[Direct answer]When the guarantor is tricked by the debtor and a third party, there are legal solutions available. According to Article 154 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), civil legal acts that harm the legitimate rights and interests of others through malicious collusion between the actor and the counterparty are invalid. Therefore, the guarantor can claim that the relevant contract is invalid and be exempted from the guarantee obligation; if the guarantor has already compensated for the debtor, he/she can recover the compensation from the debtor in accordance with Article 700. The success or failure of such cases depends on the proof of collusion. The guarantor should immediately preserve evidence such as fund transaction records, chat logs, and related relationships. If necessary, he/she can initiate a lawsuit to confirm the invalidity of the contract and simultaneously apply for property preservation or submit clues for criminal reporting. The earlier the action is taken, the better the preservation effect of the evidence chain and the responsible property will be.

I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios

In the guarantee chain, the guarantor is naturally at an information disadvantage and can only rely on the one-way information provided by the debtor and the creditor. Typical scenarios include: the debtor and the counterparty fabricate the main debt and then ask the guarantor to provide a guarantee; the debtor conceals the fact that the main contract has been extended or increased, thereby increasing the guarantor's liability without their knowledge; the debtor transfers assets to related parties through fictitious transactions before facing bankruptcy, leaving an empty shell for the guarantee structure; and the debtor colludes with third parties to fabricate false litigation, transferring the property to others through mediation agreements, leaving the guarantor with no assets to recover after compensating for the debt. The situation where a company's legal representative personally borrows money and then has related companies guarantee each other further entangles multiple entities in a web of risks.

These operations have one thing in common: they appear to follow all the necessary procedures, but in reality, they are colluding to strip the guarantor of their liable assets. Guarantors often only realize the abnormality when creditors come to demand repayment or when their accounts are frozen, by which time several months or even years may have passed since the signing of the contract. Evidence is scattered among multiple parties, and the window for seeking legal redress has already closed. By the time the judgment takes effect and they try to recover the assets, there are often only empty shell accounts that have already been put on hold for seizure.

II. Key points of contention

One of the focuses is the standard for determining the fact of collusion. Malicious collusion requires proof that both parties have a common intent to harm others. If only the debtor commits fraud on his own and the third party is merely aware of it, the court may not necessarily rule it invalid. The evidence must form a closed loop, such as the record of funds flowing back and the chat records corroborating each other, in order to pass a higher-intensity judicial review. In judicial practice, courts are cautious about isolated evidence. Relying solely on a transfer certificate or a unilateral audio recording is usually not enough to overturn the effectiveness of the contract.

The second focus is the choice of the liability path. If the main contract is invalid due to malicious collusion, the guarantee liability will be extinguished accordingly; if the main contract is still valid but the debtor damages the guarantor's interests through acts such as transferring property, the guarantor will need to pursue the right of recourse or compensation for infringement. The two paths differ in the burden of proof, the jurisdiction of the court, the commencement of the statute of limitations, and the methods of preservation. Choosing the wrong direction will waste precious litigation opportunities. In mixed situations, parallel claims can also be pursued. The invalidation suit resolves the exemption of liability, and the recourse suit resolves the recovery of the compensation. The two lines do not conflict with each other.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm

When handling guarantee disputes, Hengluo Lawyers noticed that the most common mistake made by guarantors is to only focus on the guarantee contract itself, while neglecting to verify the authenticity of the principal creditor-debtor relationship. An effective approach is to conduct a reverse investigation: retrieve the fund flow records before and after the signing of the main contract, compare the agreed loan purpose with the actual flow direction; apply for a court investigation order to retrieve the debtor's litigation records and enforcement information; search for the debtor's equity, employment, and kinship connections with the counterparty, and piece together the scattered clues into a complete picture. When necessary, it is also possible to apply for the retrieval of reconciliation materials during the pledging period to verify whether the principal debt amount matches the records on the books.

