[Direct answer]An oral rental agreement is generally valid. Article 707 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) requires that leases with a term of more than six months be in writing. However, if the parties have actually delivered the house, paid the rent, and moved in, the lease relationship will still be protected by law; if the lease term cannot be determined, it will be deemed an indefinite lease. The real difficulty is not the form of the contract, but whether it is possible to reconstruct the rent and lease term agreed orally with transfer records, chat records, move-in certificates, etc. In the event of a dispute, the parties should first secure evidence, then assert their rights based on the actual performance of the contract or the rules of an indefinite lease, and, if necessary, hire a lawyer to evaluate the litigation strategy.
I. Problem background and typical scenarios
In practice, a large number of leasing relationships are based on oral communication: after being shown the property by an acquaintance or an agent, the parties negotiate the monthly rent and the deposit method in person. The tenant transfers the money, picks up the keys, and moves in. The two parties never sign a written contract. Matters such as renewal of the lease, repairs, and subletting often remain only in WeChat voice messages or verbal promises. When everything is going well, there may not be any problems. However, once the landlord suddenly raises the rent, the tenant leaves early to claim the deposit, or there are disputes over responsibility for damage to the property, the shortcomings of the vague oral agreements will become apparent.
There are three more common situations: First, after the tenant has lived in the house for several months, the landlord claims that he can take back the house at any time on the grounds that no contract has been signed; Second, the lessor denies the free rental period or maintenance obligations promised at the beginning; Third, the tenant insists on continuing to live according to the long-term lease agreed upon orally, but the landlord only recognizes the monthly lease. The outcome of the arbitration largely depends on which party can fully restore the oral content at that time with evidence, rather than who speaks first or who shouts the loudest.
From the perspective of the source of the cases, whole renting, shared renting, direct renting by individual landlords, and subletting by secondary landlords may all establish relationships orally. Among them, subletting by secondary landlords is most prone to problems: subtenants often haven't even met the real property owners, and the lease term promised orally has no connection with the actual lessors. Once the real lessors claim to reclaim the house, the subtenants will find it difficult to prove the existence of the contract or the other party's right to sublet. In addition, short-term tenants who renew their leases monthly are more accustomed to oral communication, and the density of disputes among them is even higher than that among tenants who have signed long-term contracts. This is not necessarily related to the parties' legal awareness.
II. Key points of dispute
Firstly, whether the lease contract is established and what its content is. Oral agreements also constitute a form of contract formation. As long as both parties reach an agreement on the house, rent, and lease term and have actually performed the contract, the contract is deemed to be established. Disputes usually arise over the specific terms of the contract, with each party holding a different viewpoint.
Second, the legal consequences when the lease term cannot be determined. According to Article 730 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if there is no agreement on the lease term or the agreement is unclear and no supplementary agreement can be reached, it shall be deemed an indefinite lease. Both parties may terminate the contract at any time, but the terminating party shall notify the other party within a reasonable period of time.
Thirdly, the burden of proof and the strength of evidence. The party claiming the existence of the contract and its content shall bear the burden of proof. Whether the WeChat records retain the original carrier, whether the transfer is marked with the purpose of rent, and whether there are receipts and handover records all directly affect the court's conclusion on the determination of the facts.
Fourthly, the procedural aspect also involves the choice of case basis and jurisdiction. Such disputes are usually filed as lease contract disputes, and are subject to the jurisdiction of the court where the real estate is located or the defendant's residence. Requests such as arrears in rent, security deposits, and eviction can be combined into a single claim, which can save the cost of multiple rounds of litigation. Listing the claim amounts item by item before suing can also help the court quickly determine the scope of the trial and shorten the scheduling time.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
Based on Hengluo Lawyer's experience in handling lease disputes, the written form requirement in Article 707 is a regulatory guideline rather than a mandatory provision with legal effect. In judicial practice, it is generally believed that even if there is no written contract, the lease contract is still valid and effective if the rent has been actually paid and the house has been actually delivered for use. What is really weakened is the certainty of the lease term - when the lack of a written form results in an undetermined lease term, the court usually handles it as an indefinite lease. The lessor can terminate the contract after giving reasonable notice in advance, and the long-term stable residence expected by the tenant will lose its guarantee.
