[Direct answer]It's possible to send money, but it's not in cash. Instead, it's deposited into the detention center's escrow account. Families cannot directly hand over cash to detainees, nor can they transfer it through lawyers, police officers, or so-called intermediaries. There are only two official channels: either go to the detention center's reception window to make a deposit, or transfer the money to the account announced by the detention center. When doing so, provide the detainee's name and ID number. After the money is deposited into the account, the detainee can spend it within the monthly spending limit. Any claims that the money can be directly delivered to the detainee should first be verified as fraudulent, rather than paying the money upfront.
1. Problem background and typical scenarios
The motivation of family members to send money is very simple: they are afraid that the detainees may not eat enough, buy daily necessities, or be bullied in detention. In most cases, this motivation can be satisfied through formal channels, but the problem lies in misunderstanding these channels. Detention centers are not hotels. The spending of detainees is subject to unified management, and cash does not circulate within the detention area. The money sent by family members cannot be stored or used, and it may even lead to disciplinary records for the detainees.
There are four typical scenarios. The first type is treating the escrow funds as bribes and entrusting others to transfer them. The money is gone, and the person involved will also face punishment. The second type is confusing the escrow funds with the bail pending trial funds and believing that paying the money will lead to the person's release. They deposit more than 100,000 yuan into a private account. The third type is directly handing over the compensation funds to the victims' relatives without any receipts or witnesses, which cannot be recognized as compensation circumstances in the judgment. The fourth type is that even after the person has been sent to prison to serve their sentence, the family still deposits money into the detention center. After making several trips, they find that the account has already been transferred with the person.
The common point of these four scenarios is that they mix different types of money into one thing. Escrow funds are used for daily consumption, security deposits are used for compulsory measures, and restitution and fines are used for sentencing and execution. The collecting entities, voucher forms, and legal consequences of these three channels are completely different. If they are mixed up once, the losses are often irreversible.
II. Key points of contention
The first point of contention is the nature of the escrow fund. It is personal funds held by detainees, which are kept and recorded by the detention center and used to purchase daily necessities and food from the on-site supermarket. The balance will be refunded upon release. It is not a fine, not a deposit, and cannot be used to offset the fine. After the family deposits the money, the ownership still belongs to the detainees, and the family has no right to request a refund in the middle of the process.
The second point of contention is the deposit limit and spending limit. The rules vary from institution to institution. A common practice is to set a monthly deposit cap and a daily spending cap, and any excess amounts will either not be accepted or will be postponed for entry into the account. The purpose of these limits is to prevent comparison and swapping, not to make things difficult. Family members can deposit money monthly and replenish it as needed. Making a large one-time deposit is not only unnecessary, but may also trigger verification.
The third point of contention is the payment path for the bail pending trial. The Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) stipulates that the decision-making organ for bail pending trial shall comprehensively consider the need to ensure the normal conduct of litigation activities, the circumstances of the case, the social danger, the severity of the possible sentence, and the economic situation, etc. to determine the amount of the bail, and provide a special account of the designated bank. The formal process is to first obtain the notice of collecting the bail, then pay it to the designated bank, and exchange the receipt for a certificate. Any request to transfer the bail to a personal account, WeChat, or Alipay is not in accordance with the regulations.
The fourth point of contention is the channels for restitution and fines. The restitution to victims should be carried out under the supervision of the case-handling organ or defense lawyers, with a written agreement signed and transfer receipts retained, indicating the nature of the funds; the fines should be paid to the court that issued the judgment after the judgment takes effect, and the payment receipts should be included in the case file. Neither of the two channels can be replaced by escrow funds, nor can the payment be made privately in cash.
