[Direct answer]There is an agreement, and if there is no agreement, the interest shall be paid first and the principal shall be paid later. According to Article 561 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the debtor's payment is insufficient to settle all debts, unless otherwise agreed by the parties, the payment shall be applied to the relevant expenses, interest, and principal of the debt in the order of realizing the creditor's rights. Therefore, if the borrower transfers the money without specifying the purpose and there is no special agreement between the parties, the payment will first offset the interest and then the principal. The principal will not be reduced, and the interest will continue to be calculated based on the remaining principal. This will easily make the borrower feel that the more they repay, the more they owe. To change this result, it is necessary to clearly stipulate in the loan contract that the principal shall be paid first and the interest shall be paid later, or to confirm the offset method in writing after each repayment.
I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios
The order of offsetting debts may seem like a technical detail, but it actually directly determines the total amount of repayment. There are four common scenarios. First, in private lending, when the borrower agrees to repay in installments, they transfer a fixed amount each month without specifying whether it's principal or interest, and the promissory note doesn't mention the order of offsetting debts. Years later, both parties may disagree over the remaining principal. Second, between enterprises and suppliers, there may be multiple rolling loans, but when making payments, it's not specified which loan the payment corresponds to. During the reconciliation process, it's found that the payment gap is getting larger and larger. Third, after entering the enforcement process, the court deducts funds, but the applicant for enforcement and the respondent argue over which part of the deducted funds should be offset first. Fourth, when the borrower transfers funds with a note indicating repayment of principal, the lender refuses to accept or confirm it, claiming that the funds should be offset against interest first.
The common background of these disputes is a long-term lack of reconciliation. The parties often only communicate at two points: borrowing and collection. There is no written confirmation in the intervening years, and they only review the accounts when the relationship breaks down. However, neither memory nor transaction records can accurately reflect the true intentions at that time. Whoever holds the complete transaction records and reconciliation records will take the initiative in the litigation.
II. Key points of contention
The first controversy is whether the agreement is valid. The order of offsetting debts is a matter that the parties can freely agree upon. Written contracts, supplementary agreements, repayment plans, and confirmations on account statements may all constitute agreements. The key is whether there is a clear expression and whether it has been signed by both parties. The second controversy is the offsetting of multiple debts. According to Article 560, if the debtor's payment is insufficient to settle all debts, unless otherwise agreed, it shall be offset against the matured debts first; if several debts are all matured, it shall be offset against the debt for which the creditor lacks or has the least guarantee first; if the amount of the guarantee is the same, it shall be offset against the debt with a heavier burden first; if the burdens are the same, it shall be offset in the order of the debts' maturity; if the maturity time is the same, it shall be offset in proportion to the debts.
The third controversy is the interest rate cap. According to the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Private Lending Cases" (amended in 2020 and implemented on January 1, 2021), the agreed interest rate shall not exceed four times the one-year loan market quotation rate at the time of the contract's establishment. The excess part shall not be protected, and this part shall also be deducted first when offsetting. The fourth controversy is natural debts. According to Article 192, after the expiration of the statute of limitations, the obligee who agrees to perform the obligation may no longer raise the defense of statute of limitations, and the obligee who has voluntarily performed the obligation may not request a refund. Therefore, after the debts that have exceeded the statute of limitations are offset first, the borrower cannot request a refund.
The fifth controversy concerns the order of the enforcement phase. According to the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law to Calculate the Interest on Debts for Delayed Performance in the Enforcement Procedure" (effective August 1, 2014), if the property of the debtor is insufficient to pay off all debts, the debtor shall first pay off the monetary debts determined by the effective legal documents, and then pay off the interest on the doubled part of the debts, unless otherwise agreed by the parties. The sixth controversy concerns the probative force of documents. The effectiveness of transfer notes, receipts, reconciliation statements, and WeChat confirmations decreases in order, and a single note is often insufficient to override the provisions of a written contract.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers
To handle such disputes, the first step is to convert the transaction records into a table. List the date, amount, payer, recipient, remarks, and corresponding period of each payment in chronological order. Then, recalculate the difference between the remaining principal and interest using two approaches: one is to pay interest first and then the principal, and the other is to pay the principal first and then the interest. This difference often reaches thousands of yuan to tens of thousands of yuan in cases of long-term installment payments and high interest rates, which is enough to affect the bottom line of the mediation plan. The second step is to identify the written agreements. Check whether there are any statements about the order of offsetting in the IOUs, supplementary agreements, repayment commitments, or reconciliation statements. Even if there is just a sentence stating that the order of offsetting principal and interest will be negotiated separately, it may change the interpretation direction.
