[Direct answer]The fact that the house is mortgaged does not invalidate the existing lease contract. Article 275 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) stipulates that if the ownership of the leased property changes during the lease term, the effectiveness of the lease contract shall not be affected. If the house is transferred by auction or sale after the mortgage right is realized, the lease relationship will generally remain effective against the buyer. The real impact arises at the stage when the mortgagee exercises his rights: if the lessee still needs to vacate the premises upon the expiration of the lease term, and if the lessee knew at the time of signing the contract that the house had been mortgaged or sealed up, the court may apply the rule of "the lease prevails over the sale" more strictly. If the landlord conceals the fact of the mortgage and disposes of the property without authorization, the lessee may claim breach of contract and demand compensation for the residual value of the decoration and the relocation losses.
1. Problem background and typical scenarios
A common scenario is that after living in the rental property for one or two years, tenants suddenly receive a call from the court informing them that the house has been sealed up due to debts and will soon be listed on the judicial auction platform. The landlord mortgaged the rental property to the bank for financing, but failed to repay the loan when it matured. The bank then sued and applied for enforcement, with the auction announcement stating that the property will be auctioned with or without the lease. The former means that tenants will face the new buyer, while the latter means that they must vacate the property within a specified timeframe. Prior to this, tenants are often unaware of the mortgage, pay rent on a monthly basis, and have their deposits held by the landlord. Suddenly, they are asked to move out.
There is another type of problem that was exposed earlier: when signing the contract, the house was already mortgaged and even entered the execution process, but the landlord still rented it out at the normal market price. After moving in, tenants gradually found that the execution ruling documents and appraisal reports were posted at the door, and the rent was significantly lower than that of similar properties in the surrounding area. Moreover, tenants and landlords were not in a direct relationship, but moved in through the platform operator, with the contract counterparty being a certain homestay company. When asked about the mortgage situation, the other party evaded answering. In such cases, the timing of knowledge and the attribution of responsibility become the main points of controversy.
II. Key points of contention
The first point of contention is when the mortgage right is established and when it can be invoked against third parties. Article 403 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) stipulates that where the debtor or a third party provides a mortgage guarantee for real estate, the mortgagee shall acquire the mortgage right from the date recorded in the real estate registration book; Article 404 specifically states that where the mortgage is established by registration, the mortgage right shall be established upon registration. Therefore, whether the mortgage is effective and when it is established can be verified by checking the registration book records, and the validity of the lease contract does not preclude this.
The second point of contention is the continuation of the lease relationship after the mortgage right is realized. The rules of Article 725 apply to changes in ownership. Auction and sale also belong to methods of changing ownership. In principle, the lease contract continues to be effective for the new owner. However, there are limitations to these rules: if the lessee knows or should have known that the house has been mortgaged or sealed up, but still leases it, and continues to occupy it to resist the rights holder in the enforcement process, the court may not grant the same protection as that for a bona fide lessee; if the lessee colludes with the mortgagor or the rights holder to harm the interests of others, they may also violate the provisions of Article 154 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021) on the invalidity of civil legal acts.
The third point of contention is the preemptive right of purchase and procedural nodes. Article 726, paragraph 3 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) stipulates that if the lessor sells the leased house, the lessor shall notify the lessee within a reasonable period before the sale, and the lessee shall have the right to purchase the house on equal terms, unless the co-owners of the house exercise the preemptive right of purchase or the lessor sells the house to a close relative. In the judicial auction process, the preemptive right of purchase needs to be declared and confirmed in accordance with the requirements of the auction announcement and the executing court. Failure to declare within the time limit is usually regarded as a waiver, and the declaration point thus becomes a watershed for whether the right can be realized.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
When dealing with such issues, lawyers usually do two things first. The first is to establish a timeline: the date of signing the lease contract, the record of rent payments, the time of occupancy and possession, the date of registration of the real estate mortgage, the date of the court's seizure ruling, the date of the auction announcement, and the deadline for eviction. These dates, when listed together, can often be characterized with a single sentence. For example, if the mortgage registration precedes the lease contract and the tenant could have checked it at the time but failed to do so, the likelihood of knowing about it clearly increases; if the mortgage registration occurs after the signing of the contract and the landlord never informed the tenant, the landlord can be held liable for failing to fulfill his obligation to inform. The second is to determine the remedy path: if the lease relationship is still in effect, proceed with third-party objections and claims within the enforcement process; if the lease expires or the house is forcibly evicted, switch to a lawsuit for breach of contract compensation.
