[Direct answer]It's not allowed to directly change the locks. Although tenants defaulting on rent constitutes a breach of contract, landlords have no right to directly change the locks, inventory and remove the tenants' belongings. Such private remedies are easily regarded as infringements, and landlords may instead bear compensation and even administrative responsibilities. The safe approach involves three steps: first, issue a written notice of default and retain the delivery receipt; if the tenant still fails to pay within a reasonable period after the notice, terminate the contract in accordance with Article 722 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021); then, pursue the unpaid rent, occupancy fees, and breach of contract penalties through litigation and, if necessary, apply for property preservation. Forcible eviction should be completed through court enforcement procedures.
1. Problem background and typical scenarios
Arrears in rent are the most common type of housing rental disputes. There are typically three typical scenarios: First, tenants face operational difficulties or income disruptions, and fail to pay rent for two or three consecutive months while refusing to move out. Second, tenants withhold rent on the grounds of housing leaks, equipment malfunctions, and other defects, with both parties having conflicting opinions. Third, deposit disputes overlap with rent arrears. Tenants want to use the deposit to directly offset the last few months' rent, while landlords insist on full payment before discussing the return of the deposit. Some tenants take advantage of the landlord's reluctance to sue, dragging out the situation for more than half a year, allowing the arrears to accumulate like a snowball. In commercial storefront leases, there are special circumstances such as business closures for renovations or temporary work stoppages. After identifying the reasons for the rent arrears, more flexible solutions can be implemented to address the issue.
Faced with these situations, many landlords' first reaction is to change the locks, cut off water and electricity, or clear out the tenants' belongings while they're away. This approach may seem satisfying, but in reality, it turns them from the party fulfilling the contract into the party infringing it, giving the other party a basis for claiming compensation. What was originally a simple issue of unpaid rent can drag on into two legal cases. More commonly, the two parties end up arguing in the hallway, completely ruining their relationship, with no room for further negotiation. Some landlords even damage the tenants' computers and furniture during the clear-out process, only to be ordered to pay compensation that exceeds the amount of rent recovered, making the effort completely futile.
There is also a high-frequency scenario that often occurs in the long-term rental apartment and second-hand landlord chains: after the subletting chain breaks down, the actual residents cannot find the real right holders, nor can anyone collect the rent, and the house is left in a state of limbo for a long time. At this time, the landlord cannot directly dispose of the items in the house. He should first verify the occupancy status and the validity of the subletting contract, otherwise, it is very easy to infringe the interests of legitimate sub-lessees.
II. Key points of contention
Firstly, does the landlord have the right to reclaim the house by private force? During the term of the lease, the tenant enjoys the legal right to occupy and use the house. Even if the tenant owes rent, the landlord cannot deprive him of his possession without going through the termination procedure, otherwise it may constitute infringement. The responsibility for keeping the items in the house will also be transferred to the landlord. If the items taken away are lost or damaged, the landlord will have to compensate for them. Even if the landlord wins the lawsuit in the future, this episode of infringement will be used by the other party to offset the claim for unpaid rent, thus losing the bargaining chip in the negotiation.
Secondly, whether the contract has been terminated and when it was terminated. Arrears in rent do not necessarily lead to the termination of the contract. It is necessary to first issue a reminder and grant a reasonable period for making up the arrears; the time of delivery of the notice of termination directly determines the starting point of the occupation and use fee. Whether the notice is deemed to be delivered on the date of EMS receipt or on the date of WeChat delivery, the parties' disputes often focus on these time points. A one-month difference can result in a difference of thousands of yuan.
Thirdly, how to calculate and offset the amounts. The unpaid rent, occupancy fees, liquidated damages, and deposit refunds are often intertwined. If the agreed liquidated damages are too high, the court may reduce them at its discretion. It's also necessary to check who will bear the water, electricity, and gas fees and property management fees. Whether the deposit can be directly offset against the unpaid rent also depends on the contract terms. These figures directly determine how to list the litigation claims and how much can ultimately be recovered through enforcement.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Lawyers
When Hengluo Law Firm handles such cases, it usually first reviews three sets of materials: the provisions in the lease contract regarding payment deadlines, conditions for termination, and breach of contract liabilities; the rental payment records and reconciliation records; and the delivery receipts for the reminder letters and termination notices. In practice, many landlords lose not because of substantive rights, but because of procedural issues—for example, the contract stipulates that the lease can only be terminated after two months of rent arrears, but the landlord unilaterally changes the locks when the rent arrears reach three weeks. The tenants then claim that the landlord breached the contract and demand compensation. Such reverse claims are not uncommon and often succeed in court. At the trial, if the landlord cannot provide delivery receipts, the validity of the termination action will first be questioned, and every subsequent step will be passive. Cross-checking and supplementing the evidence item by item according to the contract provisions is the first thing lawyers do after getting involved in the case.
