[Direct answer]Whether the written evidence provided by colleagues can prove overtime work depends not on the identity of the witnesses, but on the reliability of the testimony, whether it is based on personal observation, and whether it is corroborated by other evidence. The claim for overtime pay begins with the worker's obligation to provide evidence of the overtime facts. If materials such as punch-in records, access control records, and office system logs are controlled and managed by the employer and not provided, the employer shall bear the adverse consequences. Therefore, a handwritten certificate from a colleague usually only serves to reinforce the evidence. When it is corroborated by objective materials such as email sending records and timestamps of work results, its probative value will be significantly enhanced.
I. Problem Background and Typical Scenarios
During the project's rush to meet deadlines, employees worked overtime for several consecutive weeks after work and were also assigned to work on-site at clients' locations on weekends. However, no records were found in the attendance machine, which is quite common in overtime pay disputes. The reason for this is often not that there was no overtime, but that the overtime approval forms were not properly processed: the company's overtime application portal was just a formality, or the supervisor arranged overtime verbally without signing the forms afterwards. Employees were worried that admitting unapproved overtime would be considered unauthorized overtime, so they instead asked colleagues in the same group to write a certificate, attaching their signatures and dates.
Another type of scenario occurs after an employee leaves the company. Six months after leaving the company, the employee realizes that the overtime pay has never been settled. When they want to claim it, their colleagues have already changed jobs and are unwilling to cooperate or cannot be contacted; the clock-in data can only be queried in the system for the last three months; the old computer has long been replaced by a new one, and the correspondence emails in the personal email inbox have not been fully preserved. At this point, the focus of the dispute shifts from whether overtime actually occurred to whether it is possible to reconstruct the working hours with other indirect evidence.
II. Key points of contention
The first point of contention is the allocation of the burden of proof for the fact of overtime work.Article 42 of the "Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Legal Issues Applicable to the Trials of Labor Dispute Cases (I)" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 26, implemented on January 1, 2021) stipulates that where a worker claims overtime pay, the worker shall bear the burden of proof for the existence of overtime work; however, if the worker has evidence to prove that the employer holds evidence of the existence of overtime work and the employer fails to provide such evidence, the employer shall bear the adverse consequences. Article 6 of the "Law on Mediation and Arbitration of Labor Disputes" (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008) makes the same arrangement. For materials generated by the company's system, such as original attendance records, access control data, and shift schedules, the burden of proof mainly lies with the company.
The second point of contention is the probative force of the witness's testimony.According to Article 90 of the "Several Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Proceedings" (amended on September 25, 2019 and implemented on October 14, 2019), the statements of witnesses who have a vested interest in one of the parties or their agents cannot be used alone as the basis for determining the facts of the case. When reviewing, four aspects are usually considered: whether the witness personally witnessed the overtime work scene, whether there is a common interest relationship with the parties, whether the witness's statements were written uniformly after the dispute arose or naturally formed, and whether they are willing to appear in court for questioning. There is usually a difference in the probative force between written testimonies and the witness's statements in court.
The third point of contention is the criteria for determining overtime work.Overtime work generally requires that the employer arranges it or the worker knows about and agrees to it, and the worker actually provides labor. It's hard to get recognition for simply extending working hours without corresponding work output or periods that are not substantially different from normal working hours. However, the email sending records, access control records, and duty roster records formed during overtime work can be pieced together to form a complete time chain. Article 31 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012) also clearly stipulates that employers shall strictly control overtime work and shall not force workers to work overtime in disguise.
III. Professional analysis by Hengluo Law Firm
The first step of Hengluo Law Firm in handling the overtime pay dispute is to prepare an overtime evidence comparison table: break down each claimed period one by one and list five types of available materials for each period, including overtime approval forms and screenshots of the process system, original records of access control and attendance, login and email sending records of the office system, project deliverables such as version submissions, and reimbursement and car usage records. Overtime pay is accumulated by the hour or even by the minute. If there is a lack of evidence for a period, there will be a lack of a claim. It is more meaningful to first calculate the total amount that can be claimed.
