[Direct answer]Follow the three-step process of identifying fixed violations, initiating remedies, and asserting consequences. The procedural violations that can be litigated are concentrated in six areas: failure to issue a pre-announcement of land expropriation, failure to conduct a land status survey and social stability risk assessment, failure to announce or insufficiently announce the compensation and resettlement plan for 30 days, failure to organize a hearing when required, failure to fully pay the compensation before seeking approval, and occupation of land without signing a compensation and resettlement agreement. Within the statutory time limit, the parties may apply for administrative reconsideration or initiate administrative litigation, requesting confirmation of the violations, revocation of the relevant administrative acts, or an order to make a new decision, and also claim compensation for the actual losses that have occurred.
I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios
For projects such as high-speed rail, highways, power transmission and transformation, and water conservancy, the construction period is tight and the hierarchical level is high. In practice, it's not uncommon for land to be used first and then the formalities to be completed later. Villagers often only realize that their contracted land has been included in the expropriation scope when they see the survey team entering the fields, the boundary stakes being buried, and the construction access roads being built to the end of the fields. When they approach the village committee, they are told that it's an above-level project; when they approach the natural resources department, they are told that the relevant documents haven't arrived yet.
The implementing entities of such projects are often the project headquarters, urban investment companies, or construction agencies. The administrative authorities that actually make the expropriation decisions and issue announcements often remain behind the scenes. If the parties list the headquarters or construction units as defendants, their cases are likely to be dismissed due to the unsuitability of the defendants, wasting half a year of time in vain. Identifying the appropriate defendants is the first technical hurdle in such cases.
Another typical scenario is the phased collection of fees. The same project spans multiple cities and counties, and the progress of the procedures for different sections is uneven. Some sections have already issued announcements, while others are still in the stage of surveying and demarcating boundaries. The parties only focus on their own piece of land, and it's easy to overlook the correspondence between the overall approval documents and the actual situation of the local section.
II. Key points of dispute
Firstly, the qualification of the plaintiff. The plaintiff needs to have an interest in the administrative act, usually proven by a contractual management right certificate, a residential land use certificate, a house ownership certificate, or continuous records of actual farming. If the land has been transferred to others, the plaintiff's qualification of the original contractor may be affected, and it is necessary to clarify the nature and term of the transfer contract.
Second, the identification of the contested actions. The pre-announcement, the announcement of the compensation and resettlement plan, the compensation decision, the decision to order the surrender of the land, and the forced clearance of the land belong to different types of administrative acts, and the remedies and time limits for them are all different. When suing, requesting the revocation of a non-existent administrative act is a common reason for losing the case.
Thirdly, the distinction between procedural defects and substantive results. Procedural violations do not necessarily lead to the revocation of the act. If the violation is minor and does not actually affect the rights, the court may only rule to confirm the violation. The parties should raise the claim for compensation at the time of suing to avoid being passive after the confirmation of the violation and claiming in another case.
Fourth, the statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit. Generally, it is six months from the date when the party knows or should have known about the administrative act. For cases involving real estate, the maximum statute of limitations is not more than 20 years, and for other cases, the maximum statute of limitations is not more than 5 years.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
The focus of reviewing land expropriation cases involving large-scale infrastructure projects should be on whether the administrative authorities have fulfilled the statutory procedures, rather than the amount of compensation. This is because the compensation standards fall within the administrative authorities' discretionary scope, and courts generally respect the evaluation conclusions; while the procedural steps are statutory obligations. The lack of public announcements, hearings, or proof of funds being in place are all hard defects that can be directly reviewed.
The evidentiary structure is favorable to the parties involved. Article 34 of the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that the defendant shall bear the burden of proof for the administrative acts it has taken, and shall provide evidence of the acts and the normative documents on which they are based. This means that the parties do not need to prove that the expropriation procedures are illegal, but only need to point out the missing links in the procedures, and the administrative organs shall provide evidence to prove that they have fulfilled their obligations. In practice, many cases have failed because the administrative organs were unable to provide records of the announcement posting, hearing transcripts, or proof of the compensation funds being in place.