From the perspective of the judge's bias, the court generally recognizes the compliance path of urging, reasonable time limit, and notice of termination, and holds a negative attitude towards self-help remedies such as cutting off water and electricity, changing locks, and clearing out belongings. The reason is that the tenant's right to housing is also protected by law, and disputes over arrears in rent should be resolved through the procedures of contract termination and enforcement. The occupation and use fees are generally calculated based on the original rent standard, starting from the date of contract termination to the actual date of vacating the premises. If the tenant still refuses to move out after the judgment takes effect, the landlord can apply for forced execution, and the court will organize the eviction and record the entire process.
Hengluo Law Firm advises that before taking any action, landlords should first consolidate the evidence into a complete timeline: the start and end months of the rent arrears, the reminder letters and replies, WeChat and SMS records, and photos of the current state of the property. You can first create a timeline table, corresponding the dates, events, and voucher numbers one by one. This will save time and effort whether you negotiate with the tenant yourself or entrust a lawyer to handle it. Once the chain of evidence is complete, it will be much smoother to either terminate the contract or recover the arrears. When the specific circumstances of each case vary greatly, you can refer to the relevant legal provisions for guidance.Property sale and purchase dispute agency servicesObtain a targeted assessment.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
At the contractual level, Article 721 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) stipulates that the lessee shall pay the rent according to the agreed term; Article 722 grants the lessor the right to rescind the contract if the rent is not received within a reasonable period after the reminder; Article 733 stipulates that after the termination of the lease relationship, the lessee shall return the leased property; if the lessee refuses to return it, the lessor may request the eviction and claim the occupancy fee. If there are provisions on the penalty for breach of contract or the late payment penalty in the contract, as long as it is not obviously excessively higher than the actual loss, it can usually be supported.
At the operational level, it is recommended to proceed in five steps: 1. First, verify the amount of unpaid rent and the starting date, and reconcile the accounts monthly to generate a detailed record. 2. Second, send a written reminder letter stating the amount of unpaid rent, the deadline for payment, and the consequences of late payment. Send the letter via EMS and retain the receipt. 3. Third, if the tenant still fails to pay by the deadline, send a notice of termination. 4. Fourth, if the tenant refuses to vacate the premises, file a lawsuit with the local court to request eviction and payment of unpaid rent and occupancy fees. 5. Fifth, if there is concern about the tenant delaying or transferring assets, apply for property preservation simultaneously with the lawsuit to pave the way for subsequent enforcement. During the litigation process, although rent will no longer be collected, occupancy fees will continue to accrue. Starting the process as early as possible is advantageous. If the tenant proposes to pay in installments, a written repayment agreement can be signed with clauses on resuming payments after delays, which not only gives the tenant an outlet but also preserves the right to seek recovery.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
Saving a few days by changing the lock may lead to a lawsuit for infringement. The more anxious the landlord is to reclaim the house, the more he needs to follow the procedures: leaving a record of the notice, delivering the notice, and applying for litigation preservation. Keeping good evidence for each step ensures that the case can stand up at any stage. Landlords with complete evidence often get a more satisfactory solution in the mediation stage, and most disputes don't even reach the judgment stage.
When encountering complex situations such as tenants going missing, leaving valuable items in the house, or the house being sublet repeatedly, do not handle them on your own. It is best to engage a lawyer as soon as possible to design eviction and claim settlement plans, so as to avoid turning from a creditor into a defendant. The ancillary expenses such as moving company fees and storage fees should also be included in the settlement list with the tenants, and keep all receipts. Especially for large quantities of goods or equipment in the house that are difficult to remove, improper disposal methods will result in exponentially increased liability for compensation.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What responsibilities does the landlord need to bear if he/she changes the locks and clears out the tenants' belongings without their consent?
