[Case Summary]This case involves a supervision of village affairs disclosure and administrative review. The applicant, Xu **, is a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village, Qianjin Town, A District, Harbin City, Heilongjiang Province. Her father, Xu ***, was allocated 1.5 mu of grain fields and 6 mu of contracted land in the first round of land distribution in 1983. However, 7.5 mu of land was later recovered. To clarify the facts of land contracting and recovery, Xu ** sent three letters to the Shuguang Village Villagers' Committee on May 11, 19, and 25, 2026, requesting the disclosure of the original land allocation records and the text of the land contract. The village committee responded by refusing to accept the letters, signing for receipt and returning them, without providing any written or oral response. Xu ** then sent a letter to the Qianjin Subdistrict Office of A District, Harbin City, requesting supervision of village affairs disclosure. However, the subdistrict office failed to handle the case in accordance with the law, prompting Xu ** to apply for administrative review. The core disputes include: whether villagers have the right to request disclosure of village affairs information related to their own rights and interests; whether the village committee's refusal to accept the application constitutes a failure to fulfill its statutory obligations; whether the subdistrict office has the supervisory duty to investigate and order disclosure; and whether the petition process can replace the performance of supervision duties related to village affairs disclosure. Beijing Henglu Law FirmSong MeinaAfter the lawyer took over the case, he fully fixed the three mailing receipts and supervised the application materials. He argued that the petition supervision and the supervision of village affairs disclosure are two independent legal procedures. The review organ, in accordance with Article 31 of the "Village Committee Organization Law" and Article 66 of the "Administrative Review Law", ordered the sub-district office to perform its statutory duties within 60 days, and urged the village committee to give a formal written reply and feedback on the results of the handling.
I. Review of the case facts
"What should I do if they refuse to let me see the open village affairs?" "Does the village committee's refusal to accept the application count as a failure to perform its duties?" "How to appeal against the rejection of the application for open village affairs?" "I went to the street office to report the village's failure to disclose information, but the street office said it's not their responsibility - who should I turn to?" These issues have long troubled many villagers. The applicant in this case, Xu ***, is a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village, Qianjin Town, A District, Harbin City, Heilongjiang Province. In 1983, during the first round of land distribution in Shuguang Village, her father, Xu ***, was allocated 1.5 mu of food-producing land and 6 mu of contracted land, totaling 7.5 mu, and signed a land contract. Subsequently, the aforementioned 7.5 mu of land was recovered. However, Xu *** has never received a clear explanation from the village regarding the basis, timing, and compensation for the land recovery.
In order to clarify the relevant facts of land contracting and recovery and safeguard his own legitimate rights and interests, Xu * * * decided to apply for village affairs disclosure in accordance with the law. On May 11, May 19, and May 25, 2026, he mailed the "Application for Village Affairs Disclosure" to the Shuguang Village Villagers' Committee three times, requesting the disclosure of the original land distribution ledger (including land location and area information) of the grain-producing fields in the village, as well as the land contracting contract of his father, Xu * * *. These two materials are directly related to the boundaries of his family's land rights and fall within the statutory scope of village affairs disclosure. However, the village committee handled the three applications by refusing to accept them, returning them after signing the receipt, and never providing any written or oral response to Xu * * *, nor did it explain the reasons for the refusal.
In the face of the village committee's persistent lack of response, Xu ** mailed the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" to the Advance Street Office of A District of Harbin City on June 4, 2026, requesting the street office to perform its statutory supervision duties and order the Shuguang Village Committee to disclose the relevant village affairs information in accordance with the law. However, after receiving the supervision application, the respondent neither conducted an investigation and verification nor ordered the village committee to disclose the information, nor provided any response to the applicant. The supervision application was shelved.
After completing the two procedures of applying within the village and administrative supervision, there was still no result. Xu * * * entrusted Beijing Henglu Law Firm to handle the matter for him/her.Song MeinaThe lawyer applied for administrative reconsideration to the People's Government of A District of Harbin City, requesting that it confirm that the Street Office's failure to perform its duty of supervising the disclosure of village affairs is illegal, and order it to perform its duties within a specified time limit.
II. The focus of the case
- Applicant and scope of the matter: As a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village, does Xu ** have the right to apply for the disclosure of the original land distribution ledger and land contract directly related to the land rights of his household? Having moved away from the village for many years, does this affect the exercise of his right to apply for village affairs disclosure and his right to information?