Another common misunderstanding is the lack of evidence awareness. Many tenants only save the transfer screenshots but delete the chat records, or pay the rent in cash without any receipts, making it difficult to clarify the nature of the payment in court. Moreover, some parties mistakenly believe that if no contract is signed, the landlord cannot reclaim the property. In fact, non-fixed-term leases precisely grant both parties the right to terminate the contract at any time. When handling such cases, Henglu Law Firm usually guides clients to export and notarize WeChat records, retrieve transfer transaction records, and organize move-in and payment certificates, transforming verbal agreements into admissible evidence chains. For the handling approach to housing lease disputes, please refer to our firm's guidance.Legal services for property purchase and sale disputesA special introduction to it.
It's worth noting that notarization is not the only option. If both parties repeat the rent, lease term, and deposit method in WeChat and reply with their agreement, they can meet the written form requirement according to Article 469, and the evidentiary value is far higher than that of scattered voice clips. Hengluo Lawyers will also advise clients to send a confirmation message to the other party after each payment and keep the reply. These seemingly trivial records are important evidence for locking in the lease term and resisting the right to terminate the contract at any time. For clients who have entered the dispute stage, lawyers will first assess the evidence gaps and then decide whether to fix the facts through supplementary confirmation, witness testimony, or applying for electronic data appraisal.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
It is recommended to complete the evidence collection according to the checklist: rental transfer receipts (with the rental month noted in the remarks column), the original media of WeChat or QQ chat records, voice and call recordings, deposit receipts, photos of the house condition at the time of moving in, utility bills, and witness clues from neighbors or real estate agents. For those who have already moved in but not signed a contract, they can actively request the landlord to sign a written contract, or ask him to issue a receipt stating the lease term and monthly rent when collecting the payment. This written confirmation is often more convincing than disputes arising after the fact.
In terms of legal basis: The effectiveness of the contract and the rules on indefinite leases are stipulated in Article 707 and Article 730 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective from January 1, 2021); the provision that data messages can be tangibly represented as written form is stipulated in Article 469 of the same law. Both parties explicitly agreed on the rent and lease term in WeChat and agreed with each other, which also meets the written requirements; the statute of limitations for claiming rights is three years, in accordance with Article 188 of the same law. In terms of procedural choice, it is advisable to first negotiate and sign the contract, and if no agreement is reached, then proceed with litigation, so as to avoid dragging matters that could have been discussed at the negotiating table into the courtroom.
At the procedural stage, before filing a lawsuit, parties can first apply for people's mediation or seek help from street mediation organizations. After reaching a mediation agreement, they can apply for judicial confirmation to grant enforceability. If mediation fails and a case is filed, parties can simultaneously apply for property preservation to prevent the lessor from transferring funds. Some courts in Beijing apply the fast-track trial mechanism to small-scale lease disputes, with the process from case filing to mediation and conclusion sometimes taking less than a month. The time and cost involved are much lower than those of full litigation, making it worth trying first.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
Oral leases are not invalid, but tenants are indeed in a more vulnerable position: the lease term cannot be determined, and they may be notified to move out at any time. There are two most economical ways to protect themselves: when signing the contract, insist on putting it in writing, even if it's just a note signed by both parties; if it's not possible to sign a contract, repeat the important agreements in WeChat and obtain the other party's confirmation. If you have already fallen into a stalemate where the landlord denies the oral agreement, do not move out or refuse to pay the rent first, so as not to put yourself in a breach of contract situation. You should first fix the evidence and consult a professional. This firmReal estate and construction project legal teamProvide solution evaluation and agency services for such disputes. The earlier we get involved, the more conducive it is to preserving evidence.
