[Direct answer]When selecting a lawyer to defend rights in corporate demolition cases, first check three key indicators: whether the lawyer's practice focus has long been on land expropriation and demolition and administrative litigation; whether they can provide review decisions or judgment documents for similar projects for detailed verification; and whether the fees and stage-specific results are clearly stated in the contract. Advertising expenditure, office size, and verbal promises should not be used as evaluation criteria. Factory relocation involves land ownership, identification of illegal construction, calculation of compensation items, and coordination with review litigation. A lawyer must be familiar with administrative procedures and able to convert items such as equipment relocation, production and business suspension, and inventory damage into monetary values. By reviewing ownership materials and expropriation announcements with the lawyer, you can determine within half an hour whether they have actually handled similar projects before.

I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios

For enterprises located in industrial parks, logistics bases, and collective construction land outside the Fifth Ring Road of Beijing, the demolition they encounter is rarely "moved away with a notice". There are three common situations: the land is included in the scope of expropriation, but only the house replacement price is discussed, and the location difference, equipment disassembly and transportation, and order breach are not mentioned at all; first, the case of illegal construction is filed, and a notice of demolition within a specified time limit is issued, and then a very low compensation figure is retroactively calculated; after signing the agreement and handing over the house, the compensation payment is suspended after half of the amount has been paid. At this time, the confusion of the business owners is usually not about whether to protect their rights, but about who to entrust with the matter.

The expropriation process itself has a fixed chain: pre-announcement of land expropriation, investigation of the current status of the land, assessment of social stability risks, announcement of compensation and resettlement plans and solicitation of opinions, signing of compensation agreements, making compensation decisions, and applying to the people's court for enforcement. Any missing link in the chain will become a target of attack in subsequent review or litigation. Choosing a lawyer essentially means choosing someone who can understand this chain and knows where to start at each link.

The regional differences in Beijing also affect judgment. The non-residential demolition in green belt areas is mostly led by district-level governments and implemented by townships, with compensation standards that are inconsistent with those for municipal engineering projects. In the pilot areas for the marketization of collective construction land, there may coexist collective ownership, use rights, and lease rights on the same plot of land, resulting in a longer ownership chain. Applying the experience from other districts to local cases often leads to miscalculations at the first step.

II. Key points of contention

First, the qualification of the contracting parties. The collective land expropriation is organized and implemented by municipal and county people's governments. Compensation agreements signed by township governments, village committees, and development zone platform companies often raise doubts about their legal validity. Second, information asymmetry. Most of the documents such as land expropriation approval documents, survey and demarcation maps, compensation and resettlement plans, evaluation reports, and conclusions of social stability risk assessments are held by administrative authorities, while enterprises only receive a notice. Third, the valuation standards for losses. Buildings and ancillary facilities are valued at their replacement cost, equipment is valued at their depreciated value after dismantling and transportation, production and business interruptions are calculated based on the average profit of the previous three years and the duration of the interruption, and inventories are valued at their actual damage. The methods of proving these four types of losses are completely different. Fourth, procedural legitimacy. How the evaluation agencies are selected, whether there is a household survey, and whether the rights to make statements, defend oneself, and participate in hearings are informed are all verifiable key points.

Among the four points, the one that enterprises are most likely to overlook is information acquisition. Without official approval and a plan, negotiations are just empty talk. Only after obtaining the official approval and plan can we determine the size of the compensation gap and judge whether it's worth entering the reconsideration or litigation process.

The evaluation process is worth discussing separately. For factory buildings, the replacement cost is often estimated using the cost method, while the land value is referenced to the benchmark land price or the comprehensive land price of the area. The figures calculated by the two methods may differ by several times. It is common for the evaluation agency to be selected by the expropriator, for the enterprise not to be present during the inspection, and for the report not to list the details of equipment and ancillary facilities. When the enterprise receives the report, it first checks three items: the purpose of the evaluation, the value date, and the detailed breakdown. If any of these items is missing, the enterprise can request a correction in writing, and the correction record should be archived.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers

A case of administrative reconsideration over the disclosure of land expropriation information handled by Attorney He Ningning of our firm illustrates the importance of the sequence of "obtaining evidence first and then applying pressure". On September 23, 2025, Liu **, a villager of Group 1, Shuguang Village, XX Town, H City, whose house was included in the expropriation scope for the construction of the F to S high-speed railway but received no compensation, applied to the H City People's Government for the disclosure of seven pieces of land expropriation information. The municipal government refused to disclose the information on the grounds that "the house had not been expropriated and the information did not exist". Whether the administrative organ could evade its disclosure obligation by citing "the information does not exist" became the focus of the case. The attorney cited Articles 26, 28, and Paragraph 4 of Article 32 of the Implementing Regulations of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective September 1, 2021) and initiated administrative reconsideration twice.