- The nature of the village committee's actions: After sending three applications for village affairs disclosure by mail, the village committee refused to accept the mail, sent it back after signing for it, and refused to respond. Does this constitute a failure to fulfill the statutory obligation of village affairs disclosure as stipulated in the "Village Committee Organization Law"?
- Does the sub-district office fulfill its duties and can petitions replace it? Does the sub-district office have the legal responsibility to investigate and verify the villagers' supervision applications and order disclosure? Can the land claims be responded to through the petition channel, exempting it from the administrative supervision duties it should fulfill regarding the supervision applications for village affairs disclosure? Does the issuance of a reminder letter after the case is registered for reconsideration constitute a complete fulfillment of its duties?
III. Professional intervention by Hengluo Law Firm
Both parties' arguments and defenses:The applicant, Xu **, claimed that he is a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village, and the land distribution ledger and land contracting contracts in the case directly relate to his family's land rights. He legally enjoys the right to apply for village affairs disclosure, the right to know and the right to supervision. The village committee refused to accept and return his application three times and refused to respond, which constitutes a failure to fulfill its statutory obligations. After receiving the supervision application, the A District Qianjin Subdistrict Office of Harbin City failed to investigate, order or respond, constituting administrative omission. The respondent, A District Qianjin Subdistrict Office of Harbin City, replied that it did not find the logistics information corresponding to the "Village Affairs Disclosure Supervision Application" submitted by Xu ** and did not actually receive the application. It regularly supervises villages to implement the "Three Public Affairs Disclosure" work and does not fail to fulfill its supervisory duties. Xu ** has moved away from the village for many years, and the village committee has no obligation to separately carry out "Three Public Affairs Disclosure" for him. His application is essentially to solve the land claims of his father, Xu ***, for 7.5 mu of contracted land, which has been handled and responded to through the petition channel. The land was normally recovered in accordance with the provisions of Document XFA (1997) No.1, and no actual infringement of Xu **'s legitimate rights and interests occurred. After receiving the notice of administrative reconsideration, it has issued a supervision letter to the village committee, requesting that the application for administrative reconsideration be rejected.
First, fix the application facts and refute the "did not receive" defense.Song MeinaAfter accepting the client's commission, the lawyer comprehensively reviewed all the evidence of the case, including the logistics proofs, mail details and delivery track records of the three applications for village affairs disclosure mailed to the village committee, as well as the mailing materials for supervision applications submitted to the sub-district office, background materials on land ownership, and petition files. In response to the defendant's defense that "the logistics information could not be retrieved and the application was not actually received", Attorney Song pointed out that the mailing proofs showed that the receiving address, recipient, and delivery time all corresponded to the sub-district office's office address and mailing system, and the mailing status was marked as "signed for". The administrative organ's denial of receiving the application should be supported by counter-evidence such as the mailing registration ledger and return records. Simply denying it with "could not be retrieved" is not enough to overturn the applicant's initial evidence of having completed the submission.
Secondly, clarify the legal obligations of the village committee and argue that refusing to accept the notice means failing to perform its duties.Attorney Song pointed out that Xu ** is a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village. The land allocation ledger and land contract directly relate to her family's land rights, and she has the right to apply for village affairs disclosure and enjoy the right to information and supervision according to law. The village affairs disclosure system requires the village committee to disclose matters involving the villagers' interests and accept inquiries and supervision from the villagers of the village. The applicant has repeatedly submitted applications to the village committee in writing, but the village committee refused to accept and return the application materials and refused to respond, which constitutes a passive failure to fulfill the statutory obligation of village affairs disclosure. The village committee cannot exempt itself from the obligation of disclosure on the grounds that the applicant has moved out of the village. The standard for judging whether the obligation of disclosure should be fulfilled is the connection between membership and rights.
