarial relationship into a basis for cooperative bargaining is often a more cost-effective approach. After all, the manufacturer's real demands are often to regulate channels rather than simply seeking compensation. By finding the intersection of the two parties' interests, the outcome is often more ideal than confrontation.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
The main legal basis includes Article 3, Article 10, and Article 54 of the Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China (effective June 1, 2021), Articles 1195 and 1197 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), and Article 2 of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on April 23, 2019). In practice, it is recommended to proceed in five steps: 1. Organize all communication records with manufacturers and guilds to confirm whether the authorization scope covers live streaming, derivative works, and replays. 2. Preserve live streaming videos, backend data, and takedown notifications to form a complete timeline. 3. Evaluate and implement deletion or defense strategies within 48 hours after receiving complaints to avoid being deemed negligent in allowing damages to expand. 4. Calculate the basis for the other party's claims, distinguishing between actual losses, infringement profits, and licensing fee standards. 5. Conduct parallel assessments of negotiation and litigation to prioritize obtaining licensing cooperation to resolve disputes. Among these steps, the 48-hour period after receiving complaints and the evidentiary deadline before trial are the most critical two junctures. Missing the former increases the risk of damages expanding, while missing the latter may force one to bear the unfavorable consequences of failing to provide evidence.
For more information on the overall protection path in the intellectual property field, please refer to the following document:Intellectual property protection legal servicesThe page; for long-term compliance investigations involving live-streaming businesses, it can be handled byCorporate long-term legal advisorThe team follows up on the progress every quarter.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
Game live streaming may seem to have low entry barriers, but legally, it is an area where copyright, contracts, and competition rules intertwine. Signing a written agreement before going live that specifies the scope of authorization, duration, and revenue-sharing methods costs very little but can prevent most future disputes. When receiving a copyright infringement warning, don't rush to delete all content immediately. First, determine whether the notice is valid and the scope of deletion is appropriate, while preserving evidence. Also, don't easily believe verbal promises of "paying to settle the matter". When the case involves multiple parties or large sums, it's better to hire a lawyer early to clarify the liability ratio, which usually leads to better results than handling the matter on one's own. For guilds or studios that operate game content long-term, it's recommended to create a fixed document for authorization records, clearly showing the duration, scope, and renewal points of each agreement, to avoid broadcasting beyond authorized rights without realizing it.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Will the process of completing the storyline of a single-player game through live streaming infringe the copyright of the game publisher?
In most cases, yes. If the continuous images displayed during the gameplay are original, they can be protected as audiovisual works according to Article 3 of the Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China (effective June 1, 2021). Live streaming without authorization constitutes an act of making the work available to the public, typically infringing on broadcasting rights or the right of dissemination through information networks. During the promotion period, manufacturers usually tacitly allow or even encourage live streaming, but tacit permission does not equal waiving rights. Continuing to live stream after the cooperation ends constitutes a new infringement. In the case of brief quotations accompanied by original commentary, there's a chance they could be deemed fair use, but the discretionary scope of individual cases is wide. It's still safer to obtain written authorization before broadcasting. Even if the manufacturer verbally agrees, it's recommended to keep chat records or email confirmations.
Q2: When a live stream is accused of infringement, what materials will the court focus on reviewing?
The review is conducted around three aspects: rights, actions, and losses. At the rights level, the focus is on the game software copyright registration certificate and the screen ownership statement; at the action level, it involves live video recordings, account backend data, and the record of removal; at the loss level, it examines the manufacturer's revenue changes, licensing fee practices, and the streamer's reward income. The streamer should simultaneously prepare authorization agreements, profit-sharing contracts with guilds, and records of complaint notifications. Only when the evidence chain is complete can they strive to reduce the liability ratio and compensation amount. For some platforms' backend data, it may be necessary to obtain it through a lawyer's investigation order, and sufficient time should be reserved for applying for it before filing a lawsuit. During the evidence collection process, attention should be paid to the legality of the sources. Materials that are copied or filmed without authorization may be excluded.
Q3: What is the general range of compensation amounts awarded to streamers after they are sued?
There is no unified standard. The common range is from thousands of yuan to hundreds of thousands of yuan. According to Article 54 of the Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on June 1, 2021), the court shall determine the compensation based on the actual losses of the rights holder, the infringer's profits, or the multiple of the license fee. If it is difficult to calculate, the court shall adjudicate the compensation within the range of 500 yuan to 5 million yuan as appropriate. In cases where the live stream is short, attracts few viewers, and is removed promptly, the compensation is mostly in the tens of thousands of yuan range; in cases of long-term bulk plagiarism with high reward income, the amount will significantly increase. The streamer may claim that the platform takes a high percentage of the reward income and the actual income is limited, and put forward this as a mitigating circumstance. When providing evidence, it is more convincing to explain the sources of income in detail rather than denying it in general. The litigation fees are accumulated in stages according to the amount of the claim in accordance with the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees". Making excessive demands will only increase the litigant's own costs.
Q4: How long does it usually take for the platform to process the live stream replays after receiving a complaint?
According to Article 1195 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), after receiving a valid notice, the platform shall promptly forward it and take necessary measures such as deletion or blocking. The internal processes of mainstream platforms typically take one to seven working days to complete, with specific timelines subject to the rules publicly announced by each platform. If the notice is not valid, such as failing to attach proof of ownership or specify the specific link, the platform may require correction, with the processing time correspondingly extended. If the rights holder believes the processing is too slow, they may send another letter and request a processing record; if the platform fails to act within the time limit, they may claim that the platform and the infringer shall bear joint and several liability for the expanded damages in accordance with Article 1197, which is the most powerful bargaining chip in negotiations.
Q5: What should I do first after receiving an infringement warning letter from a game company?
Don't rush to reply to the letter or delete the post just yet. First, check the essential elements of the letter: whether the rights proof, infringement links, and the time limit for responses are all present. Second, complete an internal investigation within 48 hours to confirm whether the live stream is indeed within the scope of authorization. Third, simultaneously back up all live stream videos and backend data to prevent their loss. Fourth, determine the response strategy - if there are indeed flaws, proactively remove the content and negotiate a licensing agreement; if there is no infringement, provide a written explanation and reserve the right to counter-claim. The content of the response must be reviewed by a lawyer before being sent out. Any self-incriminating statements may be screenshot and preserved by the other party. If the amount involved is large or the other party has already filed a lawsuit, it is necessary to hire a lawyer as soon as possible to handle all external communications.
This article is written based on the common judicial interpretations in the Beijing area. If the case occurs in other regions, it is recommended to consult local lawyers to verify the regional differences.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence, so as to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Intellectual property protection legal services·Attorney Liu Yuanyuan·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.