On April 14, 2026, the administrative reconsideration organ made a second reconsideration decision. After the trial, it was found that the land involved in the case was approved for expropriation by the Ministry of Land and Resources on November 30, 2016. At that time, the Land Management Law in effect did not stipulate procedures such as pre-announcement, proof of compensation funds being in place, and social stability risk assessment, so the relevant information did not need to be prepared according to law. The reconsideration organ also pointed out the illegal points: Article 46 of the Land Management Law of the People's Republic of China before amendment (the current law has been in effect since January 1, 2020) stipulates that the expropriation of land shall be announced and organized by the county-level or higher government. This case was handled by He Ningning, a lawyer of our firm (practice certificate number: 11101202511925103, subject to the certificate issued by the judicial administrative organ).

For enterprises, the lesson of this case lies not in the outcome, but in the approach: first, retrieve the factual materials held by the administrative authority, and then discuss compensation. Information disclosure applications, administrative reconsiderations, village affairs disclosure, and demands for the performance of resettlement and compensation duties can be advanced in parallel. This approach incurs lower costs than direct litigation, yet helps accumulate bargaining chips for subsequent negotiations.

The same approach applies in factory-related cases. Enterprises can first apply to the district-level government for disclosure of the expropriation approval documents, compensation and resettlement plans, and evaluation reports. If they are not satisfied with the response, they can then apply for a reconsideration. At the same time, they should submit a written letter to the township government, demanding that it fulfill its responsibilities for resettlement and compensation. If there is no response within the time limit, it constitutes a failure to act. These two channels each generate independent subjects of reconsideration or litigation, and can be used to adjust the pace of negotiations. It should be noted that the time limits for each channel must be calculated separately and cannot be combined into a single application.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

Before and after entrusting a lawyer, you can take back the initiative in five steps. 1. **Build an Evidence Database**: Archive business licenses and tax records, land use approval documents or lease contracts, building approval and completion inspection materials, annual utility bills, equipment lists and purchase invoices, employee social insurance payment records, and pending orders and supply contracts. Maintain monthly archiving, with both paper and electronic copies. 2. **Request Public Information Disclosure**: Obtain land expropriation approval documents, compensation and resettlement plans, appraisal reports, and status investigation forms. 3. **Calculate Losses by Category**: Separately assess losses for buildings, equipment, production/business interruptions, and inventory, and prepare written valuation reports. 4. **Determine Legal Path**: - For administrative actions: File a lawsuit within six months from the date you learn or should have learned of the action, in accordance with Article 46 of the *Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China* (amended on June 27, 2017). - For public information disclosure responses: First, apply for administrative reconsideration. 5. **Timing Negotiation and Litigation**: - Use reconsideration to gain time. - Use litigation to secure leverage.

The negotiation process requires a clear schedule. Between the pre-announcement and the announcement of the plan, it's a window to strive for adjustments in the compensation terms; between the announcement of the plan and the signing of the contract, it's a window to strive for individual matters (equipment relocation, production and business suspension, relocation rewards); after signing the contract, there's usually less room for negotiation. Before each node, complete a round of material supplementation and written communication, leaving a record of the changes in the terms to avoid oral promises that can't be verified later.

The citation of legal provisions must refer to the specific article number. Article 47 of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2020) clearly stipulates that after the land expropriation is approved through legal procedures, the local people's governments at or above the county level shall announce it and organize its implementation; Articles 26, 28, and 32 of the Implementing Regulations of the Land Administration Law of the People's Republic of China (effective September 1, 2021) set out the specific requirements for the investigation of the current situation, the announcement of the expropriation plan, and the signing of the compensation agreement. Corresponding to each article, this is much more convincing than making a general claim that "the compensation is unreasonable". If you need to check against our firm's business scope, you can refer to the relevant documents.Legal services for land expropriation and demolition, and administrative litigation.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder

When choosing a lawyer, there are three actions worth persisting in: requiring them to show their lawyer's practice certificate and check the certificate number, requesting them to write down the service stages and corresponding fees in writing, and asking them to explain how many similar projects they have handled and where the process got stuck. Any lawyer who touts "internal connections" or "guarantees to win twice as much" should be viewed with suspicion. The compensation outcome depends on the ownership basis, procedural flaws, and negotiation timing. No lawyer can promise specific figures in advance. If the factory building is still intact, the equipment can still be inventoried, and the accounts have not been frozen when intervening, there are the most options; but even the strongest professional skills can only make up for the damage once the forced demolition has taken place and the materials have been lost.

