[Direct answer]Forgetting to clock in does not necessarily mean absenteeism. Whether it is legal for the employer to terminate the labor contract on this basis mainly depends on three factors: whether the attendance system itself has gone through legal procedures and been publicly announced and notified to the workers; whether the fact of forgetting to clock in meets the serious disciplinary violation standard set by the system; and whether the worker can provide a reasonable explanation and evidence for the abnormal clocking in. If the system is not formulated through democratic procedures or not publicly announced, it is very unlikely to be accepted in arbitration; and the lack of clocking records cannot necessarily prove that the worker did not provide labor on that day. The worker can therefore claim to continue to perform the labor contract or request compensation for unlawful termination.
1. Problem background and typical scenarios
After fingerprint scanners, facial recognition, and WeCom clock-in systems became mainstream, forgetting to clock in has become the most common source of disputes. Employees might forget to clock in because their phones run out of battery, the subway signal is interrupted, the attendance machine malfunctions temporarily, or they are assigned to work at a client's site and forget to clock in the system. HR departments often directly mark such cases as absenteeism on the monthly attendance report. More commonly, the company's "Attendance Management Regulations" stipulate that failing to clock in is considered absenteeism, and three consecutive absences will be treated as a serious violation of discipline, with performance bonuses being cancelled. Employees often only learn about these provisions when they receive the notice.
Another situation is that forgetting to clock in is confused with not showing up for work. Employees may actually work on that day, but the clock-in records are not uploaded, and the unit still treats it as absenteeism; or those who work overtime on weekends may not be able to prove their presence because the access control records are only kept for one month. The consequences are often cumulative: first, a few days' salary is deducted, then the eligibility for performance awards is cancelled, and finally the labor contract is terminated on the grounds of serious disciplinary violations. Most employees only make oral defenses, without leaving system screenshots, appeal records, or traces of work output. After entering arbitration, they can only provide limited evidence to refute the allegations.
II. Key points of dispute
The first point of contention is whether the attendance system is binding on workers.Article 4 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012) stipulates that when formulating, amending, or deciding on rules and regulations that directly affect the vital interests of employees, the employer shall consult with the workers' representative conference or all employees, determine them through equal consultation with the trade union or employee representatives, and make them public or inform the employees. Attendance systems that are not formulated through democratic procedures or not made public or notified to employees are usually not used as the basis for handling disciplinary violations by arbitration institutions; provisions that evaluate a single failed record as equivalent to a whole day's absence will also be subject to review for their reasonableness.
The second point of contention is the determination of the facts and severity of the absenteeism.The employer's decision to terminate the employment contract constitutes an act unfavorable to the employee. The relevant facts shall be proven by the party claiming the legality of the termination: it is necessary to prove that the system is legal and has been notified to the employee, that the employee did not provide labor on that day, that the employee's behavior meets the termination conditions stipulated in the system, and that the trade union did not raise any objections after being notified in advance in accordance with Article 43 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012). The absence of a card record on the attendance sheet is just a formal record. If the employee explains that he was on a business trip, hospitalized, or participated in company training on that day, the determination result will be different.
The third point of contention is the choice of remedies and the relief measures after the contract is terminated.If the termination is determined to be illegal, the worker may request to continue performing the labor contract or claim compensation. According to Article 47 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012), the economic compensation shall be calculated based on the length of service; and according to Article 87 of the same law, the compensation shall be paid at twice the standard of economic compensation. There is another important point that cannot be ignored: According to Article 27 of the Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), the statute of limitations for applying for arbitration is one year, calculated from the date on which the rights are infringed.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
When handling such disputes, Hengluo Law Firm often starts not with argumentation, but with timeline reconstruction: making a list of every missing card date involved in the dispute, and checking the original attendance records, access control records, approval records for going out, emails, and messages in the work group on a daily basis, as well as the work results achieved on that day. Missing cards are often scattered across different systems, and the arbitration tribunal only recognizes evidence that can be verified in court. By the time this step is completed, many parties will find that the real disputes often only involve two or three days.