In terms of judicial rulings, the court sets a high standard of proof for malicious collusion, but its attitude towards cases with sufficient evidence is clear: if the main contract is invalid, the guarantee obligation will be extinguished accordingly, and the part of the guarantee that has been repaid by the guarantor can be recovered from the debtor in accordance with Article 700 of the Civil Code; if the debtor and the third party jointly commit infringement, the debtor can also claim that the two parties should bear joint and several liability for compensation. Judicial documents generally emphasize the corroborative relationship between evidence, and isolated evidence is difficult to support the claim of invalidity. For false debts that have been settled through litigation or mediation, it is also possible to seek correction through a third-party action for rescission or judicial supervision procedures.

There are two timelines that must be remembered: Firstly, the right of recourse obtained by the guarantor after assuming the guarantee liability is subject to a three-year statute of limitations, which starts from the date on which the actual assumption of liability takes place; Secondly, with regard to the debtor's act of transferring property free of charge or at a low price, the right of revocation should be exercised within one year from the date on which the debtor knows or should have known the grounds for revocation. Exercise of the right beyond the time limit will result in the loss of the right. Once the time limit is missed, even the most conclusive evidence will not be able to remedy the situation. It is much more effective to mark the time limits on the case management form than to make up for it afterwards.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

The main legal basis is Article 154 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), which stipulates that acts of malicious collusion are invalid; Article 149, which stipulates that fraud by a third party is invalid; Article 695, which stipulates that increasing the debt without the written consent of the guarantor is not effective; and Article 700, which establishes the right of recourse. For the part involving false litigation, it is also necessary to compare the provisions of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China on the crime of false litigation to determine whether it meets the standards for criminal prosecution.

It is recommended to take the following actions in the following order: First, immediately preserve the evidence, including the original contract, transfer records, chat logs, call recordings, and industrial and commercial registration information. Important electronic evidence should be notarized simultaneously; Second, entrust a lawyer to issue an evaluation opinion to determine whether to initiate a lawsuit to confirm the invalidity, defend against the lawsuit, or pursue recovery; Third, apply for property preservation simultaneously in the lawsuit to freeze the accounts of the debtor and the party assisting in transferring the property; Fourth, if there is suspicion of false litigation or contract fraud, submit the materials to the public security organ for reporting. Criminal procedures often facilitate civil settlements; Fifth, maintain communication with other creditors to avoid acting independently and missing the opportunity for distribution. The organization of evidence materials should be carried out throughout the entire process. The materials should be cataloged and archived according to the timeline and be available for use at any time during the litigation process.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder

Before providing a guarantee for others, it is essential to verify the authenticity of the principal debt and the debtor's asset status, and require the debtor to provide a description of the use of the funds and financial information. During the guarantee period, once the principal contract is extended or modified, insist on confirming it in writing and reassessing the scope of responsibility. These practices can prevent most collusion risks from occurring before signing the contract. For unfamiliar counterparties, you can first check their litigation and enforcement information before deciding whether to provide a guarantee.

Guarantors who have been involved in disputes do not need to panic too much. The judiciary's consistent and clear attitude towards malicious collusion is that the difficulty lies in providing evidence, which can be achieved through actions. It is necessary to complete the preparations before the evidence is lost, the property is transferred, and the statute of limitations expires. Panicking will only waste time, and a systematic response is the real way to reduce risks. For case evaluations involving corporate commercial contract disputes, please refer to the relevant materials.Business commercial contract dispute resolution servicesOn the dedicated page, determine the response plan as soon as possible.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Is the guarantee contract signed under the collusion still valid?