In the enforcement process, the lessee cannot only file a civil lawsuit. A third party who raises a written objection to the enforcement target shall file such objection and submit evidence materials to the enforcement court before the end of the enforcement process. The court shall make a ruling after reviewing the materials. If the parties, interested parties, and third parties are dissatisfied with the ruling, they may also apply for a review or file a lawsuit in accordance with the provisions of the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on September 1, 2023). There is a specific order to this process: first, assert rights within the enforcement process, and then pursue litigation. If the procedural steps are incorrect, even if the substantive claims are well-founded, it will still be difficult to enforce them effectively.
There is also room for manoeuvre at the negotiation level. Creditors such as banks are usually concerned about the transaction price and the speed of delivery. If tenants cooperate with the eviction and explain the lease relationship to the buyers clearly, they may in return get a longer eviction period or appropriate compensation. If they have a preemptive right to purchase and sufficient funds, participating in the bidding under the same conditions is often more reliable than passively waiting for eviction. In addition, the difference between the appraised value and the actual eviction cost can sometimes be dealt with through an enforcement settlement. It is necessary to list the residual value of decoration, relocation expenses, and the difference in temporary rental fees in detail and provide evidence for each item.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
It is recommended to respond to the risks in three stages. Before signing the contract: - Check the ownership and mortgage/seizure status of the property at the real estate registration authority. - Require the lessor to disclose the mortgage and seizure information in writing in the contract, and stipulate the right of rescission, compensation scope, and rent settlement method in the event that the lessor sets up a mortgage, transfers the property, or is subject to enforcement without authorization. - Require the lessor to retain copies of the ownership certificates. After signing the contract: - Pay the rent on schedule and keep the transfer receipts and invoices. - Save photos of the property's current condition, the original lease contract, and any supplementary agreements. When discovering abnormalities: - Immediately submit a written objection to the enforcement court with a list of evidence, and simultaneously send a written reminder to the lessor to fix the evidence and breach of contract facts that they either knew or should have known. Avoid oral negotiations only.
For the practical guidelines on the realization of mortgage rights and the eviction process, please refer to our firm's official document.House mortgage and leasing practicesThe column includes guidance on how to handle registration inquiries, file objections, and declare preemptive purchase rights.
In terms of legal basis, the establishment and effectiveness of mortgage contracts and mortgage rights are governed by Articles 402, 403, and 404 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021). The notification of transferring property during the mortgage period and the deposit of the sale price are subject to Article 406. The mortgagee's priority to receive compensation from the auction or sale price is governed by Article 141. The continuation of the lease relationship is subject to Article 725, and the lessee's preemptive right of purchase is governed by Article 726 Paragraph 3. The lessor's breach of contract liability is governed by Article 577. The rights claim is subject to the three-year statute of limitations under Article 188. The adjudication rules for the relationship between leasing and ownership changes can be found in the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Trials of Urban House Lease Contract Disputes" (amended on December 29, 2020). The specific requirements for enforcement procedures, third-party objections, and priority purchase declarations are governed by the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on September 1, 2023) and the relevant provisions on online judicial auctions. The time limits for each step shall be subject to the written notice of the enforcement court.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
First, it's important to conduct a thorough investigation. Before renting a property, check the real estate registration information. This costs very little, but can help avoid most subsequent troubles. If the property has been sealed off, it's advisable to sign a long-term contract with caution, especially not to pay a large amount of rent and decoration fees in advance without written disclosure. Second, don't gamble with the rent. If the lease is deemed invalid, or if the property is auctioned after the mortgage right is realized and the lease has expired, the lessee may not only lose the property but also have difficulty retrieving the deposit.
Third, we need to have a strong sense of time limits. The declaration of priority purchase rights, objections from third parties, the statute of limitations, and the eviction deadline correspond to different stages. Missing one of them means losing a chance. When receiving materials served by the court, we should record the date and check the content on the same day, rather than waiting until we have a clear overall picture to take action. Organizing the lessee's qualifications, the lease term, the facts of possession, and the situation of knowing about the mortgage into a one-page timeline is often the most effective communication material during consultations.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If the house is mortgaged, can I still continue to live in it?