The fifth point of contention is the red line of bribery. In order to obtain improper care for detainees, giving money or gifts to supervisory staff or case-handling personnel may constitute the crime of bribery as stipulated in Article 389 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (amended and implemented on March 1, 2021), and those who give bribes in large amounts will be subject to criminal prosecution. Once this line is crossed, the scope of defense will be greatly limited.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
Lawyers from our firm are often asked the following question during meetings: "Can you help me bring some money in?" The answer is no, but we can advise family members on the correct procedure. The opening of an escrow account is usually completed upon admission to the detention center. Family members can make deposits by presenting their ID cards and the detainee's identification number. Some detention centers support bank transfers, with the funds typically arriving within one to two working days, with the timeframe extended during holidays.
After the deposit, the family members often ask if the money is enough. Lawyers cannot directly answer this question, as the consumption details are internal management information of the firm. A feasible approach is to ask during the meeting whether there are shortages of daily necessities or a need for replenishment, and then for the family members to deposit the necessary funds accordingly. Making large blind deposits not only occupies the quota but also serves no practical purpose.
What's more important is to distinguish the nature of the funds. Families often have several sums of money to deal with at the same time: attorney's fees, compensation for losses, fines, and escrow funds. It is recommended to make a list, clearly stating the recipient of each sum of money, the form of the receipt, and the time limit. Attorney's fees should be paid to the attorney's office's public account and a written power of attorney should be signed; compensation for losses should be paid to the victim or the account designated by the case-handling organ and an agreement should be signed; fines should be paid to the court; and escrow funds should be deposited into the detention center's account. There are four different destinations for the four sums of money. If any of them is transferred to the wrong account, it may result in both financial losses and a loss of evidence for the case.
There's another situation that needs to be reminded of: after the case enters the trial stage, some families are eager to make a good impression and ask others to "do the work" for them. They spend a lot of money, but nothing is left in the case file. What can really be seen during sentencing are compensation agreements, letters of understanding, and receipts for paying fines, all of which have written records and can be verified. Spending money on things that can be recorded is the most practical lesson in this kind of matter.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
First, confirm the detention facility and the detainee's number. The number can be found on the admission notice, the lawyer's meeting receipt, and the notice received by the detainee's family. Without the number, the window cannot register the payment. Second, confirm the payment method. Call the reception window of the detention center to ask whether the payment should be made in cash or by bank transfer. The account name and account number for the transfer should be based on the information publicly announced by the detention center. Do not accept account numbers forwarded by others. Third, deposit within the monthly limit. Most detention centers have a monthly payment limit. It's safer to make monthly payments rather than a large single payment. Fourth, keep all receipts. Save the deposit receipt, the transfer screenshot, and the account balance inquiry records. Fifth, distinguish between the four payments and handle them through the aforementioned channels separately, without mixing them or making payments on behalf of others.
In terms of legal basis, the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) stipulates the determination factors and payment methods of bail pending trial, and provides for the living security of suspects and defendants during their detention; Article 389 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (amended and implemented on March 1, 2021) stipulates the constitution and punishment of the crime of bribery. For specific issues concerning the protection of rights during detention, please refer to our firm.Criminal defense and criminal case filingColumn.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
There are three types of scams that you should reject on the spot: first, those who claim to know the prison guards and can provide extra care; second, those who claim that you can pay money to secure bail and get a refund if unsuccessful; third, those who claim that they can deliver cash directly to the detainees' cells. The first two types are common forms of fraud, while the third type is not just a scam—it may also lead to detainees being accused of smuggling contraband into the prison.
The division of labor among family members should also be clear. Who is responsible for the deposits, who is responsible for liaising with the lawyer, and who is responsible for keeping the receipts? It's important to clarify this in advance to avoid duplicate procedures and confusion in the accounts. There's no need to add extra funds during festivals; just deposit as needed. What really affects the outcome of the case are the evidence, the circumstances, and the procedural milestones, not the balance in the account.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Can family members directly deposit money into the detainees' accounts?
