[Direct answer]The court will ask questions, but there are specific procedures to follow. According to Article 1084 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the child is over eight years old, his/her true wishes should be respected. In Beijing courts, judges usually conduct interviews separately outside the courtroom, without the presence of parents. When necessary, video interviews are arranged or social workers are commissioned to conduct supervision investigations. What lawyers can do is not to teach children how to answer questions, but three things: confirm whether the interview procedures are compliant, fix the child's daily care and schooling status with evidence, and submit the child's expressions in the form of written opinions or investigation applications. What the child says is just one of the factors. Stabilizing the child's life remains the main line.

I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios

When it comes to children's wishes, the difficulty has never been in the legal provisions, but in how to ask and whether the answers given by the children count as their true wishes.
There are four common scenarios. The first one is that the child lives with one parent for a long time, and the other parent repeatedly says bad things about the other parent during visits. When the child meets the judge, they say they don't want to live with their father or mother.
The second situation is that the child is already in his early teens and has clearly stated that he does not want to appear in court or meet the judge, but the parents dare not force him to do so.
The third type is that the child says "with dad" in front of his father and "with mom" in front of his mother, so as not to offend either side.
Fourthly, the child may have emotional disorders or developmental delays, resulting in unstable expression and inconsistent statements.
Beijing courts handle such issues quite maturely: for children aged eight and above, they are generally interviewed separately, usually in mediation rooms or psychological counseling rooms outside the courtroom, with parents and agents not allowed to be present. The content of the interview is not limited to who they will live with, but also includes who cooks, who picks them up, who helps with homework, and how they spend their weekends. These details can better reflect the actual relationship than a simple declaration. There is another category that is easily overlooked: when the child has been raised by one parent for a long time, but the actual caregivers are grandparents, the child's expressed wishes often reflect the attitudes of the elderly. During the interview, these two aspects should be considered separately. Some courts also arrange for family investigators to conduct home visits first, and then write reports on the living conditions, daily routines, and learning environments and attach them to the case files. The younger the child is, the more the judge relies on observing the parent-child interaction rather than asking questions.

II. Key points of dispute

Firstly, the form in which the intention to enter the case file should take. The court inquires about the written statements, social worker supervision reports, psychological assessment opinions, and letters written by the child, which have different legal effects and credibility. The written statements are the most direct form of evidence.
Secondly, the boundary between parents' presence and instigation. Parents' presence might affect the child's expression, so it should be ruled out in principle. As for instigation, evidence is needed, such as chat records, audio recordings, and teachers' testimonies. It cannot be determined solely based on the child's inconsistent statements.
Thirdly, whether the wishes of children under the age of eight are of any reference value. Although the law does not require that their wishes be heard, judges will indirectly judge them by observing parent-child interaction and asking about care details. It's unrealistic to completely ignore their wishes.
Fourthly, respecting the wishes does not mean making a judgment based on those wishes. The wishes are just one factor under the principle of maximizing the interests of minor children. It also depends on whether the party has the ability to raise the children and whether they can maintain a stable life.
Fifth, how to determine the change of mind. Article 56(3) of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Marriage and Family Chapter of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) lists the willingness of children aged eight or above to live with the other party and the other party's ability to raise them as grounds for change. However, repeated changes of mind may make this ground difficult to establish. Sixth, there are written opinions in addition to the transcript. If it is inconvenient for the child to appear in court, they can write a letter of intent by themselves, or have the school teacher or community worker relay their wishes, and submit it together with the attorney's opinion. The court will review them together. The threshold for determining incitement is high, usually requiring continuous evidence, such as multiple recordings and consistent statements from multiple witnesses. The degree to which the wishes are accepted also depends on whether the expression is specific. Those who can describe the details of their lives are more credible.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers

Take the divorce dispute handled by our firm as an example. The plaintiff, Wang *sheng, and the defendant, Zhang *hua, registered their marriage in 2006 and had a son (11 years old). In 2025, Zhang *hua first filed for divorce, but the lawsuit was dismissed. Later, Wang *sheng discovered that Zhang *hua had been having an affair, and she entrusted Attorney Xiong Binrong of Beijing Hengluo Law Firm to file a lawsuit again, putting forward six claims, including dissolving the marriage, the child following the plaintiff, the defendant paying child support, dividing 70% of the joint property, sharing debts, and seeking damages. The court found that Zhang *hua had committed major faults during the marriage and granted the divorce, ruling that the child would follow Wang *sheng, with Zhang *hua paying 550 yuan per month in child support and Wang *sheng receiving 70% of the joint property. This case was handled by Attorney Xiong Binrong of Beijing Hengluo Law Firm (practice certificate number: 11101202211410897, validated by the judicial administrative authority).
From the perspective of the child's wishes, the judgment provides three clues.
Firstly, the child is already eight years old, which belongs to the age group that should be heard of their wishes according to law. In custody cases, the court will not only consider the parents' statements.
Secondly, the judgment awarded custody to the party who has been providing long-term actual care, indicating that the continuity of daily care carries great weight, beyond mere intentions.
Thirdly, the fault is included in the evaluation of the rearing environment. Infidelity during marriage does not directly disqualify a person from being a guardian, but if they fail to return home regularly or neglect to care for the children, such an evaluation will clearly be unfavorable. The standard of 550 yuan for child support also shows that the court refers to the income certificate and actual needs, rather than the figure proposed by one party. Fourthly, when there are children of two age groups at the same time, the court tends not to separate siblings unless there are special reasons. The lesson from this case is that, in addition to the stated intention, there must also be evidence to prove daily care. Otherwise, even if the child says something, it will be difficult to put it into practice. For attorneys, the value of such cases lies not in the conclusion, but in the order of evidence presentation: first prove the facts of care, then discuss the intention.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

The legal basis is Article 1084 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), Article 4 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Minors (effective June 1, 2021), which establishes the principle of acting in the best interests of minors, and Article 56 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Marriage and Family Chapter of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021).
The operation follows a five-step process.
The first step is not to rehearse. If you teach children to memorize lines, they will give themselves away when asked about the details, which will only make the judge doubt their true intentions.
The second step is to keep daily records. These include attendance records for pick-ups and drop-offs, sign-in sheets for parent-teacher meetings, signed homework assignments, hospital visit accompaniments, and photos of weekend activities. These records are archived by time, serving to document relationships rather than positions or stances.
The third step is to submit a written application for individual questioning. Submit the application within the time limit for providing evidence, stating the child's age, the school they attend, the location and method of questioning they wish to conduct, and any requests for video questioning, if applicable.
Fourthly, if necessary, apply for a psychological assessment or social supervision. If the child shows obvious signs of being disturbed or has emotional problems, a neutral institution will provide an opinion, which is more convincing than parents' conflicting accounts.
The fifth step is not to inquire about the child's position during the trial. The focus should be on the child's ability to care for themselves and their stability, with the child's statements serving as corroborating evidence rather than the sole basis for judgment.
The overall plan involving custody arrangements can be compared with the following example.Divorce litigation and family disputesThe description of the page needs to be clarified. It should be noted that requests for applications must be submitted within the evidentiary period. If they are submitted after the deadline, the court may not arrange them; if they have been arranged but are changed at the last minute, the reasons should be explained in writing, otherwise it may be regarded as delaying. Before the trial, these materials should be compiled into a catalog, which will greatly shorten the time for the judge to review them.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Advice

First, teach the child to speak ill of the other party. It may be effective in the short term, but once it's exposed, the court will discount the entire statement of that party.
Secondly, forcing the child to choose between the parents. When the child is forced to take sides, they often try to please both parents, which often leads to contradictory statements in the records, which is not beneficial at all.
Thirdly, don't make the child's wishes the deciding factor. Although children aged over eight should be consulted, the court still needs to consider factors such as the parents' ability to raise the child, their stability in life, and their educational conditions when making a judgment.
The rational expectation is that if a child lives with one parent for a long time, has stable schooling, and a natural parent-child relationship, and their expressed wishes align with their actual living situation, then that parent clearly has the advantage. However, the current situation created through temporary arrangements and sudden pickups cannot withstand scrutiny of the details. Fourthly, some people believe that the older the child gets, the more likely they will automatically return to their parent's custody. Age only affects whether the child's wishes are taken into account, and it does not change the judgment standard that is most beneficial to the minor child. It's more effective to focus on what can be proven than to repeatedly explain the other party's shortcomings.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: If the child is eight years old but unwilling to appear in court, will the court still question them?