It's necessary to distinguish the different situations. If the debtor and the creditor collude maliciously to fabricate debts or conceal important facts to induce the guarantor to provide guarantees, according to Article 154 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021), the relevant civil legal acts are invalid, and the guarantor can claim not to bear the guarantee responsibility; if it's only the debtor who conceals the facts unilaterally, the guarantee contract may not be invalid, but the guarantor can still enjoy the debtor's defense against the creditor according to Article 701. Whether it constitutes collusion depends on whether the evidence such as the flow of funds, communication records, and the relationship between the two parties can corroborate each other. It is recommended to conduct an evidence evaluation first and then determine the claim path. When evaluating, it may be helpful to estimate the scope of responsibility under the two outcomes at the same time, so as to avoid making decisions only based on the most favorable situation.

Q2: What evidence do I need to submit to prove that the other party colluded with each other?

Common evidence can be divided into four groups: First, financial evidence, including transfer records and repayment records under the main contract, used to prove that the funds were nominally paid but actually flowed back; Second, communication evidence, including WeChat chats, emails, and call recordings, used to prove that the two parties colluded in advance; Third, related evidence, including industrial and commercial registration, equity structure, and employment information, used to prove that the debtor and his counterparty have an interest relationship; Fourth, procedural evidence, including litigation files and mediation transcripts, used to reveal traces of fraudulent litigation. The evidence should form a corroborative chain, and a single record is usually insufficient to support the determination of malicious collusion. When organizing the evidence, it should be classified and numbered according to the above four groups, which will make the cross-examination in court more organized.

Q3: Approximately how much does it cost to litigate a case like this?

The litigation fees are calculated in accordance with the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" based on the amount of the litigation request. Claims for the invalidation of contracts are usually calculated based on property-related requests, and the losing party shall bear or share the fees proportionally after the plaintiff wins the case. Lawyer's fees depend on the complexity of the case and the amount of the subject matter. Collusive cases typically involve large amounts of evidence collection and multiple procedural steps, so the fees are generally higher than those of ordinary contract disputes. The specific fees shall be determined in accordance with the entrustment contract. Property preservation requires providing guarantees, and insurance company guarantees can be used to reduce the need for cash deposits. It is recommended to estimate the three types of expenses (evidence collection, litigation, and preservation) before filing a lawsuit, and then determine the overall strategy. A scheme with transparent fee structures is less likely to lead to secondary disputes during the execution process.

Q4: Is there a time limit for claiming exemption from the guarantee obligation?

It is necessary to distinguish the nature of the requests. Requests to confirm the invalidity of the contract itself are not subject to the statute of limitations, but requests for the return of property and compensation for losses under the consequences of the invalidity are subject to a three-year statute of limitations; the guarantor's right to recover from the debtor in accordance with Article 700 of the Civil Code is calculated from the date of actually assuming the guarantee responsibility for three years; for exercising the right of revocation against the transfer of property, it is generally necessary to raise the claim within one year from the date when the revocation grounds become known or should have become known. The passage of the statute of limitations will result in the loss of defenses and rights of claim, so after discovering signs of collusion, it is necessary to fix the evidence as soon as possible and assert the claim within the time limit. If necessary, it is better to sue first and then supplement the evidence. Reversing the various time limits into a timeline is the most basic task in such cases.

Q5: What is the first thing to do after discovering that you've been tricked?

The first step is to freeze the situation: stop communicating with the other party for confirmation, immediately back up and notarize key electronic evidence to prevent the account from being suspended or the records from being deleted. The second step is to simultaneously entrust a lawyer to conduct an overall assessment of the validity of the main contract, the flow of funds, and the path of responsibility, and determine whether to initiate a lawsuit to confirm the invalidity first or to defend against the lawsuit first. The third step is to evaluate the parallel measures of property preservation and criminal reporting. Preservation prevents the continued loss of property, and reporting relies on investigative forces to obtain information that individuals cannot obtain. It is best to initiate all three steps within two weeks, as delaying will only make the burden of proof increasingly difficult. Each step should leave written records, so that there will be evidence to refer to if questioned in the future.

The above answer is based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. The judicial interpretation in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.

If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, so as to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Business and commercial legal services·Beijing Henglu Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.