It's equally important to remind landlords that denying verbal agreements doesn't necessarily give them an advantage. If tenants have been paying the same amount for several consecutive months and actually living there, the court can fully presume that a lease relationship has been established, and the landlord may even be liable for compensation if they breach the contract midway. Honest performance and written records are the most cost-effective way for both parties to get along with each other.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: If I haven't signed a written contract for the rental, can I still sue the landlord if a dispute arises?
You can file a lawsuit. Oral lease contracts are also protected by law. Article 707 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) only requires that leases of more than six months be in writing. If the lease is not in writing and the lease term cannot be determined, it shall be treated as an indefinite lease, and the validity of the contract itself shall not be affected. The prerequisite for filing a lawsuit are to prove the existence of the lease relationship: transfer records, chat records, and check-in certificates can all be used. It is recommended to fully export the evidence before filing a lawsuit, and if necessary, have the electronic records notarized. Then, the lawyer will determine the case basis and the jurisdiction of the court to avoid losing the lawsuit due to insufficient evidence. When filing a lawsuit, remember to also claim overdue interest, which will provide an additional safeguard for subsequent enforcement.
Q2: What evidence can prove the rent and lease term agreed upon orally?
The proof of an oral agreement mainly relies on four types of materials: first, payment receipts, bank transfer records or WeChat/Alipay transfer records, preferably with a note indicating the monthly rent, which can correspond to the amount and period; second, communication records, such as WeChat chats, voice messages, and call recordings, which need to be kept on the original mobile device. Screenshots can only be used as supplementary evidence; third, performance receipts, such as deposit receipts, utility bills, and records of access control and key handover; fourth, third-party testimonies, such as statements from real estate agents and neighbors about the facts of the rental. The materials should be able to corroborate each other, forming a complete chain of agreement content, actual performance, and continuous residence. Isolated evidence is difficult to support the claim of the rental period.
Q3: If there's no contract, does the landlord have legal grounds to evict tenants at any time?
It depends on whether the lease term can be determined. According to Article 730 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021), if the lease term is not specified and cannot be supplementarily determined, it shall be deemed a non-fixed-term lease. The lessor may terminate the contract at any time, but shall notify the lessee within a reasonable period of time to allow the lessee to vacate the premises and find another place to live. If it can be proven that the parties have agreed on a clear lease term, the landlord's termination of the contract in the middle of the term is a breach of contract, and the tenant may claim for continued performance or compensation for losses. Therefore, the dispute over whether it is reasonable to evict someone actually focuses on the proof of the lease term. It is necessary to prioritize organizing WeChat confirmation records and continuous payment receipts.
Q4: How much does it usually cost to fight a verbal lease lawsuit?
The fees are divided into two parts. The litigation fees are calculated according to the amount of the litigation request in stages, as stipulated in the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Fees" (implemented on April 1, 2007). For example, for the rent deposit requested to be returned, the fee is 50 yuan per case if the amount is less than 10,000 yuan, and the excess part is increased proportionally. The losing party ultimately bears the cost, or the cost is shared according to the outcome of the case. There is no unified government pricing for attorney's fees. The fees are charged on a per-case, hourly, or proportional basis, depending on the subject matter and complexity of the case, and the fees are subject to the provisions of the contract. The subject matter of such cases is generally not large, and most parties choose a per-case fee. Before suing, the litigation costs and the recoverable amount should be calculated first, and then a decision should be made on whether to litigate.
Q5: How long will it take to get a judgment result if I sue my landlord?
The duration of the legal process can be estimated as follows: According to the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (amended in 2023), the first-instance ordinary procedure shall be concluded within six months from the date of acceptance of the case, and the simple procedure shall be applied for three months; if the parties appeal against the judgment, the second-instance procedure shall generally be concluded within three months. Lease disputes are relatively simple in nature, and most of them can apply for the simple procedure. From the acceptance of the case to the first-instance judgment, it usually takes two to four months. It should also be noted that Article 188 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China stipulates a three-year statute of limitations, which starts from the date when the party knows that his rights have been infringed. Delaying in suing may lead to the loss of the right to win the case, so it is better to claim rights as soon as possible.
The above answer is based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. The judicial interpretation in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Legal services for the purchase and sale of real estate·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.