There are three common mistakes that need to be reminded of. Firstly, only repaying the principal without checking the details. The borrower transfers the money in whole numbers, and the lender records the payment as interest first and then the principal. After a few years, the principal amount has hardly decreased, but the borrower thinks they have almost repaid it all. Secondly, not issuing invoices or receipts when collecting the money. The lender does not provide any proof of payment after receiving the money, and later denies having received it or claims it is for other payments. Thirdly, calculating compound interest on their own. Rolling the unpaid interest into the principal and then charging interest on it again. Except for the circumstances specified in the judicial interpretation, the portion of the interest charged repeatedly is not protected, which actually undermines the credibility of the overall claim.
In a lawsuit, the party claiming the order of set-off bears the burden of proof. If the borrower claims that the parties agreed to pay the principal first and then the interest, he/she shall submit a written agreement or a subsequent confirmation; if the lender claims that the set-off shall be conducted in accordance with the statutory order, he/she only needs to prove that there is no special agreement. If neither party has any written materials, the court usually handles the case in accordance with Article 561 and judges the true purpose of each payment based on the transaction habits and the corresponding relationship between the repayment amount and the interest.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
According to Articles 560, 561, and 192 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), it is recommended to prevent risks from three aspects. At the contractual level, a separate clause on the order of offsetting should be included in the loan contract, specifying whether the principal should be repaid before interest, interest before principal, or offsetting on a pro rata basis, and stating how the costs of realizing the creditor's rights will be borne. At the performance level, each transfer should be noted in the remarks column with the corresponding installment and offsetting item. The recipient should issue a receipt or confirm it on WeChat within three days after the funds arrive, forming a consistent record between the two parties. At the settlement level, a face-to-face reconciliation should be conducted at least once a year, with both parties signing and confirming the principal, interest, and amount paid as of a certain date.
After entering the litigation process, you can apply to the court to retrieve the bank transaction records, or entrust a professional institution to calculate and explain the repayment offset; for the bills prepared unilaterally by the other party, you should promptly raise objections and submit your own calculation tables. If you have objections to the order of deduction during the enforcement stage, you can file a written objection in accordance with the "Regulations of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Enforcement Objections and Review Cases by the People's Courts" (implemented on May 5, 2015). For the connection between the contract text and the enforcement procedure, please refer to the relevant provisions.Creditor-debtor relations and enforcement case services.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
The rule of "interest first, principal later" is neutral in itself. It protects the creditor's reasonable expectation of profits during the period of fund occupation, but for the borrower, it means that the principal will not decrease for a long time. If the borrower wants to accelerate the decrease of the principal, the most effective way is not to argue about it afterwards, but to specify "principal first, interest later" in the contract or to agree on a fixed ratio of principal and interest in each repayment. Lenders should pay attention that if they do not check the principal for a long time and only collect interest, once the borrower claims that the principal has been repaid, the burden of proof will shift to themselves.
It's also worth noting that the order of offsetting payments does not affect the legality of interest rates. Even if the parties have agreed to pay interest first and then the principal, the portion of interest exceeding the statutory limit is still not protected, and the amount already paid can be claimed as an offset against the principal. For cases that have already led to disputes, it is recommended to prepare a complete repayment comparison table as soon as possible to clarify the use of each payment. This is more effective than arguing about memories in court.