There is another aspect that is easily overlooked: keeping records of decisions made within the enterprise. Shareholders' resolutions, board meeting minutes, and power of attorney documents can prove the contracting parties and the scope of their authorizations; financial ledgers and fixed asset cards can prove the original value and depreciation of equipment. When litigation actually occurs, the opposing party often defends against claims by arguing that the party lacked the authority to dispose of the assets or that the losses were not genuine. These two types of materials can effectively fill the gaps in evidence.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: The compensation plan obviously undervalues the factory building. Is there still a chance to overturn the decision through a reconsideration?

There is room for review, and the scope of review depends on procedural flaws and evidence, not emotions. The review organ reviews the legality of administrative actions. For decisions with unclear main facts, insufficient evidence, or violations of legal procedures, it may make decisions to revoke, modify, or confirm the illegality in accordance with the "Administrative Review Law of the People's Republic of China" (effective January 1, 2024). What enterprises need to prepare are photos of the announcement of the compensation plan, evaluation reports, compensation examples of similar factories, and equipment lists. If the plan is not announced and opinions are not heard in accordance with the law, it constitutes a procedural violation, and the probability of revocation will significantly increase. If the procedure is complete but the compensation amount is deemed insufficient, the review will likely be upheld. In this case, enterprises should shift to negotiation or strengthen the evidence of losses in litigation.

Q2: If an enterprise claims compensation for losses caused by production and business suspension, which types of original vouchers must they provide?

There are three categories. Business operation authenticity: business license, tax declaration forms for the past three years, and bank transaction records; profit level: financial statements or audit reports, main customer contracts, and industry profit rate information; and the shutdown period: the date of the collection notice, the date of house delivery, and the records of equipment disassembly and restart. In practice, the losses from production and business suspension are often calculated by multiplying the average profit of the past three years by the duration of the suspension. Some localities also set fixed standards based on the floor area of the premises. When supporting documents are missing, it is possible to apply to the court to retrieve tax and social insurance data to supplement the evidence, or to use indirect proof such as electricity consumption and employment records during the same period to demonstrate production capacity.

Q3: When hiring a lawyer to handle the demolition of a factory, what is the basis for calculating the fees?

There are four common types: piecework, fixed fees based on stages; hourly billing, charged by the hour; proportional fees, based on the total amount of compensation or the increase; and mixed fees, which combine a base fee with a risk-based commission. Administrative case acceptance fees are charged per case, typically 50 yuan per case. Fees involving property matters are calculated based on the value of the subject matter, and are borne by the losing party or shared according to the proportion of liability. Before signing a contract, it is necessary to specify the service stages, the delivery of legal documents, and the conditions for refunds, to avoid a situation where the lawyer provides "full-service representation" but only appears in court once. The fee level is not the only criterion; it is more important to ensure that the compensation gap is accurately calculated.

Q4: How many steps are there between the disclosure of application information and the decision on the reconsideration request?

The standard process is as follows: - Submit the application, and the administrative authority will respond within 20 working days from the date of receipt, with the possibility of extending the deadline by another 20 days. - If dissatisfied with the response, apply for administrative reconsideration within 60 days. - After accepting the request, the reconsideration authority will generally make a decision within 60 days, with the possibility of extending the deadline by 30 days in complex cases. - If dissatisfied with the reconsideration decision, file a lawsuit within 15 days. The entire process typically takes about four to six months, but may be prolonged due to corrections, extensions, or second-round reconsiderations. All receipt certificates at each stage must be preserved. Failure to respond within the deadline can itself serve as grounds for administrative omission.

Q5: If the company is asked to sign an agreement first at the negotiation table, how should it respond on the spot?

I won't sign it, but I need to leave a written record. I can ask to see the approval documents for the expropriation, the compensation plan, and the appraisal report on the spot, write down my objections in the conversation record, and ask the other party to sign for receipt. If the other party refuses, I can submit my written objections by mail and keep the mailing receipt. Blank agreements, agreements that only list the total amount without specifying the details, and clauses stipulating "waiving all subsequent claims" cannot be signed. For those that have already been signed, the party can request to revoke them within one year from the date they learn of the grounds for revocation, but the burden of proof will increase significantly. It's far more advantageous to refuse to sign on the spot than to try to remedy the situation afterwards.

The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the adjudication standards in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.

If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Land expropriation and demolition legal services·Attorney He Ningning·Beijing Henglu Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.