They may bear triple responsibilities. At the civil level, tenants have the right to claim the return of their property, compensation for property losses, and losses during the period when they cannot use the house normally; at the administrative level, the act of changing locks and emptying others' occupied spaces without authorization may be fined or detained according to the "Public Security Administration Punishment Law of the People's Republic of China" (amended in 2012); if the circumstances are serious and the damage to property is significant, it may also cross the criminal threshold. It should be emphasized that tenants' arrears in rent only give rise to breach of contract liability and cannot be a justifiable reason for private enforcement. The correct procedure is to give a notice, terminate the contract, and sue, and then leave the eviction to the court for enforcement. Only in this way can landlords always be in the right.
Q2: What should a written reminder letter include when a tenant defaults on the rent?
The notice of default is a preliminary procedure for terminating the contract, and the absence of essential elements may result in the termination being invalid. It should specify five items: the specific address of the leased house and the date of signing the contract; the start and end months of the unpaid rent and the exact amount; a reasonable time limit for making up the payment, which is usually seven to fifteen days in practice; a clear intention to terminate the contract in accordance with the contract provisions and Article 722 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (effective January 1, 2021) if the payment is not made within the time limit; and the information of the receiving account. The notice should be signed by the landlord and indicate the date of issuance. It should be sent by EMS to the delivery address specified in the contract and the face sheet and receipt should be retained. At the same time, a copy should be sent via WeChat, forming a two-track record-keeping system.
Q3: What evidence materials are needed to sue for the recovery of unpaid rent?
It is recommended to organize the materials into three layers according to the relationship, breach of contract, and amount: - **Relationship layer**: The original lease contract, the parties' identity information, and proof of the establishment of the lease relationship, as well as agreements on payment and termination clauses; - **Breach of contract layer**: Rent payment records, demand letters and EMS receipts, WeChat message collection records, which prove the fact of rent arrears and that the obligation to give notice has been fulfilled; - **Amount layer**: Rent reconciliation details, deposit receipts, and utility bills, used to calculate the outstanding rent and the items to be offset. If claiming occupancy fees at the same time, proof of delivery of the termination notice must also be submitted. All materials should be numbered and bound into a booklet in chronological order. A well-organized evidence booklet with a clear timeline often prompts the other party to settle the case before trial and allows judges to verify the amounts more quickly.
Q4: What is the approximate cost of hiring a lawyer to recover the rent owed by tenants?
The costs are calculated in two parts. The court acceptance fee is calculated according to the "Measures for the Payment of Litigation Costs" (implemented on April 1, 2007) and is cumulative according to the amount of the litigation request. For amounts below 10,000 yuan, it is 50 yuan per case; for the excess part, it increases incrementally. After the judgment, it shall be borne by the losing party or shared according to the proportion of victory and defeat. The attorney's fee is calculated based on the amount of the unpaid rent, the completeness of the evidence, and whether it involves preservation and enforcement. It is charged by the hour, by the number of hours, or as a percentage of the subject matter, subject to the provisions of the agency contract, and there is no unified government pricing. It is recommended to calculate the recoverable amount, the estimated period, and various costs together before suing, so as to determine the scope of claims and litigation strategies, and to avoid the situation that the money recovered is not enough to cover the expenses.
Q5: What should you do first if a tenant consistently fails to pay the rent on time?
The first step is not to change the locks, but to reconcile accounts and leave records. Immediately check the start and end dates of the arrears and the detailed amounts, and export the bank or mobile payment transaction records; simultaneously file and back up the lease contracts, payment receipts, and WeChat and SMS records of previous collection efforts, and if necessary, take photos and videos of the current state of the property. Subsequently, within one week, send a written reminder letter, clearly stating the deadline for making up the payment and the consequences of terminating the contract in case of default. Throughout the process, do not take actions such as cutting off water and electricity or changing the locks and clearing out the property, to avoid pushing the defaulting party into the role of a victim. It is crucial not to act impulsively first and give up the initiative. After completing the above two tasks, consult a lawyer to evaluate the legal options, which can usually help reduce both time and costs while ensuring legal compliance.
The above answer is based on the judicial practice in Beijing. The adjudication standards in other provinces and cities may vary. For specific cases, please refer to the local rules and evidence situation.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, so as to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Legal services for the sale and purchase of real estate·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. In the event of a dispute, please consult a practicing lawyer in a timely manner.