[Direct answer]The guarantee shall be deemed to be a general guarantee. According to Article 686 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the parties do not stipulate or stipulate unclear guarantee methods in the guarantee contract, the guarantor shall bear the guarantee liability in accordance with the general guarantee. The guarantor of the general guarantee enjoys the right of prior defense. The creditor shall first file a lawsuit or apply for arbitration against the debtor. Only when the debtor's property cannot be enforced by law to fulfill the debt, can the guarantor be required to bear the liability. When signing the guarantee contract, it is the most effective way to clarify the guarantee methods, guarantee period and guarantee scope item by item to avoid such disputes.
1. Problem background and typical scenarios
The forms of guarantee contracts in practice are varied and complex: some people only sign their names on promissory notes and indicate their status as guarantors, while others state that they will assume guarantee responsibilities without distinguishing between general and joint guarantees. Still others simply state in the guarantee clauses that they are willing to provide guarantees without specifying the type of guarantee. Once the debt is due but not repaid, the first dispute that often arises between the creditor and the guarantor is the form of guarantee—which determines the order of litigation, the scope of liability, and the path of recovery. A slight difference in wording can completely overturn the entire litigation strategy.
After the implementation of the Civil Code, there have been significant changes in the rules of determination. In the previous era of the Guaranty Law, if the guarantee method was not specified, it was presumed to be a joint and several liability guarantee. From January 1, 2021, the rules were reversed, and if there was no agreement or the agreement was unclear, it would be handled as a general guarantee. Many contracts signed using the old template, the parties still claimed joint and several liability according to the old concept, but failed in litigation. There are also guarantors who mistakenly believe that they need to pay immediately after signing the contract, ignoring their own sequential interests. This is the deep-seated reason for the high incidence of such disputes and the confusion in understanding.
The scenarios of the company's external guarantees are more worthy of vigilance. Due to the cooperative relationship, the company's bosses let the financial staff casually stamp the official seal on the supply contract to act as guarantors, without specifying the guarantee method or obtaining the resolution of the shareholders' meeting; after the debt default, whether the guarantee liability is established, the way to bear it, and whether the company can defend itself against the over-authority guarantee are three disputes that erupt simultaneously. The same is true of the situation where individuals act as guarantors in loans from relatives and friends. The casualness when signing the contract contrasts sharply with the passivity when recovering the debt.
II. Key points of contention
First, how to determine the type of guarantee. When the text does not specify whether it is a general guarantee or a joint and several liability guarantee, the court will make a comprehensive judgment based on the provisions: if the terms include the meaning that the guarantor enjoys the right of prior defense and should first execute the debtor's property, it is likely to be identified as a general guarantee; if the terms use words such as joint and several liability, joint repayment, and direct assumption, it may be identified as a joint and several liability guarantee. Second, how to calculate the guarantee period. If there is no agreement, the guarantee period shall be six months from the date of expiration of the main debtor's performance period; if the agreement is unclear (for example, it is written that the guarantee obligation shall continue until the debt is repaid in full), it shall also be handled according to the six-month period.
Thirdly, there are differences in the order of liability between the two types of guarantee. General guarantors enjoy the right of prior litigation defense, and creditors must first sue the debtors and still cannot be compensated after enforcement; joint guarantors can be directly sued and have their property enforced without priority interests. Fourthly, how to exercise the right of recourse after the guarantor assumes liability, the validity of the over-guarantee by the company as a guarantor without the resolution of the shareholders' meeting, and the order of enforcement when the debtor's pledge and the guarantor's guarantee coexist are also common points of contention in the trial. Improper handling of these issues will directly affect the outcome of debt recovery.
Fifth, the distinction of the levels of effectiveness and responsibility. The guarantee contract may be invalidated due to the invalidity of the main contract, or it may not take effect due to the lack of a company resolution. In different situations, the scope of the guarantor's responsibility is not the same: when the contract is invalid, the guarantor may bear compensation liability rather than guarantee liability, and the compensation ratio should be determined based on the fault of all parties. Before suing, the creditor should distinguish these three levels, which directly determines whether the litigation request can be fully supported.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
When the contract terms are incomplete or ambiguous, the arbitration body will fill in the gaps and define responsibilities in accordance with the law. This approach is applicable to all types of contracts, including commercial contracts. A mining resource contract dispute handled by Attorney Wu Jiani of Beijing Henglu Law Firm (practice certificate number: 11101202011245064, subject to the document issued by the judicial administrative authority) is a typical example. This case was the first of its kind handled by the Shaoguan Intermediate People's Court, with the trial lasting for one year and being reviewed by the Judicial Committee. Attorney Wu Jiani represented the three appellees, namely Chenguang Branch of Jiangxi Province B Engineering Construction Co., Ltd., Liu Gang, and Wu Qiang.
