[Direct answer]The litigation costs are not always fully borne by the losing party. Article 29 of the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Costs" (Decree No. 481 of the State Council, effective from April 1, 2007) stipulates that the litigation costs shall be borne by the losing party, unless the winning party voluntarily assumes them; in cases of partial victory and partial defeat, the people's court shall determine the amount to be borne by each party based on the specific circumstances of the case. For cases settled through mediation, applications for withdrawal of litigation by the parties, or those heard through simplified procedures, the case acceptance fees may be paid at half the normal rate. Litigation costs are just one part of the cost of protecting one's rights. Expenses such as attorney's fees, preservation fees, and appraisal fees are not necessarily borne by the other party.
I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios
The paragraph on litigation fees attached to the main body of the judgment is the most likely to be misinterpreted. Some people believe that as long as they have filed a lawsuit, the fees will definitely be deducted from the other party's account; others, after reaching a mediation agreement, mistakenly believe that the case acceptance fees will be automatically refunded. In fact, the burden of litigation fees must be specified by the court in the legal document. If the legal document does not specify it or the parties have objections to the calculated amount, the handling process will be different.
When there are multiple defendants, debts are divided into several parts, or there is joint and several liability, it is easier to have disputes over cost sharing. When the creditor applies for enforcement, he/she also needs to pay the application enforcement fee separately, which is a separate account from the litigation fee; even if the judgment supports the main creditor, if the destination of the subject matter is unclear, the actual litigation fees may not be recovered. Estimating the costs in advance often determines whether the parties are willing to proceed with the dispute through legal procedures.
II. Key points of contention
The first point of contention is the scope of the litigation costs.According to Article 6 of the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" (Decree No. 481 of the State Council, effective from April 1, 2007), the litigation fees that parties should pay to the people's court include case acceptance fees, application fees, and the transportation, accommodation, living expenses, and work-related compensation incurred by witnesses, appraisers, translators, and adjusters when they appear in court on the dates specified by the people's court. Article 12 further clarifies that the expenses incurred during the appraisal, announcement, inspection, evaluation, auction, and sale processes shall be directly paid by the parties to the relevant institutions or units in accordance with the principle of "who claims, who bears". Confusing these expenses with litigation fees often leads to parties raising unfounded objections to the court's fees.
The second point of contention is the method of determining the burden-sharing ratio.Article 29 sets out the principles of distribution, but the specific cases still need to be decided by the people's courts; in the case of joint litigation, the court shall determine the amount of burden according to the parties' interests in the subject matter of the litigation; if the appeal upholds the original judgment, the expenses shall be borne by the appellant; if the second-instance court changes the original judgment or ruling, the second-instance court shall correspondingly change the decision on the burden of expenses of the first-instance court. After the case is concluded, the court will attach a detailed list of litigation expenses in accordance with Article 53, indicating the amounts that each party should bear.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers
The cumulative total of each segment is the part that parties are most likely to miscalculate.In property cases, the litigation fees shall be paid in accordance with Article 13, cumulatively calculated based on the amount or value of the litigation request: - For amounts not exceeding 10,000 yuan, a fee of 50 yuan shall be paid per case; - For amounts exceeding 10,000 yuan but not exceeding 100,000 yuan, a fee of 2.5% shall be paid; - For amounts exceeding 100,000 yuan but not exceeding 200,000 yuan, a fee of 2% shall be paid; - For amounts exceeding 200,000 yuan but not exceeding 500,000 yuan, a fee of 1.5% shall be paid; - For amounts exceeding 500,000 yuan but not exceeding 1 million yuan, a fee of 1% shall be paid; - For amounts exceeding 1 million yuan but not exceeding 2 million yuan, a fee of 0.9% shall be paid; - For amounts exceeding 2 million yuan but not exceeding 5 million yuan, a fee of 0.8% shall be paid. Once the litigation request amount exceeds a certain bracket, the amount of fees paid may change significantly. Therefore, the amount claimed should be limited to the extent supported by evidence.
