[Direct answer]First, review the identification subject and procedures, and then discuss whether the entity is a violation of construction regulations. Town governments and sub-district offices, in their own names, make determinations of illegal construction in urban planning areas and order demolitions, which in most cases exceed their authority; if they fail to conduct on-site inspections, inform the parties of their rights to make statements and defenses, or deliver the decision documents in accordance with the law before making such determinations, this constitutes a procedural violation. Even if the factory building indeed does not have planning permits, administrative authorities can only handle the case in accordance with legal procedures and cannot skip the announcement and notice period to proceed directly to forced demolition. For buildings that have existed for a long time, have obtained licenses and operated for a long time, the authorities should also consider the time of their establishment and the legitimate expectations of the parties concerned, and not treat them as illegal construction without exception.

I. Problem background and typical scenarios

The most common scenario is a coincidence in timing: the launch of the expropriation project, the stalemate in the compensation negotiations, and the enterprise suddenly receiving a notice requiring it to demolish the building within a specified time limit, while no one had paid attention to it for more than a decade. The enterprise had once obtained a business license, passed the fire safety inspection, paid property taxes and land use taxes on time, and even received local commendations. However, none of these details were mentioned in the determination letter.

Another type is that the factory buildings have been modified and expanded multiple times. The initial construction was subject to approval, but the subsequent additions were not. During the assessment, the entire building was identified as an illegal construction, and even the legal parts were required to be demolished. In some cases, ancillary facilities such as fences, paved ground, and awnings were all included in the area of the illegal construction, thereby expanding the scope of demolition.

At this point, business owners often fall into two extremes: one is to ignore it and believe that the identification document is not enforceable, only to have their buildings forcibly demolished; the other is to rush to find connections and coordinate with relevant departments, thereby missing the deadlines for reconsideration and litigation.

II. Key points of contention

First, determination of jurisdiction. Article 64 of the Urban and Rural Planning Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on April 23, 2019) stipulates that if a construction project fails to obtain a construction project planning permit or fails to carry out construction in accordance with the provisions of the permit, the competent urban and rural planning departments of local people's governments at or above the county level shall order the construction to be stopped, rectified within a prescribed time limit, or demolished; Article 65 stipulates that illegal construction within the planning areas of towns and villages shall be ordered by the township people's governments to stop construction and rectify within a prescribed time limit. If the factory building is located within the urban planning area and the township government makes the determination, it is an act exceeding its jurisdiction.

Secondly, whether the procedures are complete. Before making a determination, an on-site inspection should be conducted, a written record should be made, and the parties should be informed of their right to make statements and defenses. The decision document should be served in accordance with the law and the remedies should be informed. The absence of any of these steps constitutes a procedural violation.

Thirdly, whether it belongs to historical legacy. The time of the building's construction, the planning and management status at that time, and the long-term acquiescence and permission of administrative organs will all affect the judgment of legality. For cases where the procedures are incomplete due to government reasons, the enterprises should not bear all the adverse consequences.

Fourthly, whether demolition of illegal buildings is used to replace expropriation. If the time node of the demolition is close to the start of the expropriation, and the land plots are used for project construction after the demolition, it is necessary to review its true purpose.

III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm

The technical core of identifying illegal construction cases is to break down a seemingly physical problem into three levels: authority, procedure, and facts, and review them respectively. The review of authority is the fastest, checking whether the signing unit matches the statutory authority; the review of procedure is next, checking whether the inspection records, notification documents, and service receipts are complete; and the review of facts is the slowest, requiring retrieving cadastral archives, planning permits, and historical aerial maps to determine the construction era and the planning requirements at that time.

