[Case Summary]This case is a case of administrative reconsideration concerning the supervision of village affairs disclosure. The applicant, Zhang **, enjoys the right to contract and operate 50 mu of land in Shuguang Village, XX Town, A County, Heilongjiang Province. A portion of the contracted land involved in the case was subject to expropriation. To clarify the information about the expropriation of the contracted land, Zhang ** submitted a request for village affairs disclosure to the Shuguang Village Committee, demanding the disclosure of four items of village affairs information regarding the area of his 50 mu of contracted land. However, the village committee failed to fulfill its obligation to disclose the information in accordance with the law. On March 2, 2026, Zhang ** mailed the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" to the XX Town People's Government via EMS, and the mail was signed for receipt by the town government's reception office on the same day. After receiving the application, the town government neither conducted an investigation and verification nor ordered the village committee to disclose the information, nor provided any written response. The core disputes include: whether the town government has a statutory supervision duty over the village committee's village affairs disclosure; whether its failure to investigate and respond after signing for receipt constitutes administrative omission; whether the voting by the party members' conference of the village committee in accordance with the "Four-Discussion and Two-Disclosure" system can replace the statutory village affairs disclosure; and how to handle the situation where the respondent fails to provide evidence to prove its performance of duties. Beijing Henglu Law FirmZhai Chao LiAfter the lawyer took over the case, the argument was conducted around three aspects: whether there is a duty, whether the duty has been performed, and how to determine the omission of duty. According to Article 36 of the Organic Law of the Villagers' Committee and Article 66 of the Administrative Reconsideration Law, the reconsideration organ ordered the town government to deal with the supervision application within 20 days from the date of receiving the decision letter.

I. Review of the case

How to handle the situation where the village does not publicly disclose land expropriation compensation information? Is it considered negligence of duty if no one responds to the supervision application sent to the town government? How to appeal against the evasion of responsibility when applying for village affairs disclosure? Does holding a party member meeting automatically constitute public disclosure of information? These questions are particularly concentrated in the field of land expropriation and demolition. In this case, the party concerned, Zhang ***, enjoys the right to contract and operate 50 mu of land in Shuguang Village, XX Town, A County, Heilongjiang Province. A portion of the contracted land involved in the case was subject to expropriation. After the land was expropriated, information such as the compensation standards, distribution plans, expropriation scope, and identification of aboveground attachments directly affect their vital interests, but this information has never been fully disclosed within the village.

In order to obtain information about the land expropriation in the village within the scope of his contracted land, Zhang * submitted an application for village affairs disclosure to the Shuguang Village Committee, requesting the disclosure of four pieces of village affairs information in the area of his 50 mu of contracted land. However, after receiving the application, the Shuguang Village Committee failed to fulfill its obligation to disclose village affairs in accordance with the law, neither providing the relevant materials for review nor issuing a written explanation.

On March 2, 2026, in order to safeguard his own rights, Zhang * * * mailed the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" to the People's Government of XX Town via EMS, requesting the town government to fulfill its statutory supervision duties and urge Shuguang Village Committee to implement village affairs disclosure. The mail was signed for receipt by the reception office of the People's Government of XX Town on the same day, and the delivery track could be traced clearly. However, after the town government signed for receipt of the supervision application, it neither carried out investigation and verification work nor ordered Shuguang Village Committee to disclose the corresponding village affairs information. It never gave any written reply to Zhang * * *, and the supervision application was shelved.

Under the circumstances that the handling result was delayed for a long time, Zhang * entrusted Beijing Henglue Law Firm to handle the matter for him/her.Zhi Chao LiThe lawyer helped safeguard the rights and interests of the client. On June 23, 2026, Attorney Xie, on behalf of Zhang **, filed an application for administrative reconsideration with the People's Government of A County, with the request that the People's Government of XX Town be found guilty of violating its duty to supervise the disclosure of village affairs; and that the town government be ordered to handle the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" submitted on March 2, 2026 in accordance with the law, and to provide a written response to the applicant regarding the handling results.