It is also necessary to ensure the accuracy of confirming the applicability of illegal judgments. Article 74 of the Administrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that if an administrative act should be revoked according to law, but the revocation will cause significant damage to the national interest or the public interest, the judgment shall confirm its illegality; Article 76 stipulates that if it is confirmed to be illegal or invalid, the defendant may be ordered to take remedial measures at the same time. If the plaintiff suffers losses, the defendant shall be ordered to bear compensation liability according to law. Large-scale infrastructure projects usually involve public interests, and the scope of application of revocation judgments is limited. It is often more practical to focus on confirming the illegality and seeking compensation rather than insisting on revocation.
It should be noted that the value of a program being illegal lies not only in the judgment result. After confirming the illegality, the party concerned can claim compensation for the difference in price, the loss of attached objects on the ground, and the cost of temporary resettlement, and can also gain a more proactive position in subsequent negotiations. The judgment itself is not the end, but the starting point of new negotiations.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
First, identify the illegal points and create a checklist. Compare each item with the seven key stages of pre-announcement, status investigation, risk assessment, plan announcement, hearing, agreement signing, and fund availability, and mark the presence or absence of each item and its corresponding timeframe. This will result in a one-page procedural comparison table.
Secondly, supplement the documents through information disclosure. Apply to the county-level natural resources competent department for the disclosure of the land expropriation approval documents, compensation and resettlement plans, and announcements, as well as the survey and demarcation maps. Apply to the township government for the disclosure of the announcement posting and measurement records. The documents are the mirror of the procedure, and it's clear at a glance which item is missing.
Thirdly, identify the defendant and the request. The county-level people's government makes the expropriation or compensation decisions, and the local governments at or above the county level issue the announcements. The township governments or sub-district offices may implement the forced clearance of the land. The requests should correspond to the specific actions taken.
Fourth, claim compensation simultaneously. The actual losses of fixtures on the ground, green seedlings, relocation expenses, and transitional expenses shall be listed together when suing, and an appraisal report or purchase receipts shall be attached.
Fifth, make full use of the pre-review and relief connection. If you are not satisfied with the compensation decision, you can first apply for administrative review. The review organ will handle it in accordance with the "Administrative Review Law of the People's Republic of China" (effective from January 1, 2024); if you are not satisfied with the review decision, you can file a lawsuit again to avoid losing the right to sue due to errors in the calculation of the time limit.
In terms of legal basis, Article 47 of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2020) stipulates that when expropriating land, the government shall issue a pre-announcement of land expropriation, conduct a survey of the current status of the land and an assessment of social stability risks, prepare a compensation and resettlement plan for land expropriation and announce it, and sign compensation and resettlement agreements with the owners and users of the land to be expropriated; Article 48 stipulates that the compensation shall ensure that the original living standards of the farmers whose land is expropriated will not be reduced. The Implementing Regulations of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective September 1, 2021) further specify that the pre-announcement period shall be no less than ten working days, and the announcement period of the compensation and resettlement plan shall be no less than 30 days. For a complete overview of procedural nodes and remedial pathways, please refer to the relevant documents.Land expropriation and demolition, and administrative litigation.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
Don't wait until after the land clearing to take action. Once the land is leveled, it's difficult to restore the value of the attachments on the ground. Even if the illegality is confirmed, the evidence for the compensation amount will be extremely passive. When you receive a pre-announcement or a measurement notice, you should start photographing the original state of the plot, inventorying the seedlings and ground objects, and preserving the contract and payment receipts.
There is another often overlooked detail: you should carefully check the title of the document when signing for receipt. In practice, there have been cases where parties signed for receipt of the decision to order the surrender of land as an ordinary notice, failed to file a lawsuit within the time limit, and were eventually subject to enforcement. For any document with the words "decision", "notice", or "advice", you should immediately consult a professional lawyer after signing for receipt to determine its nature and time limit, rather than handling it based on your own judgment.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If the high-speed rail project fails to issue a pre-announcement for land expropriation, can it be confirmed that the expropriation is illegal?