From the perspective of negotiation, the order of offsetting debts can also be a bargaining chip. If the borrower raises funds in one go and repays the loan in advance, they can strive to settle the debt according to the principle of "principal before interest" or settle it at a discounted rate; if the lender wants to recover the funds as soon as possible, they can make appropriate concessions on interest in exchange for the other party giving up on the recalculation of the interest already paid. Any concessions should be written into a written agreement, indicating the settlement deadline and the remaining amount, to avoid the other party reneging on the agreement after an oral agreement.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If the promissory note does not specify the order of offsetting, how should the interest be calculated when the borrower repays the loan in installments?
Calculate in accordance with the statutory order. According to Article 561 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021), if there is no agreement, the fees for realizing the creditor's rights shall be deducted first, then the interest, and finally the principal. Each repayment shall be calculated based on the remaining principal and the agreed interest rate on that day, and the excess amount shall be deducted from the principal. Therefore, the longer the installment period and the higher the interest rate, the greater the difference between the "interest first, principal later" and the "principal first, interest later" methods. If the borrower claims that there is an oral agreement, he/she shall provide evidence himself/herself. A simple transfer note is usually not enough to overturn the statutory order.
Q2: If the same debtor owes two sums of money, one of which has exceeded the statute of limitations, which sum should be repaid first?
First, check whether there is an agreement. If there is no agreement, the rules stipulated by law shall apply. According to Article 560 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021), if several debts are all due, the debt with the least or no guarantee to the creditor shall be offset first; if the guarantees are the same, the debt with the heavier burden on the debtor shall be offset first. Debts that have exceeded the statute of limitations are natural debts. If they are offset first, the borrower shall not request the return of the debt in accordance with Article 192. If the lender wishes to preserve the creditor's rights that have not exceeded the statute of limitations, he/she shall specify the offsetting object and keep a written confirmation when collecting the payment.
Q3: If the lender rolls the interest into the principal and recalculates the interest, will the court support this?
It depends on the specific circumstances. According to the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Civil Loan Cases" (amended in 2020 and implemented on January 1, 2021), if the pre-term interest rate does not exceed four times the one-year loan market reference rate at the time of the contract's establishment, and the interest is included in the subsequent principal and a new creditor's certificate is issued, the stated amount can be recognized as the subsequent principal; the excess part shall be excluded, and the total amount of principal and interest during the entire loan period shall not exceed the total amount calculated based on the initial principal and a four-fold interest rate. Simple repeated rollover calculations without settlement certificates are usually not supported.
Q4: When executing the deduction of funds, should the interest on general debts be offset first, or the interest on the doubled portion?
First, settle the monetary debts determined by the effective legal documents. According to the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law to Calculate the Interest on Debts for Delayed Performance in the Enforcement Procedure" (effective August 1, 2014), if the debtor's property is insufficient to repay all debts, the monetary debts determined by the effective legal documents shall be repaid first, followed by the interest on the doubled portion of the debt, unless otherwise agreed by the parties. This means that general debt interest is included in the monetary debts and is repaid first, while the interest on the doubled portion of the debt is of a subordinate position. When calculating the interest, it should be listed in segments.
Q5: Can the offset confirmation signed by both parties after the fact overturn the original repayment notes?
It's usually acceptable. A confirmation letter serves as a re-settlement of a fulfilled debt. As long as it reflects the true intention of both parties and its content does not violate the law, it is binding on both parties and its legal effect is generally higher than that of a unilateral transfer note. However, if the confirmation letter harms the interests of third parties, for example, by maliciously backdating it to resist other creditors after the debt has entered the enforcement stage, it may be deemed invalid. When supplementing the signing, the settlement deadline, the total amount paid, the offset items, and the remaining amount should be specified, and both parties should sign and stamp it. If necessary, the signing process should be confirmed by a witness.
The above content is based on the compilation of judicial practices in the Beijing area. The facts of individual cases and the jurisdiction of the court may affect the conclusions. Welcome to consult Henglu Law Firm for specific situations.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials, so as to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Legal services for creditor-debtor disputes·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. In case of disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.