II. The focus of the case

  • Is there a responsibility: Does the township people's government have a statutory supervision duty to investigate and verify whether the villagers' committees in its jurisdiction have carried out the work of making village affairs public, order them to make the information public according to law, and provide feedback to the applicants? Is this responsibility conditional on the villagers filing complaints separately?
  • Whether the duty has been performed: The town government's reception office has signed for the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Openness", but thereafter, it failed to investigate, order, or respond. Does this constitute administrative omission of failing to perform statutory duties? Who should bear the burden of proof?
  • Can it replace: the village committee holding a party member meeting to vote on the distribution of land expropriation compensation according to the "Four-Discussions and Two-Openness" procedure; can it replace the village committee's obligation to disclose village affairs in accordance with the law; and can it exempt the town government from its supervisory duties?

III. The professional intervention of Hengluo Law Firm

Both parties' arguments and defenses:The applicant, Zhang **, claimed that he enjoys the right to contract and operate 50 mu of land in Shuguang Village. The land involved in the case was expropriated, and the four village affairs information he applied to disclose is directly related to his personal interests. After receiving the application, the village committee failed to disclose the information in accordance with the law. On March 2, 2026, Zhang ** submitted a supervision application to the town government by EMS and received a receipt, but the town government failed to investigate, order, or respond, constituting administrative omission. The respondent, XX Town People's Government, argued in its defense that the Shuguang Village Village Committee had carried out relevant work in accordance with the "Four-Discussion and Two-Publicity" procedures, held a party member meeting to vote on the distribution of land expropriation compensation, and fulfilled the obligation of public notice. Zhang **'s reasons for appeal were unfounded, and it was requested to reject all the appeal applications. At the same time, it was proposed that the Shuguang Village Village Committee should be added as a third party to the appeal.

Firstly, clarify the statutory supervision responsibilities of the town government.Zhi Chao LiThe lawyer pointed out that according to Article 36 of the Organic Law of the Villagers' Committee, the town government, as the town people's government to which the Shuguang Village Committee belongs, has the statutory supervision duty to investigate and verify the village affairs disclosure work of the villagers' committee in its jurisdiction and order the disclosure in accordance with the law. After the applicant submits a written supervision application, the town government shall conduct an investigation according to law to verify whether the village committee has failed to disclose the village affairs information that should be disclosed, and make corresponding handling according to the investigation results, and inform the applicant of the handling results. This duty is directly set by law and does not require the applicant to file a separate petition or complaint.

Secondly, we need to establish the fact of receipt and demonstrate that the defendant failed to fulfill its statutory duties.Attorney Xi pointed out that Zhang * * * had submitted the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" through EMS on March 2, 2026, and the mail was received by the mailroom of XX Town on the same day. The delivery track and the signing record were complete. However, after receiving the application, the town government did not carry out substantive investigation and verification work, did not order Shuguang Village Committee to disclose relevant village affairs information, and did not give a written reply to the applicant about the handling results, which constituted administrative omission. The signing of the mailroom belongs to the internal receipt and circulation of the organ, and the legal consequences should be borne by the organ. It cannot shirk responsibility by saying that "the handling department did not receive it".

Thirdly, refute the defense that "the vote at the party member conference replaces public disclosure".In its response, the respondent argued that the Shuguang Village Village Committee once held a party member meeting to vote on the land expropriation compensation distribution matters in accordance with the "Four-Discussion and Two-Publicity" procedure, but the vote failed. Therefore, the respondent claimed that the applicant's grounds for appeal were unfounded. Attorney Xie pointed out that the public disclosure of village affairs is a statutory duty of the village committee, and the objects of disclosure are all villagers, and the content of disclosure is statutory village affairs. The vote on the land expropriation compensation distribution matters by the party member meeting belongs to the village-level democratic decision-making procedure, and cannot replace the village committee's statutory obligation to disclose village affairs, nor can it exempt the town government from its statutory duties of investigation and verification, ordering disclosure, and responding. Whether the decision is passed or not is a different issue from whether the information should be disclosed.