The second step is to evaluate the source and acquisition method of each piece of evidence. If the proof written by colleagues is organized and completed by the worker himself after the event, the arbitration tribunal will usually require an explanation of the formation process. If necessary, the witness will be notified to testify in court. If the witness changes his statement in court, it will lead to an unfavorable evaluation; conversely, process-based materials that naturally form through daily communication such as work groups and emails are more likely to be recognized as authentic. Hengluo Lawyers also remind the parties to retain the original carriers and complete contexts. Cropped single screenshots are likely to lose their probative value.
The third step is to prepare alternative approaches for situations where witnesses are unwilling to cooperate: applying to the arbitration tribunal to retrieve the original attendance and access control data, or using third-party materials such as social insurance enrollment, personal income tax declaration, and housing provident fund payment records to verify the intensity of work. It should be noted that once the overtime period is denied, it often leads to the determination of work-related injuries related to working hours and accidents in the workplace, which will be reviewed together according to the standards set forth in Article 14, Paragraph 1 of the "Regulations on Work-Related Injury Insurance" (State Council Decree No. 586, amended on December 20, 2010).
IV. Practical suggestions and legal basis
It is recommended to follow four steps. Firstly, while you still have system permissions, export the original materials that you are legally entitled to obtain, including attendance system export files, corporate email communications, access control records, and reimbursement details. Be sure to retain the original file attributes and time information. Secondly, classify the disputed periods into three categories: those with sufficient evidence, those with partial evidence, and those with no evidence at all. For the periods that cannot be substantiated, adjust the claimed amount in a timely manner. Thirdly, submit a written request to the company to confirm the overtime facts and pay overtime wages, and retain the delivery receipt. Fourthly, understand the arbitration statute of limitations and procedural deadlines, and decide whether to apply for arbitration as needed to avoid waiting until the window for dispute resolution narrows.
The main norms that need to be cited include: Article 36 of the Labor Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 1995), which stipulates the working hour system; Article 44, which stipulates that overtime work, work on rest days, and work on statutory holidays shall be paid at a rate of not less than 150%, 200%, and 300% of the employee's wage respectively; Article 31 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China (amended on December 28, 2012), which stipulates strict control of overtime work; Article 6 of the Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), which stipulates the burden of proof and Article 43 on the time limit for arbitration; Article 90 of the Supreme People's Court's Several Provisions on Evidence in Civil Proceedings (amended on September 25, 2019 and implemented on October 14, 2019). In individual cases, the applicable laws and regulations and judicial rulings that are currently in force shall prevail.
For more details on the organization of overtime evidence, the appearance of witnesses in court, and arbitration procedures, please refer to the following document.Guidelines for Collecting Evidence of Overtime Work in Labor ArbitrationUnderstand the application process.
5. Henglu Law Firm's Advice
There are three risks that are often underestimated in practice. Firstly, colleague testimonies can only supplement, but not replace objective evidence. Do not rely entirely on one person's testimony, and more importantly, do not fabricate materials or induce witnesses to make false statements in order to establish the credibility of the testimony. Secondly, the amount of overtime pay is prone to being overestimated. Hengluo Law Firm usually calculates the statutory multiples separately for working days, rest days, and statutory holidays before filing a lawsuit, and deducts the periods for which compensatory rest has been arranged, to avoid the claim being rejected in part and the remaining part losing its basis as well. Thirdly, the communication methods during employment and after resignation are different. During employment, it is advisable to first use internal consultation channels.
There's another point that's often overlooked: the connection between the witness's identity and the outcome of the case. If the colleague is also a claimant for overtime pay, it may be considered to merge the trials to reduce the difficulty of duplicated proof. Conversely, if the witness has a conflict of interest with the company, or if their statements clearly contradict objective materials such as access control records and emails, relying on this testimony may actually expose the problems with the entire claim. Therefore, Hengluo Lawyers usually conduct a cross-check before submitting materials and then decide on the weight of the witness's materials.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: How effective is the overtime certificate written by a colleague in an arbitration process?