There are also clear milestones for the entry and exit of expenses in the process.According to Article 22, the plaintiff shall pay the case acceptance fee within seven days from the day after receiving the notice of payment of litigation fees from the people's court. If the fee is not paid within the time limit and no application for judicial assistance is filed, the people's court shall handle it in accordance with the relevant provisions; if the parties increase or reduce the amount of their claims in the litigation, they shall, in accordance with Article 21, pay the additional amount or refund the corresponding acceptance fee according to the reduced amount. If they really have financial difficulties, they may apply for deferral, reduction or exemption of payment in accordance with Article 44, and Article 46 specifies that the reduction rate shall not be less than 30%.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
Firstly, calculate the accounts before filing a lawsuit.First, calculate the case acceptance fee, preservation fee, appraisal fee, and possible attorney's fee expenses, and then decide whether to proceed with mediation or litigation. If the case can be settled through mediation or the parties apply to withdraw the lawsuit, the case acceptance fee shall be paid at half the rate according to Article 15; if the case can be tried through simplified procedures, the case acceptance fee shall also be paid at half the rate according to Article 16.Secondly, the amount of the request should be consistent with the evidenceAvoid paying excessive filing fees to inflate the amount, and also avoid making arbitrary changes to the litigation requests before the conclusion of the court investigation, which may result in the refund of the fees.Thirdly, keep the payment receipts wellArticle 52 requires the people's courts to issue payment receipts to the parties, which will serve as the basis for future verification and refund procedures.
Fourth, separate fees should be charged for the execution stage.Applicants shall pay the application fee in accordance with the standards set forth in Article 14 Paragraph 1: - For an enforcement amount or value not exceeding 10,000 yuan, the fee is 50 yuan per case; - For a portion exceeding 10,000 yuan but not exceeding 500,000 yuan, the fee is calculated at a rate of 1.5%; - For a portion exceeding 500,000 yuan but not exceeding 5 million yuan, the fee is calculated at a rate of 1%; - For a portion exceeding 5 million yuan, the fee is calculated at a rate of 0.5%; - For a portion exceeding 10 million yuan, the fee is calculated at a rate of 0.1%. Article 38 clarifies that the application fee specified in Article 10 Paragraph (1) of these Measures shall be borne by the respondent. For applications for preservation measures, the fee shall be paid in accordance with the standards set forth in Article 14 Paragraph 2, provided that the maximum fee paid by the parties for such measures shall not exceed 5,000 yuan.Fifth, the channels for appealing against the conclusion on the cost are very limitedArticle 43 stipulates that the parties shall not appeal against the people's court's decision on litigation costs separately. They may apply to the president of the court that made the decision for a review, and the review decision shall be made within 15 days from the date of receipt of the application.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
When handling such cases, Hengluo Lawyers usually prepare a cost estimate form for clients, listing the amount of the litigation request, the choice of procedures, the circumstances in which a reduction in fees can be obtained, and the application fees in the execution stage, rather than passively accepting the fees after the judgment is made. Although the burden of litigation fees is determined by the court, the determination of the amount of the request, the choice of procedures, and the timing of mediation are all in the hands of the parties, and these three factors are what really affect the cost.
There are also two points that need to be reminded. Firstly, after the court determines the litigation fees according to law, the parties are not allowed to appeal the fees separately, and the remedy channels are limited. Therefore, it is more important to solidify the basis of their claims during the stages of suing and appealing. Secondly, according to Article 53, if the litigation fees should be refunded, the people's court shall refund them within 15 days from the date when the legal document takes effect; the winning party cannot collect the litigation fees from the losing party by itself. Any claim that the party who paid the fees in advance can recover them from the other party lacks legal basis.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Does the losing party always have to bear all the litigation costs?