The second step is to review the text of the system itself. Hengluo Lawyers usually retrieve the formation time of the company's "Attendance Management System", the discussion records of employees, the photos of public announcement, or the employee's signature sheets, to check whether the system has taken effect and been known to the workers on the date of the dispute. There are two common situations: the system is signed retroactively after the dispute occurs, and the employee's signature page is blank; or the system only vaguely states that "those who fail to clock in will be treated as absenteeism", but does not specify the number of days of absenteeism and the conditions for termination. The former weakens the company's procedural basis, and the latter lacks clear standards for termination conditions. Therefore, it is more valuable to focus on the effectiveness of the system rather than on a single case of clock-out failure.
The third step is to distinguish between factual disputes and procedural disputes. If the company terminates the employment contract due to serious violations of disciplinary rules without notifying the trade union in accordance with Article 43 of the Labor Contract Law, or if the system is not formulated through democratic procedures, the focus of the dispute will shift from the factual level to the procedural level. Hengluo Lawyers also remind that it is not advisable to place all bets on the authenticity of a single clock-in record in arbitration. Once the company deletes or modifies the attendance data, the workers will have no way to verify it. Therefore, it is more crucial to fix the original data at the early stage than to repeatedly argue about it afterwards.
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
In practice, the process can be divided into four steps. Firstly, immediately submit a written request for a new work card to the company's HR department and your direct supervisor, and keep a record of the submission and the response. There's no need to just verbally explain it. Secondly, continue to work normally until the company makes a decision on the matter, and keep records of the daily work handover and task completion. At the same time, download the attendance system export files, access control records, and reimbursement details to your personal device, forming a package of materials that can be submitted. Thirdly, after receiving the termination notice, file the notice document, the delivery method, and the termination reason, and check whether the version of the company's regulations cited in the notice is consistent with the publicly announced version. Fourthly, complete a risk assessment before signing any documents, especially those that mention absenteeism or voluntary resignation.
The main provisions that need to be cited include: Article 39(2) of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012), which stipulates that a labor contract may be terminated if the employee seriously violates the employer's rules and regulations; Article 43, which stipulates that the trade union must be notified in advance; Article 47, which stipulates the calculation of the standard for economic compensation; and Article 87, which stipulates the compensation for unlawful termination; Article 50 of the Labor Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 1995), which stipulates that the employer shall not deduct or unjustifiably delay the payment of the worker's wages; Article 6 of the Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), which stipulates the burden of proof and Article 27, which stipulates a one-year statute of limitations for arbitration. The application of these provisions to specific cases shall be subject to the currently effective laws, regulations, and judicial rulings.
For more details on the review of the attendance system, the fixing of evidence, and the dismissal procedures, please refer to the following document.Labor arbitration and work-related injury compensation servicesUnderstand the application process.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Reminder
There are three points that need to be noted. Firstly, do not sign and confirm the fact of absenteeism on the termination notice or conversation records, as signing and confirming it will often be used as evidence of your own admission. If it is necessary to sign and receive the document, you can only write your name and the date of receipt, and indicate that you have objections to the content. Secondly, the records of social insurance, housing provident fund, and personal income tax payments can prove the labor relationship and wage standards, but they do not directly prove the absence of a card on the day of absence. The focus should still be on the original attendance data and the traces of work on that day. Thirdly, if you find that the company has modified or deleted the attendance data before or after the dispute, you should immediately fix the abnormal state and file a complaint with the labor administrative department, and at the same time apply for retrieving the evidence that has been controlled.
The awareness of statute of limitations is equally important. The statute of limitations for arbitration begins to run from the date the dispute arises. Many employees wait and see for several months after receiving the termination notice, only to find that the time limit for claiming compensation has almost expired when they finally want to assert their rights. It is prudent to conduct an assessment as soon as the termination notice arrives: which dates are supported by sufficient evidence, what procedural flaws exist in the company's system, and which claim is more realistic—compensation or continued performance. If there is indeed room for negotiation, employees can express their demands in writing while reserving the possibility of applying for arbitration at any time.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Is it legal for the company to say that forgetting to clock in counts as absenteeism?