There are also independent legal requirements for the forced demolition process. Article 44 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on Administrative Enforcement (effective January 1, 2012) stipulates that for illegal buildings, structures, facilities, etc. that need to be forcibly demolished, the administrative authorities shall issue a public notice and require the parties concerned to demolish them within a specified time limit. If the parties do not apply for administrative reconsideration or initiate administrative litigation within the statutory time limit and fail to demolish the structures themselves, the administrative authorities may forcibly demolish them in accordance with the law. This means that before the expiration of the time limit for reconsideration and litigation, the administrative authorities are not allowed to forcibly demolish the structures directly. In practice, if the demolition is carried out before the expiration of the time limit, it constitutes a serious procedural violation.

The allocation of the burden of proof is favorable to enterprises. Article 34 of the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that the defendant shall bear the burden of proof for the administrative acts it has taken. If the administrative organ is unable to provide inspection records, investigation and interrogation transcripts, and collective discussion records, and simply responds with a written determination, it will be difficult to pass the legality review. The focus of the enterprise's evidence lies in the legal source and historical state of the building, with supporting evidence such as business licenses, fire inspection documents, tax payment records, and historical images.

It is important to recognize that confirming that a structure is illegal does not automatically mean that the factory building becomes a legal structure. After the judgment confirms the illegality, the administrative authority may still make a new determination based on the rectification procedure. Therefore, the design of the litigation request should be pragmatic: prioritize seeking to revoke the determination and stop its enforcement, while claiming compensation for the parts that have been demolished. These two efforts should be pursued in parallel.

IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis

First, immediately fix the current state of the building. Take comprehensive photos of the factory's exterior, internal structure, construction year markings, and surrounding reference objects, and retrieve historical satellite images or aerial photography maps to prove the building's construction time.

Secondly, collect evidence of legal operations. Business licenses, fire safety inspection or filing documents, environmental impact assessment approvals, tax registration and tax payment certificates, and water and electricity account opening records can be used to prove that the administrative authorities have been aware of the situation for a long time and have not raised any objections.

Thirdly, check the elements of the verification and determination document. The six items, including the issuing authority, the basis for the determination, the illegal facts, the scope of demolition, the time limit for performance, and the remedies, are all indispensable. Any omission of any of these items should be listed as a reason for suing.

Fourth, initiate relief in a timely manner. If you disagree with the determination or demolition decision, you may apply for administrative reconsideration within 60 days or directly file an administrative lawsuit within six months; for the demolition that has already been carried out, you may also submit a request for compensation at the same time.

Fifth, apply for a stay of execution. When filing a lawsuit, you can apply to the court for a ruling to stay the execution of the administrative act being sued, so as to avoid irreversible losses caused by the demolition of the factory building during the litigation period.

In terms of legal basis, Article 64 and Article 65 of the Urban and Rural Planning Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on April 23, 2019) respectively stipulate the entities and methods for handling illegal construction in urban planning areas and rural village planning areas; Article 44 of the Administrative Enforcement Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 2012) clearly specifies the requirements for announcements, notifications, and relief periods before forced demolition; Article 4 of the State Compensation Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 2013) stipulates the scope of compensation for illegal expropriation and requisition of property. For the cross-judgment of the identification of illegal construction and the expropriation process, please refer to the relevant provisions.Land expropriation and demolition, and administrative litigation.

5. Henglu Law Firm's Advice

Don't give up on seeking remedies just because the wording of the determination letter is harsh. In practice, many illegal construction determination letters suffer from issues such as missing essential elements, incorrect legal basis, and the subject exceeding its authority. The proportion of such letters being revoked through administrative reconsideration or litigation is not low. The real danger lies in ignoring the problem and only trying to protect one's rights after the deadline has passed, the demolition has been carried out, and the site has been destroyed.

At the same time, we should avoid another misjudgment: thinking that as long as the factory building is an old building, it must be legal. It's entirely possible for the administrative authority to make a new determination after completing the procedural formalities. A prudent approach is to argue that the procedure is illegal while negotiating compensation and resettlement at the same time, using litigation as a support for the negotiation rather than the only way out. For factory buildings with large areas and a large number of equipment, it is recommended to conduct a comprehensive asset inventory and value assessment before demolition.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: The notice of identifying illegal construction has been issued. Can this identification still be overturned?