Thirdly, we should clarify the supervision responsibilities of the street offices and distinguish between the two sets of procedures for petitioning and supervision.Attorney Song emphasized that according to Article 31 of the "Villagers' Committee Organization Law", if the villagers' committee fails to announce matters that should be announced in a timely manner or announces untrue matters, the villagers have the right to report the situation to the people's governments of townships, nationality townships, or counties, or to the relevant competent departments of the people's governments. The relevant people's governments or competent departments shall be responsible for investigating and verifying the facts and ordering the announcement in accordance with the law. As the administrative organ of the jurisdiction, the Qianjin Sub-district Office has the statutory supervisory duty to investigate and verify and order the village committees to disclose village affairs information in accordance with the law. After receiving the villagers' supervision application, the sub-district office shall perform its duties in accordance with the law. The petition process and the supervision of village affairs disclosure belong to two independent legal procedures. Even if the parties have already gone through the petition channel for the land recovery issue, it does not exempt the sub-district office from its statutory duties regarding the supervision of village affairs disclosure. It is not allowed to replace the administrative supervision results with the petition response.
Fourthly, it reveals that the "Notice of Reminder" is just a formality, and it advocates confirming the violation and ordering the responsible party to perform their duties.Attorney Song pointed out that the respondent only issued a reminder letter to the village committee after the case was accepted for review, which was just a formality: it neither urged the village committee to give a formal written response to the applicant nor provided the applicant with feedback on the handling results. Therefore, it cannot be deemed that the respondent has fully fulfilled its statutory supervision obligations. Accordingly, it should be confirmed that its failure to perform its duties is illegal, and the respondent should be ordered to perform its duties within a specified time limit. Attorney Song also participated in the questioning and hearing procedures organized by the review organ and delivered the above-mentioned attorney's opinions in court, responding to the respondent's defense on a case-by-case basis around the four levels of "whether there are duties—whether they have received them—whether they have performed their duties—whether they can be substituted".
IV. Outcome of the case
The review authority held that, according to Article 31 of the Organization Law of the Villagers' Committees of the People's Republic of China, the applicant, as a member of the collective economic organization of Shuguang Village, has the right to request to review the village affairs information involving his own rights and interests. The applicant has repeatedly submitted applications for village affairs disclosure to the Shuguang Village Villagers' Committee, but the village committee refused to accept the mail and returned the applications, failing to fulfill its obligation to respond to village affairs disclosure requests. The applicant then submitted the "Application for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" to the respondent to seek administrative supervision relief. After receiving the application, the respondent failed to perform its statutory duty of urging the village committee to disclose village affairs information. Although the respondent claimed that it had not found the corresponding logistics information or actually received the application, it did not submit effective evidence to support its claim. Although the respondent issued a reminder letter to the village committee after the review case was registered, there was no evidence to prove that it had already fed back the handling results to the applicant, so it could not be determined that it had fully performed its statutory supervision duties. The handling of land petition matters and the supervision of village affairs disclosure belong to different legal relationships. The fact that the petition has been responded to does not exempt the respondent from fulfilling its statutory duties regarding the application for supervision of village affairs disclosure.
Therefore, in accordance with Article 66 of the Administrative Review Law of the People's Republic of China, the review organ decided to order the respondent, Harbin City A District Qianjin Street Office, to perform its statutory duties within 60 days from the date of receipt of the decision, and to urge the Shuguang Village Committee of Qianjin Town, A District, Harbin City to make a formal written response to Xu **'s application for village affairs disclosure in accordance with the law, and to provide Xu ** with a written feedback on the handling results. The applicant's right to information and right to supervision have been substantially remedied through the administrative review process.
The main regulations applicable to this case include: Article 31 of the "Organic Law of the Villagers' Committees of the People's Republic of China", which stipulates that if the villagers' committees fail to announce matters that should be announced in a timely manner or announce untrue matters, the villagers have the right to report to the township, nationality township, or town people's governments or county-level people's governments and their relevant competent departments. The relevant people's governments or competent departments shall be responsible for investigating and verifying and ordering the announcement according to law, which clarifies the statutory supervision duties of the sub-district offices; Article 66 of the "Administrative Review Law of the People's Republic of China", which stipulates that if the respondent fails to perform its statutory duties, the administrative review organ shall decide that it shall perform them within a certain period of time, which is the direct basis for the review decision in this case; at the same time, it refers to the relevant provisions of the law on the time limit for applying for administrative review, the burden of proof, and the respondent's responsibility for proving the legality of its administrative actions.