Fourthly, it points out that the respondent is unable to provide evidence to support their claims.During the administrative reconsideration process, although the respondent submitted a written response, it failed to provide evidence to prove that it had fulfilled its duties of supervising the disclosure of village affairs—there were no investigation and verification records, on-site verification records, written documents ordering disclosure, or proof of feedback to the applicant on the handling results. Combined with evidence such as the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" in the case and mailing inquiry records, it is sufficient to determine that the town government failed to make any response or handling after receiving the supervision application. According to the rule that the defendant in administrative reconsideration bears the burden of proof for the legality of its administrative actions, the failure to provide evidence shall result in adverse consequences for the defendant.

IV. Outcome of the case

The review organ believes that, according to Article 36 of the Organic Law of the Villagers' Committees of the People's Republic of China, the town government has the statutory supervisory duty to investigate and verify the work of village affairs disclosure carried out by the villagers' committees within its jurisdiction, and to order them to disclose information in accordance with the law. After the applicant submits a written supervision application, the town government shall conduct an investigation in accordance with the law to verify whether the Shuguang Village Villagers' Committee has failed to disclose information on village affairs that should be disclosed, and make corresponding handling according to the investigation results and inform the applicant of the handling results. The existing evidence in this case cannot confirm that the town government has fulfilled its statutory duties of investigation and verification, ordering disclosure, or responding after receiving the "Village Affairs Disclosure Supervision Application", which constitutes a failure to perform its statutory duties.

According to Article 66 of the Administrative Reconsideration Law of the People's Republic of China, the reconsideration organ decides: to order the respondent, XX Town People's Government, to deal with the applicant Zhang **'s "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" within 20 days from the date of receipt of this decision; and to inform the applicant that if he/she is not satisfied with this decision, he/she may, within 15 days from the date of receipt of the decision, file an administrative lawsuit with the people's court in accordance with the law.

The main norms applicable to this case include: Article 36 of the "Organic Law of the Villagers' Committees of the People's Republic of China", which stipulates that if the villagers' committees fail to perform their statutory obligations in accordance with laws and regulations, the people's governments of townships, nationality townships, and towns shall order them to make corrections, clarifying the supervisory responsibilities of the town governments over the villagers' committee's work of open government affairs in their jurisdictions; the provisions of the law requiring the villagers' committees to promptly announce matters involving the villagers' interests and accept the villagers' inquiries and supervision form the basis of the applicant's right to apply for disclosure; Article 66 of the "Administrative Review Law of the People's Republic of China", which stipulates that if the respondent fails to perform its statutory duties, the administrative review organ shall decide that it shall perform them within a certain period of time, is the direct basis for the review decision in this case; at the same time, reference is made to the relevant provisions of the law on the burden of proof in administrative review and the respondent's obligation to bear the burden of proof for the legality of its administrative acts.

