[Direct answer]When choosing a lawyer, there are three key factors, with reputation being the least important. First, has the lawyer handled cases involving the same charge? The differences between various charges are vast. For example, the crime of assisting in information network crime activities, the crime of illegal business operations, the crime of fraud, and the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information have almost no overlapping elements in their constitutive elements and defense points. Second, can the lawyer understand electronic data? The basis for determining guilt in such cases relies on back-end data, fund flows, chat records, and electronic data appraisals. If the lawyer cannot understand these data, they will fail to grasp the key points for cross-examination. Third, is the lawyer willing to meet with the client and submit written opinions during the investigation stage? The maximum timeframe for criminal detention to obtaining approval for arrest is 37 days. If this window is missed, remedial measures will be required afterward. Only if all three requirements are met can the lawyer be considered professionally qualified for the case.

I. Problem background and typical scenarios

There are several common characteristics of online economic crime cases, which determine that the standards for choosing a lawyer are different from those for ordinary criminal cases. Firstly, the number of people involved in the case is large and the hierarchical structure is complex. In a platform case, there may be actual controllers, technical managers, operation supervisors, customer service staff, agents, and part-time workers at the same time, and the status and role of each person vary greatly, so the defense strategy cannot be applied universally. Secondly, the determination of the amount of money relies on data. The total amount of transactions, the amount of profits, and the losses of victims often do not match each other. It is not uncommon to count the same amount twice, include legitimate business, and treat recharge as a loss. Thirdly, the line between guilt and non-guilt is blurred. Normal technical services and providing assistance knowing that others are committing crimes, direct selling and pyramid selling, administrative violations and illegal operations are often separated by just one layer of evidence. Fourthly, cross-regional case handling is common. Designated jurisdiction, detention in other places, and remote interrogations have become the norm. The time cost and response speed of lawyers directly affect the frequency of meetings and reviewing case files. One of the most easily overlooked points by family members when entrusting a lawyer is: whether they can be present at critical moments is more important than their title.

II. Key points of contention

The first level of disagreement lies in the qualification of the charges. Individuals whose main businesses involve fund settlement, technical support, advertising promotion, and payment assistance may be identified as accomplices in fraud or as guilty of aiding in information network crime activities, with vastly different sentencing ranges for the two charges. Article 287(2) of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (amended and implemented on March 1, 2021) stipulates that aiding in information network crime activities requires knowing that others are using information networks to commit crimes. Whether this knowledge exists can often be inferred from objective facts such as abnormal transaction prices, concealed settlement methods, and continued activities after receiving regulatory warnings. This provides significant room for defense. The second level of disagreement concerns the amount of the crime. The amount of transaction funds does not equal the actual crime amount. Legitimate business operations, refunds, duplicate calculations, and the victim's own faults should all be deducted. The defense team needs to verify each transaction item by item and create a comparison table. The third level of disagreement concerns the legality of electronic data. Electronic data is a statutory type of evidence. Article 50 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) lists electronic data as evidence, requiring a written record, witness presence, and integrity verification during the extraction process. Evidence obtained without these requirements may be excluded or require correction. The fourth level of disagreement concerns coercive measures and guilty pleas. Article 15 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) stipulates that if a suspect or defendant voluntarily and truthfully confesses their crimes, admits the alleged facts of the crime, and is willing to accept punishment, they may be given lenient treatment according to the law. However, a guilty plea presupposes that the facts and charges are clear. When there are major disputes over the qualification of the charges, an early guilty plea may actually limit the scope of defense.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers

When handling such cases, Hengluo Lawyers usually advise family members to evaluate a candidate lawyer based on five questions rather than listening to self-introductions. **Question 1**: How many similar cases have you handled? At what stage did you intervene in the most recent one, and what was the outcome? If the lawyer cannot specify the specific stages or approaches, they are likely just casually familiar with the case. **Question 2**: How was the amount in this case calculated? Which parts can be deducted? If they can immediately explain the relationship between the total transaction amount, the profit amount, and the victim's losses, it indicates that they are familiar with the evidentiary structure of such cases. **Question 3**: Can you cross-examine the electronic data appraisal opinion? From which aspects? A qualified answer should mention the extraction transcripts, the original storage media, the integrity check values, and the qualifications and methods of the appraisal institution. **Question 4**: How long will it take to provide a written legal opinion after the meeting? To whom will it be submitted? During the investigation stage, opinions on the lack of criminal intent or inappropriate detention should be submitted to the investigating unit; during the review and prosecution stage, opinions on non-prosecution should be submitted to the procuratorial organ. The recipients differ at different stages. **Question 5**: If there are disputes over the nature of the charges, should the defendant sign the plea agreement? Explain the timing of signing and the associated risks. It's far more reliable to clarify this before signing the agreement rather than signing it first and then explaining later. In addition to asking these questions, it's also important to verify two key points: 1. Whether the lawyer's practice certificate is valid. This can be verified through the public information disclosure of the judicial administrative authority. 2. Whether the power of attorney clearly specifies the lawyer's name and the service stages, to avoid the case being handed over to assistants after signing the contract. In cases involving online economic crimes, the defense workload is concentrated on reviewing case materials and verifying data. If a lawyer handles multiple cases simultaneously, it's difficult to guarantee adequate dedication to each case. This point can be directly raised during the consultation.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

The process of entrusting a lawyer can be divided into four steps. Firstly, in the confirmation stage, the focus is on confirming the client's needs and understanding the suspected charges and facts, as well as submitting opinions on refusing to approve the arrest or granting bail. In the review and prosecution stage, the emphasis is on reviewing the case file, verifying the amount of the case, and striving for non-prosecution or reduced charges. In the trial stage, the focus is on cross-examination and sentencing defense. Secondly, in the qualification and experience verification stage, the lawyer should check the client's practicing certificate, the letter from the law firm, and inquire about the handling of similar cases. If necessary, the lawyer may require the client to provide publicly available case materials. Thirdly, in the signing of the entrustment contract, the contract should specify the lawyer handling the case, the service phase, the number of meetings, the fee structure, and the refund agreement. It is prohibited to agree on contingency fees in criminal cases, as Article 12 of the "Measures for the Administration of Lawyer's Service Fees" (implemented on December 1, 2006) clearly restricts this. The "Lawyer Law of the People's Republic of China" (amended on September 1, 2017) also requires that lawyers accept entrustments and charge fees through law firms. Fourthly, in the materials handover stage, the lawyer should be provided with the detention notice, clues to the amount of the case, a description of the company's business model, an employee roster, and a division of labor. The more specific the materials are, the more conducive it is to quickly form a defense direction. For those who need to match the defense stage with the work content, they can refer to the above-mentioned materials.Criminal defense | Criminal case filingThe service description. After entrusting the case to a lawyer, the family members should avoid contacting co-defendants or witnesses on their own, and should not relay information on their behalf. Such actions are highly likely to be regarded as collusion of evidence in online cases.

5. Hengluo Law Firm's Advice

Choosing a lawyer essentially means choosing a working method. Cyber-economic crime cases often involve dozens of volumes of case files and terabytes of electronic data. Whether one can stay focused and conduct accurate calculations of the amounts involved can determine the outcome more than eloquence in court. Families are easily persuaded by promises of guaranteed results, but the outcome of criminal cases depends on evidence and legal application. Any promise of a specific sentence or a guarantee of innocence is untrustworthy. Another reminder about communication: After entrusting the case, a fixed information synchronization mechanism should be established, such as a weekly written progress report, to avoid misunderstandings due to information asymmetry. Additionally, evidence in cyber-cases often exists in electronic form. Families should not log into the client's account to delete chat records or transfer records on their own. Such actions may not only destroy evidence but also lead to new risks. The specific circumstances of each case vary greatly. The final conclusions should be based on the current effective laws, regulations, and judicial rulings. It is recommended to bring the detention notice and business materials for a face-to-face consultation.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Can a lawyer who has only handled traditional theft cases take on the defense of aiding and abetting crime?