5. Hengluo Law Firm's Advice
The disclosure of village affairs is an important system to guarantee villagers' right to know and right to supervision. It involves matters such as land distribution, contracting contracts, land expropriation compensation, and the disposal of collective assets, and the village committees are obliged to disclose these matters. This case is handled by Beijing Hengluo Law Firm.Song MeinaAttorney (Practice Certificate No.: 111012025118804, subject to the document issued by the judicial administrative organ): Based on case handling experience, the following recommendations apply: 1. **Documentation and traceability**: Applications must be in writing and provide evidence. Oral submissions are difficult to verify. Send the *Application for Village Affairs Disclosure* by EMS, and specify the document title in the "Item Description" column of the details sheet. Retain the mailing receipt, delivery track, and signature records to form a complete chain of evidence. 2. **Proof of submission**: Village committees' refusal to accept applications does not mean the application was not submitted. Returned or rejected mail serves as key evidence of the village committee's negligence in performing its duties. Do not give up due to returns—retain the original, unopened mail. 3. **Timely initiate supervision procedures**: If the village committee fails to respond, submit the *Application for Village Affairs Disclosure Supervision* to the township government or sub-district office, clarifying the request and factual grounds. Retain mailing and signature records as well. 4. **Avoid misconceptions about "already handled through petitions": Petitions and village affairs disclosure supervision are separate procedures. If administrative authorities substitute petition responses for supervision duties, this can be explicitly pointed out in review or litigation proceedings. 5. **Effectively utilize administrative review and litigation**: If authorities fail to process or respond to supervision applications within deadlines, apply for administrative review or initiate litigation to confirm their failure to perform duties and order compliance within deadlines. For matters involving significant property rights, early engagement of professional lawyers is recommended to avoid losing remedy opportunities due to procedural errors or insufficient evidence.
VI. Common Questions and FAQs about Village Affairs Disclosure and Administrative Review Cases
- Q: If the village committee refuses to provide villagers with access to village affairs information, what options do villagers have? A: There are three steps to follow. First, submit a "Request for Disclosure of Village Affairs Information" in writing to the village committee, specifying the specific name of the requested information, the relevant year, and the scope of the request. If the village committee refuses to accept the request, returns it, or fails to respond within the time limit, villagers can then submit a "Request for Supervision of Village Affairs Disclosure" to the township government or district office, requesting an investigation and order to disclose the information. If the administrative authority still fails to address the request, villagers can apply for administrative review or initiate administrative litigation. Throughout the entire process, it is essential to retain mailing receipts and signing records.
- Q: If the village committee refuses to accept my application, does this constitute a failure to fulfill its obligation to disclose village affairs? A: It generally does. Disclosing village affairs is a statutory obligation of the village committee. Refusing to accept the application, sending it back after signing for it, or failing to provide any written or oral response upon receiving the application all constitute a passive failure to fulfill the obligation of disclosure. The returned application in its original form and the delivery track record are, on the contrary, strong evidence of its dereliction of duty.
- Q: If an application for public disclosure of village affairs is rejected, how to apply for administrative reconsideration? A: First, a written supervision application should be submitted to the township government or the sub-district office to urge them to fulfill their duties of investigation, verification, and ordering public disclosure. If the administrative organ fails to handle or respond to the application within the time limit after receiving it, the applicant may file an administrative reconsideration application against the administrative organ to its superior people's government or the people's government at the same level, requesting that the administrative organ be confirmed as having violated its statutory duties and ordered to fulfill them within a specified time limit. At the same time, the applicant should submit evidence such as the supervision application, mailing receipts, and signing records.
- Q: If I have already gone through the petition process, can I still request the disclosure of village affairs? A: Yes. Petitions deal with specific grievances, while the supervision and handling of village affairs focus on whether the village committee fulfills its obligation to disclose information and whether administrative authorities perform their supervisory duties. The legal relationship, request content, and handling authority of the two are different. If administrative authorities refuse to handle requests for village affairs supervision on the grounds that "the petition has already been responded to," this constitutes a confusion of procedures. In the appeal process, one can argue that the authorities have not fully fulfilled their duties.
- Q: If villagers have moved away from their village, can they still apply for village affairs disclosure? A: Generally, they can. The right to apply for village affairs disclosure is based on the status of being a member of a collective economic organization and the relevance of the information to their own rights and interests, rather than whether they actually live there. As long as the matters applied for disclosure involve their own or their household's land contracting, land expropriation compensation, collective income distribution, and other rights and interests, even if they have lived away from the village for a long time, they still have the right to apply. If the village committee refuses on the grounds that "the person has moved away," this lacks legal basis.