They will ask, but they don't have to appear in court. According to Article 1084 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the child has reached the age of eight, the court shall respect their true wishes. Here, the requirement of hearing the child does not require the child to appear in court. The common practice of Beijing courts is to arrange for judges to interview the child alone in the mediation room or psychological counseling room, or to interview them via video. They may also entrust social workers or psychological counselors to conduct guardian investigations and submit reports. If the child explicitly refuses, the court will record it in the case and explain the reasons. This will not be regarded as giving up the right to be heard. What parents need to do is to explain the child's concerns to the court in writing in advance, rather than bringing the child to the court at the last minute.

Q2: When a lawyer meets with a child alone, who needs to sign the transcript of the conversation?

The conversation transcript prepared by the lawyer himself/herself should be signed by the interviewee, the recorder, and the child himself/herself. For minors, it should also be signed and confirmed by the guardian or entrusted caregiver present at the scene. It should be noted that the probative force of the transcript prepared by the lawyer alone is limited. The court attaches more importance to the interrogation transcript prepared by itself or the supervision report issued by a neutral institution. A more secure approach is to record the entire interview process with audio and video, obtain the consent of both parties in advance, organize the key points into a written opinion after the interview, and apply to the judge for a separate interrogation. The transcript shall not induce or substitute answers for the child, and the child's original words shall be recorded as they are.

Q3: If a lawyer is hired to conduct a social supervision investigation, who will bear the cost?

Usually, the applicant pays the fee upfront, and the court ultimately decides on the cost-sharing based on the circumstances. There is no nationwide unified charging standard for social supervision. In Beijing, it is undertaken by social work agencies or third parties commissioned by the court. The fees for a single case typically range from a few thousand yuan to 10,000 yuan, with higher fees for visits to other regions and psychological assessments. The fees include visiting schools and communities, interviewing children and caregivers, and issuing written reports. In some regions, if the court initiates the supervision on its own authority, the fees are covered by financial guarantees and do not need to be paid by the parties involved. Before entrusting the agency, it's important to clarify three issues: the agency's qualifications, whether the report can be submitted as evidence, and whether the fees include appearing in court to provide explanations.

Q4: How long will it take for the court-ordered psychological evaluation to reach a conclusion?

Generally, it takes four to eight weeks. The process is as follows: one party applies or the court initiates the process on its own authority; both parties consult to select a qualified institution; the child undergoes interviews and scale assessments; if necessary, parents and teachers each fill out a questionnaire; and the institution issues a written opinion. In the Beijing area, it typically takes one to two months from the time of commissioning to receiving the report, with tighter schedules during the summer and at the end of the year. The assessment focuses on the child's cognition, emotions, and the quality of the parent-child relationship, rather than rating the parents. The conclusion typically states which party the child has a stronger emotional connection with and the risk of changing the current situation. The court uses this as a reference rather than a definitive conclusion.

Q5: If the child is persuaded to change his/her statement, should we first apply to the court for a separate questioning?

First, secure the evidence, then apply for a separate questioning. The order cannot be reversed. The fixed evidence includes: audio recordings of the child's previous and current statements, chat records, the teachers' and neighbors' testimonies, and records of the pick-up and accommodation times. With these in hand, submit a written application to the court, requesting the judge to question the child separately in the absence of the parents, and explain the specific facts of the interference. If the application is made solely based on the parents' unilateral statements without corroborating evidence, the court is likely to deny the request. Simultaneously, you can apply for a psychological evaluation or a guardianship investigation, allowing a neutral organization to determine whether the child's statements have been improperly influenced. If the incitement behavior is verified, it will also become a fact in evaluating the other party's attitude towards child-rearing.

The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the adjudication opinions in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.

If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Divorce litigation legal services·Attorney Xiong Binrong·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on current laws and regulations and publicly available adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.