The first-instance court determined that the "Mine Contract" was invalid because it violated the mandatory provisions of Article 35 of the Mineral Resources Law. It ruled that A Mining Co., Ltd. should return the deposit of 8 million yuan and the task payment of 2 million yuan to Liu Gang and Wu Qiang, and compensate for the investment loss of 3.51 million yuan; and that Jiangxi Province B Engineering Construction Co., Ltd. Chenguang Branch should return the advance payment of 640,000 yuan to A Mining Co., Ltd. After A Mining Co., Ltd. appealed, the second-instance court adopted Hengluo Lawyer's opinion, determined that the basic facts of the first-instance court were clear, and ruled to dismiss the appeal and maintain the original judgment. The parties recovered a total of over 10.94 million yuan. This case shows that the validity of clauses and the assumption of liability ultimately depend on legal provisions rather than the subjective expectations of the parties. The same applies to the determination of guarantee methods. If there is no specific stipulation, the legal rules shall apply, and one cannot arbitrarily claim joint and several liability based on assumptions.
The experience in handling such difficult cases can be applied to guarantee disputes: First, we need to thoroughly sort out the contract text, performance certificates, and the timeline of fund transactions, and first establish the facts before discussing the application of law; Second, for clauses with questionable validity, we should check them one by one according to mandatory provisions and statutory presumption rules, and not rely on the other party's inevitable recognition; Third, manage procedural nodes by the day, and leave no gaps in appeals and enforcement applications. In guarantee contract disputes, the three issues of guarantee methods, guarantee periods, and prior suit defenses are interconnected, and we also need to proceed in this order.
IV. Practical Suggestions and Legal Basis
The legal basis mainly includes Article 686 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) on the presumption rules of guarantee methods, Article 687 on the right of prior litigation defense and exceptional circumstances of general guarantees, and Articles 692 and 693 on the rules of guarantee periods and exemption from guarantee responsibilities; the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Guarantee System of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China" (effective January 1, 2021) provides a more detailed explanation of the identification standards, which can be referred to when dealing with special circumstances such as guarantees by branch offices and the effectiveness of company guarantee resolutions.
Advice for creditors: When signing the contract, clearly state the guarantee method, guarantee period, and guarantee scope, and use standard expressions for guarantee with joint and several liability; before litigation, check whether the guarantee period has passed. In the case of general guarantees, first sue the debtor and obtain the final judgment on the inability to enforce the debt. Advice for guarantors: Before signing, clarify the order of liability and the scope of the guarantee, and keep copies of the main contract and communication records; if it is a general guarantee, timely raise the defense of prior suit in the litigation. For case evaluation and document review, please refer to the following materials:Professional legal services for contract disputes.
The cost and duration can be predicted in advance: the first-instance ordinary procedure is generally concluded within six months, and the summary procedure is within three months. The second-instance procedure is generally within three months. The litigation fees are calculated in accordance with the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" based on the amount of the claim, and the attorney's fees are determined by the entrustment contract. If the creditor's claim includes the cost of realizing the claim, the attorney's fees can be specified in the request and accompanied by receipts, and the court will review whether to support it. The aim is to make the defaulting party pay the cost of the delay.
5. Hengluo Law Firm's Advice
The difference of a single word in the guarantee method results in vastly different responsibilities. Under a general guarantee, the guarantor enjoys subordinate interests and the right of first-action defense. Under a joint and several guarantee, the creditor can directly enforce the guarantor's property. The two have completely different impacts on family assets and corporate cash flow. Before signing the guarantee contract, carefully read the terms clause by clause and, if necessary, consult a lawyer for review. The cost of doing so is far lower than being involved in litigation afterwards. When guaranteeing for others, we should also assess our own repayment ability at the same time and never sign the contract out of courtesy.
The guarantee period is another time limit that is easily overlooked: six months is the statutory default value, and the guarantee obligation will be extinguished after the guarantee period. Both the creditor and the guarantor should include the expiration date of the main debt performance period and the start and end dates of the guarantee period in the ledger management to avoid rights being extinguished in silence or obligations being increased without knowledge.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If the guarantor hasn't written down the guarantee method, do they still have to repay the money?