No. Cash is not allowed to circulate within the detention area. The cash handed in by family members cannot be stored or used, and will be regarded as the transmission of contraband. The correct approach is to go to the reception window of the detention center to handle the deposit of entrusted funds, or transfer money to the account announced by the detention center. After the money enters the account, the detainee can spend it in the detention center supermarket. The Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on October 26, 2018) guarantees the basic living of detainees. The specific deposit amount and spending limit are determined by the management rules of each detention center. You can confirm it by phone before handling it. Any person claiming to be able to directly deliver the cash to the detainee should not be trusted, and no advance payment should be made.
Q2: When depositing money into the custody account, do I need to provide the inmate's ID number or the cell number?
The priority should be given to the inmate number, and the cell number can only be used as a supplementary reference. The detention center's accounts are established based on the inmate numbers, which are unique. The cell numbers may change due to cell transfers or area changes, making it easy to enter the wrong account information based solely on the cell number. The inmate number can be found in the admission notice, the notification letter received by the family, or the lawyer's meeting receipt. If it cannot be found, call the reception window to verify the name and number. When applying, you also need to provide the original ID card of the depositor. For agents, an authorization letter and the agent's ID card are required. After the funds are deposited, request a receipt. The receipt should indicate the inmate's name, number, amount, and date. If any of these items are missing, you should request corrections on the spot.
Q3: How much money can I deposit for detainees each month, and what should I do if I exceed the limit?
The standards vary among different prisons. A common practice is to set a monthly deposit limit and a daily spending limit within the prison. These two limits are not the same thing. For amounts exceeding the limit, the window generally does not accept them, or delays their entry into the account until the next month. The specific rules are subject to the announcements issued by the prison. It's safest for family members to deposit money monthly and replenish it as needed. When visiting, they should check whether there is a shortage of daily necessities and then decide on the amount. It's important to note that the balance of the trust fund will be settled and refunded upon release from the prison. It cannot be used to offset fines or converted into a bail deposit for pretrial release. If someone requests additional payments on the grounds of insufficient funds or the need for bribes, they should directly refuse and report the matter to the supervisory business department.
Q4: How long will it take for the remaining funds to be transferred to the prison account after I am sent to prison?
Generally, the balance of the detainee's account is transferred to the prison upon their transfer for execution of the sentence, with the transfer period ranging from several days to two weeks, depending on the handover arrangements between the detention center and the prison. After the judgment takes effect, those with shorter remaining sentences will serve their sentences in the detention center, and their accounts will remain unchanged. For those who need to be transferred to prisons for execution of the sentence, the detention center will transfer the balance of the escrow fund to the prison when handling the discharge procedures. Upon receipt of the funds, the prison will reopen the account. Families do not need to make duplicate deposits or transfer funds to the detention center account during this period, as this may lead to double bookings. If the balance has not been transferred after one month, they can inquire at the reception window of the detention center with the original deposit receipt, or entrust a lawyer to verify it during the visit. The balance will ultimately be settled and refunded upon the detainee's release from prison or upon their parole.
Q5: When preventing family members from being cheated by capable middlemen, what should we do first to avoid losing money?
First, check the payment subject. For anyone who requests money to be transferred to a personal account, WeChat, or Alipay in the name of handling affairs, the first step is to stop immediately. Official payments will only be deposited into three types of accounts: the public account of the law firm, the special account for deposits designated by the case-handling authority, and the litigation fee and fine account of the court. Second, check the supporting documents. For obtaining bail, you should first obtain the decision letter for bail pending trial and the notice for collecting the deposit; for refunding the deposit, there should be a written agreement and transfer records. Oral promises are not valid at all. Third, check the identity. Verify the information of the practicing certificate through the official website of the Lawyers Association or the judicial administrative authority. If you fail to pass all three steps, it can be basically determined that it's a scam. It's more useful to report it to the police in time than to continue dealing with it.
This article is written based on the common judicial interpretation in the Beijing area. If the case occurs in other regions, it is recommended to consult local lawyers to verify the regional differences.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Criminal defense legal services·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.