You can try, but the success depends on the nature of the defects. If the authority lacks the necessary powers, fails to carry out the inspection and notification procedures, or fails to deliver the documents in accordance with the law, it constitutes a revocable procedural violation; if the facts relied upon are incorrect, such as including the part with planning permission in the area of illegal construction, it constitutes an unclear factual determination. The party concerned shall apply for administrative reconsideration within 60 days from the date of receipt, or file an administrative lawsuit within six months. Article 74 of the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on June 27, 2017) stipulates that if the administrative act is illegal but does not have a revocable content, the judgment shall confirm its illegality. If the demolition has been completed, revocation will be meaningless in practice, and the focus should shift to confirming the illegality and seeking compensation.

Q2: The factory building was built many years ago. What materials can be used to prove its legal existence?

The available materials include: historical topographic maps and satellite images from different years, which can intuitively reflect the construction time of buildings; approval traces such as construction land approval documents, site selection opinions, and construction permits; business license registration addresses, fire safety inspection or filing documents, and environmental impact assessment approvals; water and electricity account opening and long-term payment records; housing surveying reports and tax payment vouchers from previous years. These materials individually have limited evidentiary value, but when combined, they can form a reasonable inference that the administrative authorities have long been aware of and tacitly allowed the operation. For cases where certificates could not be obtained due to government reasons, the planning management documents at that time should also be retrieved to demonstrate that the channels for obtaining certificates did not exist objectively.

Q3: What is the approximate range of attorney's fees for litigation against unauthorized construction?

Most administrative cases are charged on a per-case or per-stage basis. For lawsuits initiated solely to revoke the determination of illegal construction, the fees are usually lower than those for comprehensive cases involving compensation amounts; if compensation for forced demolition is also claimed, the workload will increase and the fees will correspondingly rise. Risk-based fees are restricted in administrative cases, and the portion involving administrative compensation cannot be split based on the outcome. Before signing the contract, the parties should confirm whether the fees cover the review, first-instance, second-instance, and enforcement stages, as well as the way of bearing the assessment fees, appraisal fees, and travel expenses, and require the contract to specify the service list.

Q4: What are the time limits for the decision on demolition, the period for reconsideration, and the period for litigation?

The time limit for applying for administrative reconsideration is generally within 60 days from the date of knowing the decision, and it shall be submitted in accordance with the provisions of the "Administrative Reconsideration Law of the People's Republic of China" (effective from January 1, 2024); the time limit for directly initiating administrative litigation is six months, calculated in accordance with Article 46 of the "Administrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China" (amended on June 27, 2017). If the decision does not inform the remedies and time limits, there are separate rules for the calculation of the time limit, but it is still not advisable to delay. It should be noted that during the time limit for reconsideration and litigation, the administrative organ shall not implement forced demolition in accordance with Article 44 of the "Administrative Enforcement Law of the People's Republic of China" (effective from January 1, 2012).

Q5: When receiving a demolition order, what evidence should be preserved first?

There are four categories of materials that should be preserved as a priority: 1. Original notifications and delivery receipts, including return receipts, posted photos, and express delivery manifests, used to determine the delivery time and the starting point of the time limit; 2. Complete images of the building's current status, covering its exterior, structure, area references, and surrounding environment, preferably with photographic records taken on consecutive dates; 3. Legal operation and approval materials, including business licenses, fire safety and environmental impact assessment documents, and tax payment receipts; 4. Previous written statements from administrative authorities, such as meeting minutes, commitment letters, and coordination records. These materials should be backed up and stored in different locations to avoid being lost during demolition or relocation.

The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the adjudicative opinions in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.

If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Land expropriation and demolition legal services·Beijing Henglu Law Firm

Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. In case of disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.