Not necessarily. Article 29 of the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Costs" (Decree No. 481 of the State Council, effective from April 1, 2007) stipulates that the litigation costs shall be borne by the losing party, unless the winning party voluntarily assumes them; in cases of partial victory and partial defeat, the people's court shall determine the amount to be borne by each party according to the specific circumstances of the case. For cases settled through mediation, applications for withdrawal of suits, or those tried under simplified procedures, the acceptance fees shall be paid at half the normal rate in accordance with Articles 15 and 16. The principle that the losing party bears all the costs is just a general statement. In individual cases, the decision text and the detailed list of expenses shall prevail.
Q2: In cases where the plaintiff partially wins the lawsuit, how are the litigation fees shared?
It is determined by the court's discretion and there is no fixed ratio. Taking a loan dispute as an example, if the plaintiff requests 1 million yuan in principal and interest, the court will only support a portion of it. The case acceptance fee is usually shared according to the amount of the disputed subject matter finally determined by the court and the ratio of winning and losing. The fees corresponding to the unsupported part shall be borne by the claimant. In the case of joint litigation, according to Article 29 Paragraph 3 of the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees", the court shall determine the amount of the fees borne by each party according to their interest in the litigation subject matter. After receiving the document, the parties should focus on checking the detailed list of litigation fees attached to Article 53.
Q3: How much case acceptance fee do I need to pay in advance when filing a lawsuit?
For property cases, the litigation fees shall be accumulated and calculated according to the amount of the litigation request, subject to Article 13: For cases with a litigation request amount not exceeding 10,000 yuan, a fee of 50 yuan shall be paid per case; for cases with a litigation request amount exceeding 10,000 yuan but not exceeding 100,000 yuan, a fee of 2.5% shall be paid; for cases with a litigation request amount exceeding 100,000 yuan but not exceeding 200,000 yuan, a fee of 2% shall be paid; for cases with a litigation request amount exceeding 200,000 yuan but not exceeding 500,000 yuan, a fee of 1.5% shall be paid; for cases with a litigation request amount exceeding 500,000 yuan but not exceeding 1 million yuan, a fee of 1% shall be paid; for cases with a litigation request amount exceeding 1 million yuan but not exceeding 2 million yuan, a fee of 0.9% shall be paid. The plaintiff shall pay the litigation fees in advance within 7 days from the day after receiving the notice of payment of litigation fees from the people's court, and Article 22 has clear provisions on the time limit; for non-property cases, a fee of 50 yuan to 100 yuan shall be paid per case.
Q4: Do both the litigation fees and attorney's fees have to be borne by the other party?
Generally, this is not the case. Litigation fees are determined in accordance with national regulations and are calculated in accordance with Articles 6 and 13 of the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Costs". Attorney fees, which are the consideration for the commissioned services, are agreed upon by the client and the law firm and are not included in the scope of litigation costs. In principle, each party bears their own expenses. Only in cases where the law or judicial interpretations explicitly stipulate or the contract clearly stipulates that the other party shall bear the expenses, can a claim be made. The common basis for this is the breach of contract liability clauses in the contract and the agreement on the burden of realizing the creditor's rights. When making a claim, it is generally necessary to provide the commission contract and invoice certificates.
Q5: If I disagree with the outcome of the litigation fee burden, can I apply for a review?
It is possible to request a review, but not to appeal. Article 43 stipulates that parties may not separately appeal against the people's court's decision on litigation costs; if parties have objections to the decision, they may apply to the presiding judge of the court that made the decision for a review. The review decision shall be made within 15 days from the date of receipt of the party's application. If parties have objections to the court's calculation of litigation costs, they may request a review from the court that made the decision. If there are indeed errors in the calculation, the court shall correct them. The time limit is short and the channels are narrow. It is advisable to check the basis for calculating the fees with the case handler before the end of the litigation.
The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the adjudication guidelines in other regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.
If you are currently facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →\nLegal services for creditor-debtor disputes·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and publicly available adjudication rules, and is provided for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If a dispute arises, please consult a practicing lawyer in a timely manner.