It can be claimed as an independent violation, but it needs to be distinguished by stages. The pre-announcement is a preliminary procedure in the proposed expropriation stage. Article 47 of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2020) requires that it be issued before applying for land expropriation. If it is not issued before conducting the current situation investigation and signing contracts, it constitutes a procedural omission. In practice, courts' handling of cases involving the lack of pre-announcement is not entirely consistent: if subsequent announcements, plans, and agreements are complete and compensation is in place, the court may only confirm the violation; if this results in the party being unable to inquire in time or participate, thereby affecting their right to compensation, the possibility of revocation or ordering remedial measures is greater. When suing, the lack of pre-announcement should be claimed alongside other violations.
Q2: If we argue that the procedure is illegal, what announcements and approval documents do we need to retrieve?
The core elements include four categories: the land expropriation approval documents issued by provincial governments or the State Council; the land expropriation announcements issued by governments at the county level or above, including the posting time, location, and photos; the land expropriation compensation and resettlement plans prepared by county-level natural resources authorities and their announcements, as well as the hearing transcripts; proof of the availability of compensation funds and certificates of the implementation of social insurance fees. In addition, it is necessary to obtain surveying and demarcation maps and land status investigation forms to verify whether the family's land parcels are within the red line and whether the land types and areas are accurately recorded. Most of these materials can be obtained through government information disclosure, while a few need to be requested from the court in litigation.
Q3: If the lawsuit confirms the violation, what is the standard for paying the case acceptance fee?
The acceptance fee for administrative cases is generally 50 yuan per case. For cases involving property and with a high claim amount, the fee is calculated based on the standard for property cases in stages. For cases where the plaintiff requests to confirm that an administrative act is illegal but does not involve compensation amounts, the fee is usually charged per case. If the plaintiff also requests compensation, the compensation part is calculated according to the standard for property cases, but the part confirming the illegality of the administrative act is still charged per case. In practice, many courts only charge 50 yuan for confirming the illegality of an administrative act, which is far lower than what the parties expect. If the plaintiff is financially difficult, he/she can apply for deferral, reduction, or exemption of the fee, but he/she needs to submit relevant proof materials and obtain the court's approval after review.
Q4: How long does it usually take from the first instance to the second instance to confirm a lawsuit involving illegal activities?
The first-instance judgment is generally rendered within six months from the date of filing the case. If there are special circumstances requiring an extension, it shall be approved by the higher people's court; if the case is handled by summary procedure, it shall be concluded within 45 days. The second-instance judgment is generally rendered within three months. If the case involves appraisal, evaluation, or waiting for the results of related cases, the period shall not be included in the time limit for trial, and the overall period may be extended to more than one year. If the administrative organ changes its administrative act in the litigation, the parties may apply for withdrawal of the suit or modification of the request, and the procedure will be shortened or transferred to a new trial accordingly.
Q5: Within how many days after receiving the land expropriation announcement should one apply for administrative reconsideration?
According to the "Administrative Reconsideration Law of the People's Republic of China" (effective from January 1, 2024), an application for administrative reconsideration should generally be submitted within 60 days from the date when the applicant knows or should have known about the administrative act; if the administrative organ fails to inform the applicant of the remedial channels and time limits, the calculation of the time limit shall be subject to other rules. The date of posting the announcement is usually regarded as the date of knowing the announcement, so when seeing the announcement, the applicant should immediately take photos to record the posting location and date, and submit the reconsideration application as soon as possible. If the applicant is not satisfied with the reconsideration decision, he/she may file a lawsuit with the people's court within 15 days from the date of receiving the decision. If the application is submitted after the expiration of the 60-day time limit, the reconsideration organ will not accept it.
The above answer is based on the judicial practice in Beijing. The adjudication guidelines in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence, to avoid missing the statutory time limit.Land expropriation and demolition legal services·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.