Of course, it's legal. Generally, there are three levels of review in arbitration. The first level is the effectiveness of the system. According to Article 4 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012), if the attendance system has not been discussed by the workers' representative conference or all workers, or determined through equal consultation with the trade union, or notified to the workers through public announcement, it cannot be used as a basis for disciplinary action. The second level is the content of the system. Equating a failed clock-in once with a whole day of absenteeism, the reasonableness of the clause will also be reviewed. The third level is the facts and consequences. The company needs to prove that the worker did not provide labor on that day, met the conditions for termination, and fulfilled the procedure of notifying the trade union. If any of these three levels is not satisfied, the legality of the termination will be questioned.
Q2: How to collect evidence on the day of the card being missing during the arbitration process?
It is recommended to make an evidence comparison table and fill in each missing card date one by one. The first category is the original attendance and access control records, including the exported data from time clocks, WeCom or DingTalk, floor access control and visitor records, which are usually stored by the company's system. According to Article 6 of the "Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law" (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), if the employer fails to provide these records, the employee may apply to the employer to provide them and bear the adverse consequences if the employer fails to do so. The second category is the daily work traces, including the time of sending emails, the version of documents, and the submission records in the task system. The third category is external corroboration, such as travel approval, reimbursement forms, and vehicle usage records. The fourth category is communication records during the same period, such as messages in the work group and the supervisor's shift arrangement. It is necessary to keep the complete context and original carriers of the screenshots.
Q3: How is the compensation calculated when an employer terminates an employee for absenteeism?
First, distinguish the object of the claim. If you choose to require the employer to continue to perform the labor contract, you can request to return to your original position and be paid the wages during the termination period; if you choose not to require the employer to continue to perform the contract, you shall, in accordance with Article 87 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012), pay compensation at twice the standard of economic compensation. The economic compensation shall be calculated according to Article 47 of the same law, with one month's salary paid for each year of service, one year's salary paid for a period of more than six months but less than one year, and half a month's salary paid for a period of less than six months; if the monthly salary is more than three times the average monthly salary of local workers in the previous year, the compensation shall be calculated at three times the amount and be capped according to the length of service. The arbitration statute of limitations is one year, so it is advisable to assert your rights as soon as possible.
Q4: How long does it take from filing a labor arbitration application to receiving the arbitration award?
Labor dispute arbitration is free of charge, in accordance with Article 47 of the "Mediation and Arbitration Law for Labor Disputes" (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008). The arbitration hearing period is governed by Article 43, which stipulates that the hearing shall be completed within 45 days from the date of accepting the arbitration application. If the case is complex and requires an extension, it may be extended by 15 days upon approval; the hearing period before the delivery of the arbitration award shall not be included in the time limit. Therefore, from the submission of the application to the receipt of the arbitration award, it usually takes two to three months. Cases with major factual disputes or where the company delays in submitting evidence will obviously take longer. If the parties are dissatisfied with the arbitration result, they can file a lawsuit with the people's court within 15 days from the date of receiving the arbitration award. The first-instance ordinary procedure generally takes six months to conclude.
Q5: If I fail to negotiate with the company about replacing the card, what else can I do?
There are three options to proceed. First, continue to use internal channels but formalize the request in writing, requiring the company to confirm in writing that the card loss was due to equipment or system issues, and keep a record of the submission and the response. Second, file a complaint with the labor and social security supervision authority against illegal acts such as failing to keep records of wage payments in accordance with the law and arbitrarily deducting wages beyond the regulations. The complaint and arbitration can proceed concurrently, and the statute of limitations will not be interrupted by the complaint. Third, apply for arbitration to the labor and personnel dispute arbitration committee with jurisdiction, requesting confirmation of the unlawful termination and asserting rights. After submitting the application, fix the evidence as soon as possible to avoid the attendance data being overwritten over time.
The above questions and answers are mainly based on the judicial practice in the Beijing area. There may be differences in the adjudication guidelines in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the evidence materials, to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Labor arbitration legal services·Beijing Hengluo Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.