It can play a reinforcing role, but it usually cannot be used as the sole basis for making a decision. According to Article 90 of the "Several Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Proceedings" (amended on September 25, 2019 and implemented on October 14, 2019), the statements of witnesses who have a vested interest in one party cannot be used alone as the basis for determining the facts of the case. The arbitral tribunal usually pays attention to three points: whether the witness personally witnessed the overtime scene, whether the testimony was naturally formed or unified and supplemented afterwards, and whether the witness is willing to appear in court for questioning. When the testimony in court is corroborated by objective materials such as email records and access control records, the probative force of the entire set of evidence will be significantly enhanced; once there are contradictions, the entire set of claims will be affected.
Q2: How to prove that overtime work actually occurred when there are no approval records?
The approval records are just one link in the chain of evidence. If they are missing, they can be supplemented with other materials. Three approaches are more effective: First, work traces, including the time of email sending, system submission logs, and document version timestamps; Second, attendance and scheduling materials, including access control clocking, duty rosters, and shuttle bus ride records; Third, external corroboration, including reimbursement forms, car rental orders, and client on-site sign-in records. Additionally, according to Article 6 of the Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), relevant evidence is in the possession and management of the employer, who should provide it. If the claimant has evidence to prove that the materials are held by the company, they can apply to the arbitration tribunal to retrieve them.
Q3: What are the standards and amounts of overtime pay generally?
According to Article 44 of the Labor Law of the People's Republic of China (implemented on January 1, 1995), the payment for extended working hours shall not be less than 150% of the wage; the payment for working on rest days without being able to arrange compensatory rest shall not be less than 200% of the wage; and the payment for working on statutory holidays shall not be less than 300% of the wage. The calculation base is generally based on the normal working hours wage agreed in the labor contract. If the base is lower than the local minimum wage standard or the parties have another agreement, the actual agreement shall prevail. When calculating, the statutory holidays should be listed separately to avoid the overall reduction caused by the mixed calculation of extended working hours on working days and overtime on rest days.
Q4: What materials are needed to claim overtime pay?
It is recommended to prepare a list based on four categories of materials. The first category is labor relationship materials, including labor contracts, pay slips, social insurance and personal income tax records, which are used to confirm the subject and the wage base. The second category is overtime arrangement materials, including overtime approval forms, shift schedules, and overtime notifications issued by supervisors or HR departments. The third category is actual work materials, including email correspondence, system submission records, project deliverables, and access control attendance exports. The fourth category is third-party materials that can corroborate each other, such as expense reports and car rental orders. In addition to the list, a comparison table arranged by time periods should also be prepared, so that the arbitration request can be specific to specific dates and specific multiples.
Q5: How long does it usually take to arbitrate such disputes?
According to Article 43 of the "Mediation and Arbitration Law for Labor Disputes" (adopted on December 29, 2007 and implemented on May 1, 2008), the arbitration tribunal shall conclude the trial within 45 days from the date of accepting the arbitration application. If the case is complex and requires an extension, it may be extended by 15 days upon approval; arbitration does not charge fees according to Article 47. The actual period is usually three to six months, because the evidence of overtime periods needs to be checked item by item, and the retrieval of company system data requires written applications and service procedures. For witnesses, it is necessary to arrange for them to appear in court and cross-examine. If dissatisfied with the arbitration result, one may file a lawsuit with the people's court within 15 days from the date of receiving the arbitration award. The first-instance ordinary procedure generally concludes within six months.
The above Q&A is mainly based on the judicial practice in Beijing. There may be differences in the interpretation of the law in different regions. It is recommended to consult a professional lawyer based on the specific circumstances of the case.
If you are facing similar problems, it is recommended that you consult a professional lawyer as soon as possible with the relevant evidence materials to avoid missing the statutory time limit. →Labor arbitration legal services·Beijing Henglu Law Firm
Disclaimer: This article is compiled based on the current effective laws and regulations and open adjudication rules, and is for general reference only. It does not constitute a formal legal opinion on specific cases. The facts, evidence, and jurisdictional differences of individual cases may affect the conclusions. If you encounter disputes, please consult a practicing lawyer in time.