5. Hengluo Law Firm's Advice

The village committee has a statutory obligation to disclose village affairs publicly; if villagers find that the village committee fails to disclose information in a timely manner or that the disclosed information is untrue, they have the right to report the matter to the township people's government. The township government has a statutory supervisory obligation to investigate and verify the matter, order the village committee to disclose information in accordance with the law, and provide feedback on the handling of the matter. It cannot equate the voting at internal meetings of the village committee with statutory disclosure of village affairs, nor can it ignore the villagers' requests for supervision. This case was handled by Beijing Henglu Law Firm.Zhai Chao LiAttorney (Practice Certificate No.: 11101202311629788, subject to the document issued by the judicial administrative organ): Based on case handling experience, we advise as follows: First, the application must be specific. When applying for village affairs disclosure, please list the name, year, scope, and purpose of the requested information item by item, avoiding general statements such as "disclose all village affairs". Otherwise, the authority may delay the process by citing "unclear content". Second, mailing receipts are crucial evidence. Submitting the application via EMS and retaining the detailed delivery records, delivery track, and signature confirmation are key to proving that the authority has received the application. In this case, the fact was confirmed by the "receipt by the dispatch office on the same day" record. Third, focus on statutory duties rather than administrative responses. The supervisory duties of township governments are directly mandated by law. Responses from authorities such as "already provided via complaint response", "already discussed at meetings", or "already issued reminder letters" do not constitute full performance of duties. In the review process, you can point out their failure to investigate, order rectification, or provide feedback. Fourth, ensure timely coordination between review and litigation. For applications challenging statutory duty failures, you must file within the statutory time limit. If you disagree with the review decision, you can initiate administrative litigation within 15 days of receiving the decision letter to avoid missing the filing deadline. Fifth, secure information on land expropriation compensation early. After land expropriation, materials such as plot boundaries, compensation standards, and distribution plans may become difficult to retrieve over time. It is recommended to collect evidence via village affairs disclosure and government information disclosure channels at the initial stage of expropriation to preserve the basis for future legal protection.

VI. Common Questions and FAQs about Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure and Access to Land Acquisition Information

  1. Q: If the village does not disclose information on land expropriation compensation, what content can villagers request to be disclosed? A: Villagers can request the disclosure of village affairs directly related to their own rights and interests, typically including the scope and location of the land expropriation, the standards and total amount of land expropriation compensation, the distribution plan and disbursement details of the compensation, the list of compensation for fixtures and seedlings on the land, resolutions of villagers' meetings or villagers' representative meetings, and the situation of land contracting and adjustment. When making the request, villagers should specify the name and year of the information item by item. The more specific the scope is, the harder it will be for administrative authorities to evade responsibility by citing "unclear content".
  2. Q: I sent an application for supervision of village affairs disclosure to the town government, but I haven't received any response. What should I do? A: You can first confirm the fact of receipt, then initiate a review or litigation. Keep the EMS detail list, delivery track and receipt records. The administrative organ's performance period shall be calculated from the date of submission of the application; if the organ still fails to investigate, order or respond after the expiration of the period, you can apply for administrative review to confirm the violation of its statutory duties and order it to perform within a specified time limit, or directly file an administrative lawsuit with the court.
  3. Q: If the village committee holds a party member meeting and follows the "Four-Discussion and Two-Publicity" process, does that mean the information has been made public? A: No. The voting process at the party member meeting or the villagers' representative meeting is a village-level democratic decision-making procedure, addressing the question of "how to determine the matter." Village affairs publicity is a legal obligation, addressing the question of "how to inform the villagers of the information." The two cannot substitute for each other. Even if the voting fails, it does not mean that the information does not need to be made public, nor does it exempt township governments from their supervisory responsibilities.
  4. Q: If the town government has signed and received the application but said "it hasn't been forwarded to the handling department", does this count as having fulfilled their duties? A: Generally, this does not count. The receipt by the office of the organ is deemed as the organ having received it. Internal circulation belongs to the organ's own management matters, and the legal consequences shall be borne by the organ. Whether the duties have been fulfilled depends on whether the organ has actually conducted investigations and verifications, issued written orders for disclosure, and provided feedback to the applicant. If the organ only signs and receives the application or issues reminder letters and supervision letters without substantive processing and feedback, it generally cannot be considered as having fully fulfilled its duties.
  5. Q: If I'm not satisfied with the decision of the administrative reconsideration, can I still file a lawsuit? A: Yes, you can. After the reconsideration organ orders the administrative organ to perform its duties within a specified time limit, if the administrative organ still fails to handle the matter within the time limit, or if the applicant is not satisfied with the reconsideration decision itself, he/she may file an administrative lawsuit with the people's court within 15 days from the date of receipt of the decision, requesting the court to order the administrative organ to perform its statutory duties. When filing the lawsuit, the applicant should submit evidence such as the reconsideration decision, the supervision application, and the postal receipt, to form a complete chain of requests for the performance of duties.