In principle, the tenant can continue to live there. If the ownership of the house changes due to the realization of the mortgage right, it will not affect the validity of the lease contract during the lease period. Article 725 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021) clearly stipulates this, and the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trials of Urban House Lease Contract Disputes" (amended on December 29, 2020) also confirms that changes in ownership do not affect the validity of the lease contract. However, there are two exceptions: if the house was sealed up or the mortgage right had entered the realization process when the lease contract was signed, the right holder may claim to vacate the house after terminating the lease relationship; if the lessee colludes with the mortgagor to harm the right holder's interests, the lease may not be effective for the right holder. What the tenant needs to do is to check the real estate registration book to confirm the time of mortgage registration, and continue to pay the rent according to the contract and keep the payment receipts to avoid being held liable for breach of contract due to non-payment of the rent.
Q2: If the landlord conceals the mortgage, can I terminate the lease and get a refund for the deposit?
You can claim to rescind the contract and demand compensation according to Article 577 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), which stipulates that breach of contract liabilities include continued performance, remedial measures, and compensation for losses. If the lessor conceals the mortgage and causes the lessee to have a wrong understanding of the property rights status of the house when signing the contract, it constitutes gross negligence or even fraud. The lessor may also bear the responsibility of rescinding the contract. The statute of limitations for the right of rescission is within one year from the date when the lessor knows or should have known the grounds for rescission. The items of compensation generally include the paid rent, the deposit, the relocation expenses, the difference in the temporary rental rent and the residual value of the decoration. You need to submit the lease contract, the payment receipts for the rent, the registration and inquiry records, the communication records, and the list of loss calculations. Before the dispute is resolved, you should send a written notice and set a reasonable time limit to avoid making oral claims that lead to unclear facts.
Q3: After the mortgage right is realized, does the lease of the house still apply if the house is auctioned off?
Mathematically, the lease contract does not automatically terminate due to an auction. Article 275 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) stipulates that if the ownership of the leased property changes during the lease term, it shall not affect the validity of the lease contract. Auction and sale belong to the methods of ownership change, and the buyer shall continue to perform the lease contract, and the tenant may continue to use the property until the lease term expires. It is necessary to distinguish two things: after the lease term expires, the tenant shall vacate and return the house, and the subsequent occupation shall be subject to the payment of usage fees according to new standards; during the lease term, if the tenant defaults on the rent or sublets the property without authorization due to his own reasons, the lessor may still terminate the contract according to the agreement. If the buyer applies for forced eviction, the tenant shall file a written third-party objection with the enforcement court before the conclusion of the enforcement procedure, and submit the contract, payment receipts, and evidence of possession. This procedure has more advantages than civil litigation afterwards.
Q4: Can I claim the right of first refusal during the auction?
Anyone who meets the requirements can claim this right based on Article 726, Paragraph 3 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021): If the lessor sells the leased house, he shall notify the lessee within a reasonable period before the sale, and the lessee shall have the right of priority to purchase the house under the same conditions. This rule also applies to judicial auctions, but the procedures are stricter: the right of priority to purchase must be declared to the executing court within the time limit specified in the auction announcement and confirmed by the court. Failure to declare within the time limit is generally deemed as a waiver of this right. When declaring, the applicant generally needs to submit materials such as identity proof, lease contract, and proof of rent payment, and state that he/she is willing to purchase the house under the same conditions. Except for cases where the co-owners of the house exercise the right of priority to purchase or the lessor sells the house to a close relative, the right of priority to purchase no longer applies. Therefore, it is very necessary to check the identity and share of the property owner before signing the contract.
Q5: Can tenants request compensation for the money they spent on renovations?
It can be claimed, but generally not in full. The renovation investment should be converted based on the remaining use value, taking into account the length of use, the value of the removable parts, the cost of demolition and restoration to the original state, and whether the landlord was aware of and agreed to the renovation. The basis is Articles 577, 714, and 715 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), as well as the provisions on the handling of the residual value of decoration in the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trials of Urban Housing Lease Contract Disputes" (amended on December 29, 2020). The list of materials needed includes the construction contract, payment receipts, invoices for materials and labor, a bill of quantities, photos before and after the renovation, concealed works inspection forms, and materials for appraisal applications. If the renovation is not approved in writing by the lessor, the compensation space will generally be limited. Therefore, signing a written confirmation and keeping construction images before the renovation is the most economical way to preserve evidence.
This article is written based on the common judicial interpretations in the Beijing area. If the case occurs in other regions, it is recommended to consult local lawyers to verify the regional differences.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Legal services for the purchase and sale of real estate·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and public adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.