I can handle it, but it depends on whether the three capabilities are fully supplemented. The defense of traditional property-related crimes focuses on the scene, traces, and stolen goods, while the disputed points of aiding and abetting crimes are completely different: how to infer subjective knowledge, how to calculate the payment and settlement amounts, how to match the involved accounts with the criminal proceeds, and whether the upstream crimes have been investigated. Lawyers who lack experience in cross-examination of electronic data will find it difficult to identify deductible legal transactions among tens of thousands of transaction records. A feasible judgment method is to see whether they have proposed specific quantitative verification plans and whether they understand the review points of electronic data appraisal opinions. If they simply transfer the defense strategies of theft cases over, the effect will be limited.

Q2: When selecting a defense attorney for cybercrime cases, what types of case handling experience should be considered?

There are three categories to consider. The first category is the criminal record of the same charge. Which of the following crimes have you handled: aiding information network crime activities, illegal business operations, fraud, or organizing and leading pyramid selling activities? And at what stage did you handle them? The second category is data-related experience. Have you dealt with electronic data appraisal opinions, server logs, or fund flow verification? This determines whether you can gain leeway in the amount of the fine. The third category is procedural experience. Have you handled jurisdiction objections, detention necessity reviews, or non-prosecution applications? Online cases are often handled across different regions, and procedural experience directly affects the pace of the case. Beyond these three categories, we also need to consider the team's configuration. Do you have assisting staff who are proficient in finance or technology?

Q3: How is the lawyer's fee calculated for cybercrime cases by stages?

Billing by stages is the mainstream approach, with separate quotes for investigation, review and prosecution, and first-instance trials. The total cost of a full case is usually lower than the sum of the individual stages. Billing methods include hourly rates and fixed fees. For cases involving a large number of suspects or a large amount of data, hourly rates or a combination of hourly rates and fixed fees are often used. Criminal cases are not subject to contingency fees. Article 12 of the "Measures for the Administration of Lawyers' Service Fees" (implemented on December 1, 2006) stipulates that contingency fees are prohibited in criminal litigation cases, and agreements on profit-sharing based on the outcome are invalid. It should also be noted that there are no litigation fees in criminal cases. Only when the victim files a supplementary civil action will the litigation fees be paid in accordance with the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" (implemented on April 1, 2007). Before signing the contract, it is necessary to confirm who will bear the costs of travel to other places, application for appraisal, and expert assistants.

Q4: Within how many days after criminal detention must the review of the approval of arrest be completed?

The maximum period is 37 days. Article 91 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) stipulates that if the public security organ deems it necessary to arrest a suspect, it shall submit the case to the people's procuratorate for review and approval within three days after the suspect is detained. Under special circumstances, the period may be extended by one to four days. For major suspects who commit crimes in a mobile manner, repeatedly, or in gangs, the time for submitting the case for review and approval may be extended to 30 days. The people's procuratorate shall make a decision within seven days after receiving the document requesting approval of the arrest. This period is a critical window for applying for bail and submitting opinions against the approval of the arrest. The earlier you hire a lawyer, the more working days you will have available.

Q5: What materials should I bring when meeting a lawyer for the first time?

There are four categories of materials. Identity and relationship materials: family members' ID cards, household registration books or marriage certificates, used to prove the identity of close relatives. If necessary, provide power of attorney; case materials: detention notices, arrest notices, seizure and attachment lists, and notices of account freezing involved in the case; business materials: the company's business license, job responsibilities description, business processes and profit-sharing rules. For online cases, the division of responsibilities highly depends on these materials; clue materials: the possible sources of the involved amount, the relationship between co-defendants, and the physical condition and medication situation of the parties involved. The materials do not need to be complete, but they must be true. Lawyers can use them to determine the direction of the charges and the necessity of detention, so as to avoid wasting time during the first meeting.

The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the adjudication standards in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.

If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, so as to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Criminal defense legal services·Beijing Henglu Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. In the event of a dispute, please consult a practicing lawyer in a timely manner.