It needs to be repaid, but the order of responsibility is different. According to Article 686 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China, if there is no agreement on the guarantee method or the agreement is unclear, the guarantor shall bear the guarantee liability according to the general guarantee. The guarantor enjoys the right of prior defense, and the creditor must first file a lawsuit against the debtor's property and enforce it by force. If the creditor still cannot be compensated, he can then claim against the guarantor. If the creditor fails to exercise his rights according to law within the guarantee period, the guarantee liability may also be directly exempted. Therefore, the creditor should claim in time, and the guarantor should not refuse to pay in general. Instead, he should first review whether the guarantee method and period have passed, and then decide on the defense strategy. It should also be noted that the creditor's sending a reminder letter to the general guarantor during the guarantee period cannot replace the action of suing or arbitrating against the debtor. Missing the deadline and sending the letter later cannot recover the guarantee liability.
Q2: How to exercise the right of prior litigation defense under a general guarantee?
The right of prior recourse is a procedural defensive weapon for general guarantors. If the creditor fails to file a lawsuit or apply for arbitration against the debtor, or fails to enforce the debtor's property according to law and still cannot perform the obligation, and directly sues the guarantor, the guarantor may raise a defense against this. The court usually does not support the guarantor's prior request. Article 687 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China also stipulates exceptions: when the debtor's whereabouts are unknown and there is no property available for enforcement, the court has accepted the debtor's bankruptcy case, or the creditor has evidence to prove that the debtor's property is insufficient to fulfill all debts, the guarantor shall not refuse to assume responsibility. The exercise of the defense shall be raised in writing within the time limit for providing evidence and stating reasons. The creditor shall prepare clues to the debtor's property and evidence of enforcement failure in advance to avoid repeated postponements due to procedural issues during the trial stage.
Q3: If there's no agreement on the warranty period, how long is it by default?
Six months. According to Article 692 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China, if the guarantee contract does not stipulate or stipulate an unclear guarantee period, the guarantee period shall be six months from the date of the expiration of the performance period of the principal obligation. In general guarantees, the creditor shall initiate litigation or apply for arbitration against the debtor within this period; in joint and several liability guarantees, the creditor shall request the guarantor to assume the guarantee liability. If the guarantee period expires without being exercised in accordance with the law, the guarantee liability shall be extinguished. The guarantee period is a fixed period and is not subject to the rules of suspension, interruption, and extension of the statute of limitations. Any part of the guarantee period exceeding two years that is agreed upon by the parties may also be deemed invalid. Both the reminder and the lawsuit must be carried out within the specified timeframes.
Q4: When a creditor files a lawsuit, who should be listed as the defendant?
It depends on the type of guarantee. For general guarantees, the creditor should first sue the debtor in principle. If the debtor cannot be compensated through forced enforcement, the creditor can then sue the guarantor; if the creditor only sues the general guarantor, the court will usually add the debtor to the lawsuit or dismiss the claim first. For joint and several liability guarantees, the debtor and the guarantor can be listed as co-defendants and claimed together, which saves time in the litigation process. When in doubt, the creditor can first handle it as a general guarantee and apply for preservation of the debtor's property at the same time, or entrust a lawyer to make a judgment based on the contract provisions and Articles 686 and 687 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China to avoid having the lawsuit dismissed due to incorrect listing of defendants. In terms of jurisdiction, guarantee contract disputes can be tried together with the main debt disputes, and the court that is conducive to clarifying the facts can significantly shorten the overall litigation period.
Q5: What should I pay attention to when signing the supplementary guarantee agreement?
There are five key points that must be addressed in the guarantee agreement: 1. **Guarantee type**: Specify whether it is a general guarantee or a joint and several guarantee. 2. **Guarantee period**: It is recommended to state the period starting from the date of the expiration of the principal debt's repayment term and extending for a specified number of years. 3. **Guarantee scope**: Include the principal, interest, penalties, and expenses incurred in enforcing the creditor's rights. 4. **Signatory's identity**: For companies providing guarantees, it is necessary to verify the resolution of the shareholders' meeting or the board of directors to avoid invalid guarantees issued beyond authority. 5. **Modification of the main contract**: The guarantor must consent in writing to any changes, otherwise the guarantor will be exempt from liability for the increased obligations. When signing the agreement, all parties should review each item in accordance with the relevant rules of Articles 681 to 701 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China. After signing, each party should keep an original copy and scan it for archiving to prevent future disputes over the authenticity of the document.
The above answer is based on the judicial practice in Beijing. The judicial interpretations in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.
If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the necessary evidence, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Business and commercial legal services·Attorney Wu Jiani·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.